NAT reflection broken all of a sudden?

seitzbg

Yes I noticed this as well. Wonder if they will fix it…. I've also had inbound nat broken on a few of my rules as well.

yon

me too.

dbmet

Just wondering if I should update or if this is still broken?

pyrodex

@dbmet:

Just wondering if I should update or if this is still broken?

Just updated to the latest available version and confirmed it still isn't working. I created https://redmine.pfsense.org/issues/5667 a few days ago but no updates on it yet.

yon

I think should firewall has wrong.

jimp

Is everyone who is experiencing this set to NAT+Proxy?

If so, try reverting this commit using the system patches package, 9abebb137fcb520e3666d54ad67773608d1104ac

jimp

Or run this:

fetch -o /etc/services https://raw.githubusercontent.com/pfsense/pfsense/e064944f04eeea10a183b7c07852beca3fdadc7d/src/etc/services

and then save on System > Advanced, Firewall/NAT

pyrodex

@jimp:

Or run this:
fetch -o /etc/services https://raw.githubusercontent.com/pfsense/pfsense/e064944f04eeea10a183b7c07852beca3fdadc7d/src/etc/services
and then save on System > Advanced, Firewall/NAT

That fixed it!

I also had the issue when I tried Pure NAT mode so not sure if that would have been solved by the services file fix as well. Also I wasn't using a system wide setting just individual NAT setting but I know that is the same type of setting.

jimp

OK, I added that as a note to https://redmine.pfsense.org/issues/5667, we'll get that fixed up though it may be next week due to the holiday.

pyrodex

@jimp:

OK, I added that as a note to https://redmine.pfsense.org/issues/5667, we'll get that fixed up though it may be next week due to the holiday.

Understood and thanks for the workaround. Happy holidays!