PfBlockerNG v2.0 w/DNSBL

pfcode

@BBcan177:

@renegade:

I think i found out, why my network is so slow and unresponseful sometimes.
The Unbound seems to restart pretty often

Do you have DHCP Registration enabled in the Resolver? Maybe try it without those two checkboxes… Are you running it in Resover or Forwarder mode? Is DNSSEC enabled?

I am running the DNS in Resolver Mode. Forwarding is disabled. DNSSEC is enabled; but was disabled before and i had the same problems.
Yes, i have both boxes checked. (I need this).
I can try to disable the checkboxes. This morning my whole network had problems, because the Unbound stopped and did not restart.

There is a serious issue in the unbound service package, you will have to disable DNSBL, so that the line "server:include: /var/unbound/pfb_dnsbl.conf" is removed from Custom Options in the Unbound, to make unbound restart properly when your modem is rebooted or your IPv4/IPv6 WAN IP got renewed.

BBcan177

@renegade:

@BBcan177:

@renegade:

I think i found out, why my network is so slow and unresponseful sometimes.
The Unbound seems to restart pretty often

Do you have DHCP Registration enabled in the Resolver? Maybe try it without those two checkboxes… Are you running it in Resover or Forwarder mode? Is DNSSEC enabled?

I am running the DNS in Resolver Mode. Forwarding is disabled. DNSSEC is enabled; but was disabled before and i had the same problems.
Yes, i have both boxes checked. (I need this).
I can try to disable the checkboxes. This morning my whole network had problems, because the Unbound stopped and did not restart.

Check the Resolver.log for additional details… You might have to increase the Log Verbosity to get it to show more details to help diagnose the issue.

BBcan177

@pfcode:

There is a serious issue in the unbound service package, you will have to disable DNSBL, so that the line "server:include: /var/unbound/pfb_dnsbl.conf" is removed from Custom Options in the Unbound, to make unbound restart properly when your modem is rebooted or your IPv4/IPv6 WAN IP got renewed.

Please post this issue in Redmine. Its the best way to help get this resolved.

https://redmine.pfsense.org/projects/pfsense

renegade

So i would have to disable DNSBL every morning after my 24h disconnect, restart unbound and enable DNSBL again…?
I do not really understand this bug, so i think that i am not the eligible person to file an issue.

trumee

I have the following list in 'Whitelist' for slickdeals, but still the links are not being whitelisted:


dotomi.com
dpbolvw.net
evyy.net
doubleclick.net
avantlink.com
tkqlhce.com
pjatr.com
shareasale.com
pntrack.com
ojrq.net
clickserve.cc-dt.com
jdoqocy.com
pntrac.com
affiliatefuture.com
anrdoezrs.net
gan.doubleclick.net
emjcd.com
commission-junction.com
cj.com
apmebf.com
gopjn.com
bfast.com
redirect.at
redirectingat.com
7eer.net
linksynergy.com
kqzyfj.com
cc-dt.com
altfarm.mediaplex.com
onenetworkdirect.net
go2jump.org
pntra.com
pjtra.com
qksrv.net
ad.doubleclick.net
cj.dotomi.com

The following link failed:


http://www.tkqlhce.com/click-4485850-11886886-1423272259000?sid=941dcd3e509111e69c477a73c7e879150INT&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.newegg.com

BBcan177

@trumee:

I have the following list in 'Whitelist' for slickdeals, but still the links are not being whitelisted:

The following link failed:
http://www.tkqlhce.com/click-4485850-11886886-1423272259000?sid=941dcd3e509111e69c477a73c7e879150INT&url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.newegg.com

You also need to Whitelist:
www.tkqlhce.com

add that to the Whitelist, and run a "Force Reload - DNSBL"

trumee

Is it possible to have a regex like *tkqlhce.com to block all the subdomains?

tjbaudio

Hello, new member here. Long time linux user with a solid understanding of networking and Vlans but I am brand new to pfsense and complex firewall configs. Currently I am trying to set up a new firewall for my home. Ultimate goals are to filter ads, block M$ spying and IOT back doors, separate Vlan or nic for IP cameras, and VPN access for said cameras.

Currently I am stuck at the ad filtering. Ad's are blocked but page loads are very long and none are logged. The VIP is timing out on :80 and :443, connection reset error on :8443. :8081 serves up just fine and is logged in alerts correctly. Given the service is up and running and :8081 works and ads are blocked I think DNSBL is up and running just fine. I suspect a firewall rule or NAT is not correct. I have done the same install twice with the same results both times. Since this package is fairly new GOOGLE is coming up short but I will keep trying.

