Squid 5.8 ---> 5.9
-
@slu that stateement was released before 6.6 was available
-
@JonathanLee said in Squid 5.8 ---> 5.9:
FYI------>
Hello fellow Netgate community
Squid 6.6 is available in bata version 24 I am working on some bugs on it but it's more secure and fixes all the concerns as it is the latest version of Squid. Squid is very effective at blocking URLS and I am working on finding a way to access the menu with Squid support also. I have some GitHub pulls open for the issues. More to comeAre you working on the official squid package in PFSense or on an alternative ?
If the former this is interesting news...
-
@DBMandrake Official Version only issue with it is
Per Squid Support Amos Jeffries
"You do have direct proxy (and thus manager) access via the 192.168.1.1:3128 so this URL should work:
http://192.168.1.1:3128/squid-internal-mgr/menu"Per Alex Rousskov Squid Support
"Currently, you may need to figure out what hostname Squid considers to self-identify as and use that hostname in cache manager requests. The following bug report may help, but there are several overlapping problems here, and that makes it difficult to triage without more information: https://bugs.squid-cache.org/show_bug.cgi?id=5283"https://bugs.squid-cache.org/show_bug.cgi?id=5283
It works great Blocks URLs some software convergence issues but nothing really major might need a new SSL/TLS cert made but that's about it
-
@JonathanLee said in Squid 5.8 ---> 5.9:
@DBMandrake Official Version only issue with it is
Per Squid Support Amos Jeffries
"You do have direct proxy (and thus manager) access via the 192.168.1.1:3128 so this URL should work:
http://192.168.1.1:3128/squid-internal-mgr/menu"Per Alex Rousskov Squid Support
"Currently, you may need to figure out what hostname Squid considers to self-identify as and use that hostname in cache manager requests. The following bug report may help, but there are several overlapping problems here, and that makes it difficult to triage without more information: https://bugs.squid-cache.org/show_bug.cgi?id=5283"https://bugs.squid-cache.org/show_bug.cgi?id=5283
It works great Blocks URLs some software convergence issues but nothing really major might need a new SSL/TLS cert made but that's about it
What about this bug ?
https://redmine.pfsense.org/issues/14390
This is a biggy - it has existed in Squid for over 10 years and causes major problems with CDN networks with rapidly rotated multiple IP address hostnames. (only with transparent proxying)
The bug has been there for years, what has changed is CDN's have started to very aggressively rotate DNS entries with TTL's as short as 30 seconds or less, this has made the symptoms trigger far more often than in the past, and this single issue is responsible for nearly all intermittent behaviour and connection failures (HTTP/409) in transparent proxy mode.
A fix for this would be massive.
-
@DBMandrake Was the Bug also listed in Squid Bugs? I thought that was closed out in Squid 6.6 they had an open report on the Squid side also. Again they now have the version 6.6 installed if you have the ability to do BE (Boot Environments) Check it out I opened some pulls for it just small issues with Squid -k parse. Again the menu issue with making squid know its identity. Main thing is it works, I can block URLS and cache traffic in 24. I might need a new certificate. All just seem like Squid to GUI software convergence for user convenience is all. Key issue is resolved the security concerns it is running Squid 6.6 and it has all the updates in that version. The Squid DEV version is 7.X right now the stable version is 6.X
I wish I knew more I love this package I am glad Netgate did not give up on it. Squid really shines when you configure it correctly.
-
@DBMandrake They have had to do something they use acceleration systems globally. Squid is used all over it's huge. It is technically green technology as items are not downloaded a million times over and over they are downloaded once and stored closer to the client. Again software hardware convergence is a bit complicated.
This really interests me (see below), Facebook is actively working on improving cacheing, they even have an open source project. It does save energy.
2016
https://research.facebook.com/blog/2016/4/the-evolution-of-advanced-caching-in-the-facebook-cdn/
2021
https://engineering.fb.com/2021/09/02/core-infra/cachelib/
https://cachelib.orgOverall cacheing fascinates me as a computer science student, the complications, the protocols, and the challenge. It is amazing when it works correctly. This tool is amazing when it's configured correctly.
-
@JonathanLee said in Squid 5.8 ---> 5.9:
@DBMandrake Was the Bug also listed in Squid Bugs? I thought that was closed out in Squid 6.6 they had an open report on the Squid side also.
I originally reported this bug 11 months ago and only to PFSense (discussed on the forum here in another thread then I opened the ticket) as at the time it was running a very out of date version of squid.
I haven't seen any upstream reports for this issue, do you have a link to that if you think it is fixed in 6.6 ?
There has been no update in the original redmine ticket so I assumed that the problem has not been fixed.
Again they now have the version 6.6 installed if you have the ability to do BE (Boot Environments) Check it out I opened some pulls for it just small issues with Squid -k parse. Again the menu issue with making squid know its identity. Main thing is it works, I can block URLS and cache traffic in 24. I might need a new certificate. All just seem like Squid to GUI software convergence for user convenience is all. Key issue is resolved the security concerns it is running Squid 6.6 and it has all the updates in that version. The Squid DEV version is 7.X right now the stable version is 6.X
Unfortunately I'm running 2.7.2 CE which currently only has Squid 6.3, and when I checked recently version 6.3 still has this issue, and boot environments are not supported in CE either. Based on previous release cycles of CE it could be a long time (6 months or more) before 6.6 found its way into CE.
Are you able to try the Python test script I attached to the PFSense ticket ? This can be run on any PC with Python installed.
For the test to be valid transparent proxying needs to be enabled on PFSense with the client going through the transparent proxy with no explicit proxy settings.
The way it works is it resolves a test hostname known to cause issues (I have at least 4 in the script that can be tried) and saves the IP address, it then crafts an HTTPS query to the same IP address every 30 seconds instead of freshly looking up the hostname. This is to simulate use of a "stale" DNS record.
When this IP address times out of the (rapidly rotated) DNS records, Squid will start to refuse the requests with HTTP/409.
If the same test is run with no transparent proxy there will be no errors, so this script is a reliable way to reproduce the issue.
I wish I knew more I love this package I am glad Netgate did not give up on it. Squid really shines when you configure it correctly.
So far I've seen no official word from Netgate that they've reversed their decision, so I hope you're right.
If they have changed their mind and are bringing the package right up to date and as a side effect this long standing Squid bug is fixed that would be absolutely fantastic.
-
@DBMandrake I test it when I get some time, I can’t do tests while family is home so I have what I call the everything bagel boot environment running sometime in the week I will check it the script.
-
@JonathanLee I've done a little testing myself today.
Using the following I was able to install a Squid 6.8 build on 2.7.2 CE on a spare test firewall:
https://forum.netgate.com/topic/186911/squid-6-8-available
Unfortunately this does not fix the issue as it still fails my python testing script (note that some of the domain names I've given as examples in the script are no longer valid so you'll need to find some that work) and also the errors are still logged in cache.log.
So as of Squid version 6.8 this problem still exists unfortunately. I have also not been able to find mention of any fixes for this issue in recent squid release notes.
-
@JonathanLee Here is the discussion about this issue:
https://bugs.squid-cache.org/show_bug.cgi?id=4940
A patch was first provided nearly 4 years ago but it has still not been accepted. (!)
The problem has been known about for over 10 years, as the discussion shows.
There is a patch attached to the ticket which is basically a one liner change that fixes the issue. This is something that netgate could choose to include in their version of the package if they wanted to. (And if they were satisfied it was safe)
-
@DBMandrake I also had a ticket open for this, it was closed as a duplicate I do know what you're talking about, iTunes does it also.
