PfBlockerNG
-
Until this bug is fixed, debugging similar issues is a pure waste of time.
-
Hi ConfuesedUser,
If you look at your pfSense Firewall log do you have IGMP alerts (If so, create a Firewall rule to drop those packets until the Devs fix that issue)? If you filter port 25 in the Firewall log do they show ok?
I can't reproduce this error on my boxes. Maybe try to clear the Firewall log and start with a Fresh Log and see if that fixes it? Report back how it goes. Can you filter other Settings in the Alerts Page? or is this issue limited to the "Dest Port" Filter field?
-
If you look at your pfSense Firewall log do you have IGMP alerts (If so, create a Firewall rule to drop those packets until the Devs fix that issue)?
This sadly seems impossible. Best you can do is hiding them from the GUI by reverting the patch that made them show. But they will still get logged and screw things like this.
-
Hello all,
i sorted all to work fine except pflocker. Can someone please see this printscreens and tell me what caused this? Seems theres no alerts for me at all. Nothing.
Many thnx.
-
Hi ConfuesedUser,
If you look at your pfSense Firewall log do you have IGMP alerts (If so, create a Firewall rule to drop those packets until the Devs fix that issue)? If you filter port 25 in the Firewall log do they show ok?
I can't reproduce this error on my boxes. Maybe try to clear the Firewall log and start with a Fresh Log and see if that fixes it? Report back how it goes. Can you filter other Settings in the Alerts Page? or is this issue limited to the "Dest Port" Filter field?
Hi BBCan177,
To answer your questions:
-
There are no IGMP alerts in the logs
-
In the firewall logs all shows up correctly / as expected when filtering for dest. port 25
-
oh dear, I was reading end executing your questions in order, so I cleared the firewall logs now which makes it pointless to filter for other settings now in the alerts
I will let the logs fill a bit and I will test the filters again tomorrow.
Btw, my log file size limit is at 20MB. Could the big size be causing issues?Many thanks for your help!
One more question:
To be able to see the country for firewall logs is a great feature. Would it be possible to add a check box to allow querying all rules in the alerts tab? Currently it is hard-coded to filter for "pfB_".
I think it would be pretty cool to be able to see all logs listed with the country. -
-
I have a couple questions regarding my setup of pfBlockerNG
I setup pfBlockerNG to block inbound connections from nearly all countries and then set up some IPv4 lists (Emerging Threats, iBlocklist, etc.) in match inbound mode to monitor. I have the same/similar IPv4 lists setup to match and log outbound connections (preceded with OB in the name)
I checked after 24 hours and had approximately 100 matches on the IPv4 lists. I then switched them to Deny inbound. After another 24 hours I checked and I have very few blocks on the IPv4 lists. I do have a lot of blocks on the country lists. Is it possible that there is overlap between the country blocks and IPv4 list blocks and so the block statistics are only counting a block per the country blocking and not the list?
Also, the number of blocked connections I'm seeing on the pfBlockerNG widget don't match what is showing up in the alerts. I have the country blocking set to not log, but all others are set to log. Here is what I am seeing on the widget, and below that is what I am seeing on the pfBlockerNG alerts.
Shouldn't I be seeing 8 blocked connections in the alert and 15 matched connections?
-
Hello ha11oga11o,
There is an issue as you have all "-" in the Widget Packet Counts.
Please reset all files with the following steps from the General Tab:
- Uncheck "Keep Settings"
- Disable "pfBlockerNG"
- Click "Save"
After it completes, reverse the steps above. Then run a "Force Update" The widget Packet Counts should start with "0's".
NOTE - Please don't select Countries in the 'TOP' alias, and then select the same Countries in the other Continent Tabs.
-
I will let the logs fill a bit and I will test the filters again tomorrow.
Btw, my log file size limit is at 20MB. Could the big size be causing issues?I don't think so, but please let me know how it went after Resetting the Logs?
To be able to see the country for firewall logs is a great feature.
I could look at that. It will add some overhead but I could make it into an 'option'.
-
I don't think so, but please let me know how it went after Resetting the Logs?
Thanks, will do so tomorrow.
To be able to see the country for firewall logs is a great feature.
I could look at that. It will add some overhead but I could make it into an 'option'.
I just gave it a quick try (without the check boxes, simply hard coded since my php knowledge is pretty much non-existent) and changed the following:
Old:
$data = exec ("/sbin/pfctl -vv -sr | grep 'pfB_'", $results);New:
$data = exec ("/sbin/pfctl -vv -sr", $results);Old:
if (preg_match("/USER_RULE: (\w+)/",$result,$desc))New:
if (preg_match("/USER_RULE: (.*)\"/",$result,$desc))It would be very nice to be able to flip them both by toggling one check box.
Also it would be good if this one could be toggled as well:
//Remove any Duplicate IPs $pfb_local = array_unique($pfb_local);Simple reason: This allows me to see for incoming mails if the same address tried multiple times and has been blocked by the spam filter on the mail server. If that happens (and it does) for some countries again and again which I don't do business with anyway I'd add them to the country block list.
Anyway, one more thing I completely forgot: pfBlockerNG is absolutely great!!!
-
Hi jeffh,
I would read this thread for my comments on 'Blocking the world, and allow a few Countries" and reverse that approach to Permit a select few Countries instead. pfSense is a stateful Firewall by design and is already Implicitly blocking on the Inbound.
