PC xbox networking open NAT HELP NEEDED

[Pseudonym0011]

I will start by saying that I have been able to get all of the consoles in the house (4 Xbox ones, a PS4, and a Nintendo Switch) on an open NAT by creating a static port for each system and enabling UPnP. In order to get the Xbox Ones to coexist, I had to manually select the port for it to use within each xbox's settings.

Using the same method of creating a static IP and static port for my PC, I was able to get my NAT type for XBOX Networking (and Destiny 2) from a strict state to moderate.

Ideally I would like to get my system's NAT type to open.

Important Notes
I do not have any manual port forward rules created.
I used the wizard to create a basic traffic shaping rule prioritizing game traffic and de-prioritizing peer to peer connections.( I am aware that some games still use peer to peer connections for multiplayer.)
Outbound NAT is Hybrid.

[thunderman]

Hello,

Try to separate your alias xboxgroup (do a alias for each one).
Disable your rule prioritizing.
Create ACL for UPnP

It's works for me with 2 Xbox One, except for Warframe game.
Test with this configuration (copy/paste from an other post)

I have manies issues with Warframe on 2 Xbox on the same ISP (only 1 public IP address).
In Warframe, I can't invite a friend to join me.
At the best, only 1 Xbox can see the other player, launch a invit but an error message tell "The player is offline).

All the network test on Xbox is OK : (Internet, Multiplayer and NAT Open)
I try with other game (Rocket League and Warhammer Vermintide) without problem.

I use PFsense 2.4.3-RELEASE (amd64)

Firewall / NAT / Outbound

Mode : Manual Outbound NAT

Interface : WAN
Source : Xbox1 (alias for 192.168.0.16)
Port Source : any
Destination : any
Port Destination : anay
NAT Address : WAN
NAT Port : any
Static Port : YES

Interface : WAN
Source : Xbox2 (alias for 192.168.0.17)
Port Source : any
Destination : any
Port Destination : anay
NAT Address : WAN
NAT Port : any
Static Port : YES

Services / UPnP & NAT-PMP

• Enable UPnP & NAT-PMP

• Allow UPnP Port Mapping

• Allow NAT-PMP Port Mapping

• External Interface : WAN

• Interface : LAN + loopback

• ACL Entries : allow 1-65535 192.168.0.16 1-65535

• ACL Entries : allow 1-65535 192.168.0.17 1-65535

System / Advanced / Firewall & NAT

• NAT Reflection mode for port forwards : Pure NAT
• Enable NAT Reflection for 1:1 NAT
• Enable automatic outbound NAT for Reflection

Firewall / NAT / Port Forward

Nothing, because I activate UPnP

Actually, I must use the bad ISP-box only for Warframe ;-)

Regards,

Aym