I am using P4 1.8 GHz with 768 meg ram. Fresh install of PFsense 2.3.1 upgraded to 2.3.1-RELEASE-p5 (i386). Basic ip and interface settings working. Installed the latest pfBlockerNG package 2.0.17. Configured per post 18 of this thread skipping Alxea. The only oops was I enabled pfBNG a couple of steps early. Reboot after initial setup for good measure.

Again, every thing works as expected other than browsing to 10.10.10.1:80 or 10.10.10.1:443 has to time out during page loads. I have looked around and I think I see the rules in place for this but I still think one is wrong or I am missing something simple. Included below are some snips from the config XML.

Thank you very much for any help or hints you can give.

 <nat><outbound><mode>automatic</mode></outbound> 
 <rule><source>
 <any><destination><address>10.10.10.1</address>

<port>80</port></destination> 
<protocol>tcp</protocol>
<target>127.0.0.1</target>
<local-port>8081</local-port>
<interface>lan</interface>

 <associated-rule-id><natreflection>purenat</natreflection></associated-rule-id></any></rule> 
 <rule><source>
 <any><destination><address>10.10.10.1</address>

<port>443</port></destination> 
<protocol>tcp</protocol>
<target>127.0.0.1</target>
<local-port>8443</local-port>
<interface>lan</interface>

 <associated-rule-id><natreflection>purenat</natreflection></associated-rule-id></any></rule> 
 <separator></separator></nat> 
 <filter><rule><type>pass</type>
<ipprotocol>inet</ipprotocol>

<interface>lan</interface>
<tracker>0100000101</tracker>
<source>
<network>lan</network>

 <destination><any></any></destination></rule> 
 <rule><type>pass</type>
<ipprotocol>inet6</ipprotocol>

<interface>lan</interface>
<tracker>0100000102</tracker>
<source>
<network>lan</network>

 <destination><any></any></destination></rule></filter> 
 <shaper><ipsec><aliases><alias><name>pfB_DNSBLIP</name>
 <url>https://127.0.0.1:443/pfblockerng/pfblockerng.php?pfb=pfB_DNSBLIP</url> 
<updatefreq>32</updatefreq>

<address>

<type>urltable</type>
 <detail></detail> 

 <proxyarp>```
 <pfblockerngdnsblsettings><config><pfb_dnsbl>on</pfb_dnsbl>
<pfb_dnsvip>10.10.10.1</pfb_dnsvip>
<pfb_dnsport>8081</pfb_dnsport>
<pfb_dnsport_ssl>8443</pfb_dnsport_ssl>
<dnsbl_interface>lan</dnsbl_interface>
 <pfb_dnsbl_rule><dnsbl_allow_int>lan</dnsbl_allow_int>
<action>Deny_Both</action>
<aliaslog>enabled</aliaslog>
 <autoaddrnot_in><autoports_in><aliasports_in><autoaddr_in><autonot_in><aliasaddr_in><autoproto_in><agateway_in>default</agateway_in>
 <autoaddrnot_out><autoports_out><aliasports_out><autoaddr_out><autonot_out><aliasaddr_out><autoproto_out><agateway_out>default</agateway_out>
 <alexa_enable><alexa_count>1000</alexa_count>
<alexa_inclusion>ca,co,com,io,net,org</alexa_inclusion></alexa_enable></autoproto_out></aliasaddr_out></autonot_out></autoaddr_out></aliasports_out></autoports_out></autoaddrnot_out></autoproto_in></aliasaddr_in></autonot_in></autoaddr_in></aliasports_in></autoports_in></autoaddrnot_in></pfb_dnsbl_rule></config></pfblockerngdnsblsettings>

 <pfblockerng><config><enable_cb>on</enable_cb>
<pfb_keep>on</pfb_keep>
<pfb_interval>24</pfb_interval>
<pfb_min>0</pfb_min>
<pfb_hour>0</pfb_hour>
<pfb_dailystart>0</pfb_dailystart>
 <enable_dup><enable_agg><suppression><enable_log><database_cc><skipfeed>0</skipfeed>
<log_maxlines>20000</log_maxlines>
<inbound_interface>lan</inbound_interface>
<inbound_deny_action>block</inbound_deny_action>
<outbound_interface>wan</outbound_interface>
<outbound_deny_action>reject</outbound_deny_action>
 <openvpn_action><enable_float><pass_order>order_0</pass_order>
<autorule_suffix>autorule</autorule_suffix>
 <killstates></killstates></enable_float></openvpn_action></database_cc></enable_log></suppression></enable_agg></enable_dup></config></pfblockerng>