If you want to protect some open ports, you should look at creating an Alias rule to protect the individual Inbound Port(s). Otherwise, Blocking on the Inbound with no open ports is inspecting packets that are already going to be dropped by the Implicit Deny Rule.
The Alerts Tab reads the Firewall Log to get its data. The Firewall logs only hold a certain amount of data (Can be configured in the Firewall Settings). The Firewall log is also cleared on a regular basis and thus older alerts will disappear.
The Widget Packet Counts are read from pfSense 'pfctl'. Those stats are cleared if you edit/save and Rules/Nat etc and a 'Filter_reload' occurs. So the counts will increase forever if you do not make any config changes. But as per above, the Firewall log is cleared and this is why these alerts are not being displayed in the Alerts Tab.
-
I just gave it a quick try (without the check boxes, simply hard coded since my php knowledge is pretty much non-existent) and changed the following
Thanks. I will take a look and see if I can incorporate that.
Also it would be good if this one could be toggled as well:
This is the code that skips 'Repeated Alerts' You can comment out the "continue" line to skip that process.
409 // Skip Repeated Alerts 410 if (($pfbalert[3] . $pfbalert[8] . $pfbalert[10]) == $previous_dstip || ($pfbalert[3] . $pfbalert[7] . $pfbalert[9]) == $previous_srcip) 411 continue;Anyway, one more thing I completely forgot: pfBlockerNG is absolutely great!!!
Thanks! :)
-
Hi jeffh,
I would read this thread for my comments on 'Blocking the world, and allow a few Countries" and reverse that approach to Permit a select few Countries instead. pfSense is a stateful Firewall by design and is already Implicitly blocking on the Inbound.
If you want to protect some open ports, you should look at creating an Alias rule to protect the individual Inbound Port(s). Otherwise, Blocking on the Inbound with no open ports is inspecting packets that are already going to be dropped by the Implicit Deny Rule.
Thanks BBcan177, I'll read through this thread, but that definitely makes sense. Not sure why I didn't think of that approach from the get go.
-
Hello ha11oga11o,
There is an issue as you have all "-" in the Widget Packet Counts.
Please reset all files with the following steps from the General Tab:
- Uncheck "Keep Settings"
- Disable "pfBlockerNG"
- Click "Save"
After it completes, reverse the steps above. Then run a "Force Update" The widget Packet Counts should start with "0's".
NOTE - Please don't select Countries in the 'TOP' alias, and then select the same Countries in the other Continent Tabs.
Hello BBcan177,
Many thnx that works fine for widget.
But still cant see anything at Alerts tab :/
Cheers :)
-
Many thnx that works fine for widget.
But still cant see anything at Alerts tab :/
Find an IP that is in any of the pfBNG Alias Tables and ping it from a Device behind pfSense… That should trigger an Alert. Also make sure that logging in enabled in the Aliases.
This command will give you some more stats from the Shell:
pfctl -vvsTables -
Thanks BBcan177, I'll read through this thread, but that definitely makes sense. Not sure why I didn't think of that approach from the get go.
If you don't have open ports and you only want to have your devices talk to certain Countries, then you can create "Permit Outbound" rules. Keep in mind that their is a ton of Malicious IPs in NA Countries also.. Recommend using decent Blocklists to block known Malicious IPs.
-
Many thnx that works fine for widget.
But still cant see anything at Alerts tab :/
Find an IP that is in any of the pfBNG Alias Tables and ping it from a Device behind pfSense… That should trigger an Alert. Also make sure that logging in enabled in the Aliases.
This command will give you some more stats from the Shell:
pfctl -vvsTablesSomething is really wrong with mine pfblockerNG. Again i have "-" on widget and this is shell output.
http://pastebin.com/Gze9xyAd
-
ha11oga11o,
Does the pfblockerng.log show any errors/Issues?
Disable pfBlockerNG again as indicated in my post above. Then Reboot.
After the reboot, enable a few Aliases at a time and run a "Force Update" to see if those Aliases show "0's" in the widget… Rinse and Repeat with a few more Aliases. Then you can determine which alias is causing the issue. -
Hi ConfusedUser,
Those changes that you made to capture the Country in the List column are not correct unfortunately. But I think you need to look at the "CC" column which will already tell you which Country it is anyways. :)
-
ha11oga11o,
Does the pfblockerng.log show any errors/Issues?
Disable pfBlockerNG again as indicated in my post above. Then Reboot.
After the reboot, enable a few Aliases at a time and run a "Force Update" to see if those Aliases show "0's" in the widget… Rinse and Repeat with a few more Aliases. Then you can determine which alias is causing the issue.No errors at all,
i rebooted, enabled couple of lists all is working fine. Now i just need to enable one by one and update. I think that should solve problem to find which list is broken, or maybe i have way to much IPs on lists that they cannot fit to tables.
Many thnx for pinpointing me to right direction., Now its up-to me just to do my stuff and find broken one.
Cheers :)
-
Hi ConfusedUser,
Those changes that you made to capture the Country in the List column are not correct unfortunately. But I think you need to look at the "CC" column which will already tell you which Country it is anyways. :)
Those changes were not made to change anything in the List or CC column.
$data = exec ("/sbin/pfctl -vv -sr", $results);
This is to prevent filtering by 'pfB_'if (preg_match("/USER_RULE: (.*)"/",$result,$desc))
And this is to display the rule name correctlySo on my side it's working absolutely fine.
