Can't access VLAN20 from VLAN60 - Interface bound state help
-
@runevn You didn't specify what NAS equipment you are using, but I experienced exactly the same issue in my setup when I switched to 24.03. I run a Synology NAS, so it might be applicable to you, and for this setup to work you need to set "Enable Multiple Gateways" in Control Panel / Network / General / Advanced Settings. If that is not set you end up with assymetric routing just like @johnpoz said, as everything goes through your default gateway on the NAS.
-
@runevn said in Can't access VLAN20 from VLAN60 - Interface bound state help:
I did some searching on the topic and found this topic on state policy but I don't know if that even relates to my issue and if so I can't find the setting for enable multi gateways
Ah, I see you found my thread from earlier. Yes it might apply, and if you run Synology then the specific setting is as I specified in my previous post.
-
@pst said in Can't access VLAN20 from VLAN60 - Interface bound state help:
@runevn I run a Synology NAS, so it might be applicable to you, and for this setup to work you need to set "Enable Multiple Gateways" in Control Panel / Network / General / Advanced Settings.
I don't know why but can't find the setting where I can enable multiple gateways. Could you be more specific where I can find it? Am I on the wrong setting section?
BTW - I'm using Trueness Scale Dragonfish-24.04.0
-
@runevn said in Can't access VLAN20 from VLAN60 - Interface bound state help:
Could you be more specific where I can find it? Am I on the wrong setting section?
The change you need to do is not in pfSense, it is on the NAS.
-
@runevn said in Can't access VLAN20 from VLAN60 - Interface bound state help:
I'm using Trueness Scale Dragonfish-24.04.0
I'm not familiar with that NAS, but I'll take a quick look if there a similar gateway option there.
-
@runevn I can't see any setting for multiple gateways in the TrueNAS Scale documentation. From what I gather it should work if everything is set up "normally", confirm:
- your NAS interfaces are configured using DHCP
- pfSense provides the correct gateway address (check DHCP server setup)
- you don't have default gateway specified in NAS Global Configuration / Default Gateway Settings, as that overrides the one given in DHCP (according to https://www.truenas.com/docs/scale/24.04/scaleuireference/network/globalconfigurationscreens/)
-
@runevn does your nas have more than 1 interface?
-
@johnpoz Yes, three different:
- One management interface (GUI)
- NFS share
- SMB share
-
@pst said in Can't access VLAN20 from VLAN60 - Interface bound state help:
@runevn I can't see any setting for multiple gateways in the TrueNAS Scale documentation. From what I gather it should work if everything is set up "normally", confirm:
- your NAS interfaces are configured using DHCP
- pfSense provides the correct gateway address (check DHCP server setup)
- you don't have default gateway specified in NAS Global Configuration / Default Gateway Settings, as that overrides the one given in DHCP (according to https://www.truenas.com/docs/scale/24.04/scaleuireference/network/globalconfigurationscreens/)
Thanks a million! You were right.
I had defined a default gateway and had a static IP address for the vlan 20 interface. I removed the default gateway and then set the storage vlan20 to get the IP from the DHCP server (I couldn't find a way to manually add a gateway per interface when using static IP.
But now it works.
-
@runevn glad we could help :)
-
@runevn said in Can't access VLAN20 from VLAN60 - Interface bound state help:
You were right.
This brought to mind a line from Grateful Dead song ;)
"Well, I ain't always right, but I've never been wrong"
You get a cookie if you know what song, without having to look it up ;)
Dead on the Brain - My Dave's Pick 50 came in the mail today.. Always a good day when they come..
I always have subscription, so 4 times a year is like xmas ;)
Glad you got it sorted.
edit: soon to be 52, as soon as get it ripped and on plex ;)
edit2: make that 53, this shipment had the bonus disc.. Sweet! And hint that above line is from a song on the bonus disc ;)