 <virtualip><vip><mode>ipalias</mode>
<interface>lan</interface>

<type>single</type>
<subnet_bits>32</subnet_bits>
<subnet>10.10.10.1</subnet></vip></virtualip> 

```</proxyarp></address></alias></aliases></ipsec></shaper>

BBcan177

@trumee:

Is it possible to have a regex like *tkqlhce.com to block all the subdomains?

The pending version 2.1.1 has the option to Whitelist all Sub-Domains by prefixing the Whitelisted Domain with a "dot"… Just waiting for the Devs to merge the new changes... See this thread:

https://forum.pfsense.org/index.php?topic=115357.0

BBcan177

@tjbaudio:

Again, every thing works as expected other than browsing to 10.10.10.1:80 or 10.10.10.1:443 has to time out during page loads. I have looked around and I think I see the rules in place for this but I still think one is wrong or I am missing something simple. Included below are some snips from the config XML

Since you are using multiple VLANS, you need to ensure that all VLANs can hit the DNSBL VIP… There is an option in the DNSBL Tab, to add a Permit Floating rule... Ensure that you select all of the VLANs in the selection menu... You will have slow browsing issues if you can't get ping the DNSBL VIP and Browse to the DNSBL VIP and get the 1x1 pix....

tjbaudio

@BBcan177:

@tjbaudio:

Again, every thing works as expected other than browsing to 10.10.10.1:80 or 10.10.10.1:443 has to time out during page loads. I have looked around and I think I see the rules in place for this but I still think one is wrong or I am missing something simple. Included below are some snips from the config XML

Since you are using multiple VLANS, you need to ensure that all VLANs can hit the DNSBL VIP… There is an option in the DNSBL Tab, to add a Permit Floating rule... Ensure that you select all of the VLANs in the selection menu... You will have slow browsing issues if you can't get ping the DNSBL VIP and Browse to the DNSBL VIP and get the 1x1 pix....

My apologies. That is my ultimate goal. At this point I just have a stock install with 2 nics, WAN and LAN nics. No Vlan's. Just default settings+ pfBNG installed.
Edit to add:
I can ping 10.10.10.1 from LAN.
In states I get:
LAN tcp 10.10.10.1:8081 <- 192.168.1.101:50268 ESTABLISHED:ESTABLISHED 5 / 4 587 B / 576 B
When loading 10.10.10.1:8081 in a browser.

LAN tcp 127.0.0.1:8443 (10.10.10.1:443) <- 192.168.1.135:50120 CLOSED:SYN_SENT 3 / 0 152 B / 0 B
When loading 10.10.10.1:80 in a browser.

LAN tcp 127.0.0.1:8443 (10.10.10.1:443) <- 192.168.1.101:35768 CLOSED:SYN_SENT 2 / 0 120 B / 0 B
LAN tcp 127.0.0.1:8443 (10.10.10.1:443) <- 192.168.1.101:35770 CLOSED:SYN_SENT 2 / 0 120 B / 0 B
When loading 10.10.10.1 in a browser.

renegade

@BBcan177:

@pfcode:

There is a serious issue in the unbound service package, you will have to disable DNSBL, so that the line "server:include: /var/unbound/pfb_dnsbl.conf" is removed from Custom Options in the Unbound, to make unbound restart properly when your modem is rebooted or your IPv4/IPv6 WAN IP got renewed.

Please post this issue in Redmine. Its the best way to help get this resolved.

https://redmine.pfsense.org/projects/pfsense

Okay guys, what can i do here?
I am really sad that i cannot use DNSBL, because my provider cuts my line every day…
Do i have to post a bounty and refer to that forum post?

tjbaudio

I think I have traced my problem to NAT reflection. DNSBL is responding with the VIP address when tested with a known add site. The VIP server is up and responds as it should when using ports 8081 and 8443.
The firewall states show it forwarding when using 80 and 443. but nothing ever comes back.
I have tested this with wget, firefox, and chrom.

I love how DNSBL and pfBlockerNG are working. I am just going to have to go back over my pfsense setup to figure out the NAT reflection problem.

BBcan177

@renegade:

Okay guys, what can i do here?
I am really sad that i cannot use DNSBL, because my provider cuts my line every day…
Do i have to post a bounty and refer to that forum post?

Hi renegade,

You don't need to post a bounty. The redmine link is a site to post bugs/features for pfSense. The issue at hand seems to be related to the base pfSense software and not with the package. I don't have a similar network environment to debug this issue. So that's why I suggested that someone with the issue post in redmine to help sort out this issue. In the meantime try to reduce the number of feeds used for DNSBL which might reduce the unbound resolver load time.

BBcan177

@tjbaudio:

I think I have traced my problem to NAT reflection.

