pfSense at 20
-
Hi @JeGr, I might be misunderstanding but the way I understood it is that the Nexus UI (for the lack of a better description) is going to replace the PHP UI. And to be able to do good bug reports or fix issues on your own it is helpful to have that code opensource. We did that a lot with system patches in the past (granted, this is easier for PHP than a go program) and would love to be able to do so in the future.
If I misinterpreted everything and a PHP UI is going to stay the default UI, there is no issue.
-
Happy Birthday pfsense and Netgate
...hope, for many more years and a growing community, Thanks also to the whole support Team here! -
If I misinterpreted everything and a PHP UI is going to stay the default UI, there is no issue.
It will be there for now but as I read on Reddit it's the plan to remove it after feature parity is there. The guess was ~1y.
So you took Nexus as the GUI - OK that was the problem I was confused about, as Nexus is way more than the GUI especially the multi instance management component and that wasn't OSS ever, so that's what I didn't understand.
Yeah your question goes hand-in-hand with mine then about the new GUI (or better the API layer and the corresponding GUI elements) and if there will be a possibility to develop against that, create packages like others in the past that needed GUI and file components etc.
@stephenw10 Is there some more info about that coming? If Netgate pushes 26.10 to GitHub - great! - but how or will we still be able to create additional packages? Will the API/GUI components (not the MIM parts, that's clear with licenses and stuff) be open to new additions or is Netgate the only one that then can add new addon packages to the system? As we have a few contacts that would be happy to add new packages to pfSense like Netbird and stuff, that would be great to know :)
Cheers
-
There will be more info coming on many of the things discussed here. Nothing I can add right now though.
We are reading the comments here and they are being discussed internally.
-
@DBMandrake When I first started reading the announcement, I was wondering what the catch is because that's what I've come to expect. Then I saw the artificial friction they deliberately added and laughed.
-
took Nexus as the GUI
(I'm just restating for all, here, not aimed at you)
Netgate has sort of re-used the name, and at least one place on Reddit I've seen someone assume/argue a license was required to use the new GUI.
https://docs.netgate.com/pfsense/en/latest/nexus/
"Netgate Nexus is a GUI configuration interface and API for pfSense Plus software with multi-instance management (MIM) capabilities."
and
"The Netgate Nexus GUI can manage the host on which it is running even without using it for multi-instance management."
So it is sort of an umbrella name for a new GUI, an API, and MIM. MIM requires a license. Everything else does not. Or maybe "Nexus GUI" and "Nexus controller/API" and "Nexus MIM" are/should be separate names.
Nexus is its own package in pfSense, however it has been a required package for a bit now, at least in Plus.
-
@SteveITS Well nexus also seems to be a new container for feature/extension packages. Already it also brings CoreDNS, Threatgate, mDNS and Snort. Not as separate packages, but integrated in Nexus.
To me that looks like the "supported 3. party packages" system is going away.
By "killing" off the old UI, they slowly abandon the option of using the old package system, and eventually will be Netgate "only" unless you go CLI and add an unsupported package outside of the Nexus ecosystem... -
@keyser That's what I mean, it (IIRC) started out as the licensed MIM management, and it is now more of a "new stuff" or "next generation" label.
I'm not saying it's bad, necessarily, just potentially confusing.
For sake of discussion, if the Nexus/Go code will not be open source, and the PHP goes away in a year, what is left? The blog post says, "...publishing the updated PHP and the FreeBSD source for 26.10 to GitHub."
-
what is left?
pfSense
running on top of a Linux kernel. -
pfSense
running on top of a Linux kernel.
-
Just parroting.

-
-
I've been a pfSense user since ~2005. It is a great product that has never failed to serve my needs over the years. The forum content has been excellent, such that I've never had a need to contact support for anything not directly related to their Netgate hardware.
The upcoming change that takes away online upgrades concerns me. In addition to my local pfSense firewall, I manage five remote pfSense firewalls through ipSec tunnels for my family and friends. All but one are on third party hardware.
While I am certainly willing to support pfSense financially, paying for five $129 subscriptions just for the convenience of online upgrades is completely out of the question. If I were supporting businesses, this would not be an issue.
I hope Netgate can find a way to offer online upgrades at a reduced price. How about a 5 pack?
-
*FreeBSD, yeah.
-
i could not help myself.....
-
I used Pfsense in the same time frame as you and later moved to Sophos UTM as the ability to do content blocking was much like Pfblocker is today and was a key component of the Sophos GUI. When Sophos decided to stop production of UTM 9 series I again looked at Pfsense which had grown to a considerably more mature product. The decision to move back to Pfsense was made and I have not looked back. I agree forum content has been excellant, the number of people who were ready to provide techincal experience and knowledge when asked is outstanding. Reviewing information from the original I believe patches are included provided you are on the current version: "Every pfSense install gets security fixes at no cost, whether it runs on our hardware or yours, and whether or not you ever pay us anything." Take a look at the original post beginning at "Netgate keeps you secure, for free" it addresses patches and should provide additional clairity.
-
@scottjh1 Yes, I did indeed read that security patches will be included w/o a subscription.
However, what isn't stated is how many major releases back will security issues be backported.
If they support just two major releases (seems to be what they do now) and rarely push out new releases, then occasional release upgrades are less of an issue. If releases come more often (now that there is only one branch to maintain?), then that forces more manual labor on those w/o a subscription to keep within the support window. Time will tell.
I really just wish they would give a more affordable option for home users with multiple systems. A multi-pack bundle would be nice.
-
There is far more to the big picture then what is seen on the surface. Considering the the amount of coding required to consistantly maintain two current releases is considerable overhead. Just because two products exist for downloading does not mean code changes are not being considered or applied. Engineers and programmers have a heavy weight on them in reviewing, editing, and correcting code which is a huge ongoing responsibility. Patching in addition new features adds additional loading. There is more to the story particularly when you weigh the needs of many customers both paying and non paying. Necessity forces certain decisions to be made with might not make everyone happy. We see the user side of what goes on which does not give a snapshot of the internal weight in making decisions to keep Pfsense the excellant tool that it is.
-
I was going to extend my plus license, I only purchase TAC-Lite, but will now wait until the dust settles.
One question re 26.10 release, there is reference to API integration, so does that mean things like Crowdsec can be interface with the firewall etc.
-
What a mess. First you split pfSense into Plus and CE, and now you’re merging them again?! I just paid for a Plus subscription, and now the features I paid to access will be free. If I don’t need support or fleet management, am I effectively paying just to upgrade to new versions without reinstalling? Really?!
As I suggested a while ago, I’d happily make a donation to support development. But making users choose between paying and reinstalling feels like unnecessary friction, not a compelling reason to subscribe.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register LoginPrivacy Policy · Cookie Policy