Firewall — Rules, moving rule order on LAN bug

w0w

When you try change LAN rules order by drag and drop them over in list, after hitting "save" button all WAN rules appearing on LAN tab and WAN tab consists from two standard blocking rules RFC 1918 networks and Block private networks.

doktornotor

Oooops, Scheisse…

maverick_slo

Seriously?
That is really nasty bug if its true…

doktornotor

The only 2.4 box I could test with ATM is a remote one. Obviously, not keen on doing that. ::) ;D

w0w

Actually it's not moving WAN rules to LAN,WAN rules just disappear, except those two and LAN rules are all duplicated in list. Tested in VM. The first conclusion about moving rules to LAN tab is wrong, I am just blind ;)

doktornotor

Well, having them disappear is not exactly much better than having them moved. In fact it's worse I'd say, otherwise you could get those back more easily by changing the interface in the rules.

NOYB

Yum. Not good at all. This must be a recent development. Can't believe it would have gone long without being noticed.

Firewall Rules
LAN
Drag and drop a rule to reorder.
Save

See attached result.

2.4.0-BETA (amd64)
built on Fri Feb 17 18:23:30 CST 2017
FreeBSD 11.0-RELEASE-p7
on VirtualBox VM

Snap128.jpg_thumb

Derelict

I am seeing the same thing here.

Thanks, guys: https://redmine.pfsense.org/issues/7277

doktornotor

@NOYB:

Yum. Not good at all. This must be a recent development. Can't believe it would have gone long without being noticed.

I believe it's another result of the GET -> POST conversion. :-(

NOYB

@doktornotor:

@NOYB:

Yum. Not good at all. This must be a recent development. Can't believe it would have gone long without being noticed.

I believe it's another result of the GET -> POST conversion. :-(

Agree that would make sense to be the most like culprit.

w0w

Looks like fixed.