From an earlier post, it seems like you reversed the in/outbound interfaces in the pkg General tab. Not sure if that's related. Also try to enable suppression in the general tab and run a "Force Reload -All". This will remove any loopback addresses that could potentially be in the DNSBL IP aliastable.

tjbaudio

Thank you for the recommendations. These did not work. Unfortunately I may not have much time over the next week to work on this. I am thinking I may try a fresh install again when I do. Taking screen shots the whole way. If it works you can use them for a how to, if not I will know what I did :o

D0X

Problem here;

Running pfsense 2.3.1 with pfblockerng.

Did set up IPV4 with two lists, EasyList and EasyPrivacy.
I also have DNSBL enabled with Easylist.

But now when browsing I continuously get Safari telling me the certificate is invalid (as shown in the attached picture, it is in Dutch but I think you'll get it).
The certificate seems to me just the thing you'd like to have being blocked. How do I fix this, it is bugging the hell out of me.

![Schermafbeelding 2016-07-25 om 12.43.09.png](/public/imported_attachments/1/Schermafbeelding 2016-07-25 om 12.43.09.png)
![Schermafbeelding 2016-07-25 om 12.43.09.png_thumb](/public/imported_attachments/1/Schermafbeelding 2016-07-25 om 12.43.09.png_thumb)

BBcan177

@tjbaudio:

Thank you for the recommendations. These did not work. Unfortunately I may not have much time over the next week to work on this. I am thinking I may try a fresh install again when I do. Taking screen shots the whole way. If it works you can use them for a how to, if not I will know what I did :o

With just a single WAN/LAN, it should be fairly straightforward to setup the pkg… Double check your LAN Devices for DNS and ensure that they only have pfSense as its only DNS server setting.

BBcan177

@D0X:

But now when browsing I continuously get Safari telling me the certificate is invalid (as shown in the attached picture, it is in Dutch but I think you'll get it).

Safari seems to be the only browser that has this issue. Doesn't seem to occur with Chrome/FF/IE/Edge etc…

Are these cert popups happening when you browse to that blocked Domain directly, or when its blocking that Domain as part of the webpage? Two checks to ensure DNBSL is working as expected... Ping the DNSBL VIP and get a proper response ... Browse to the DNSBL VIP and get the 1x1 pix...

If the popups are from a few common Domains, try to whitelist those and see if that improves it.

Also, in the IPv4 tab, you cannot enter any EasyList Feeds... the IPv4 tab is for IP based listed only.

DNSBL is designed to block the DNS resolution to Advert/Malicious Domains. As such only a portion of the EasyList/Privacy Feeds can be used (Where the feeds lists the actual ADvert Domain). Browser-Addons like ADBlock/UBlock manipulate the elements that are displayed on the page. So they can block certain elements from a particular Domain, while DNSBL can only block the entire Domain.

Only two EasyList feeds can be used with DNSBL and they are hardcoded in the EasyList Tab. There are several other DNSBL Feeds listed at the start of this thread that can fill in the gap to block the balance of the Domains from serving any ADs. Plus its achieved at Network level, without any add-ons manipulating or potentially opening security holes in the browser.

It would really be nice if Safari fixed this issue with their software... Not much I can do to fix that without killing the package logging feature and just NXDOMAIN the DNS requests.

D0X

Safari seems to be the only browser that has this issue. Doesn't seem to occur with Chrome/FF/IE/Edge etc…

Are these cert popups happening when you browse to that blocked Domain directly, or when its blocking that Domain as part of the webpage? Two checks to ensure DNBSL is working as expected... Ping the DNSBL VIP and get a proper response ... Browse to the DNSBL VIP and get the 1x1 pix...

Should the VIP be one inside the LAN subnet or outside, tried both. Only inside the subnet I am getting the 1x1 pix, both don't respond to pings.

If the popups are from a few common Domains, try to whitelist those and see if that improves it.

googleads.g.doubleclick.net seems to be the main culprit. Isn't there any other way to block this certificate?

Also, in the IPv4 tab, you cannot enter any EasyList Feeds… the IPv4 tab is for IP based listed only.

Check, only using DNSBL now.

It would really be nice if Safari fixed this issue with their software… Not much I can do to fix that without killing the package logging feature and just NXDOMAIN the DNS requests.