CONNECTION WITH REMOTE SERVER NOT ESTABLISHED BECAUSE OF A SERVER VERIFICATION METHOD ERROR

romantik70

"zip removed by mod" here is the file they provided to me

Gertjan

Not related (edit : but will totally break everything) : Correct this :

stephenw10

Ok! Now we're getting somewhere.

The server is at ovpn-20.shpv.fr on port 443 and you're connecting to port 1194.
It's also using TCP and you're connecting using UDP. So not surprisingly it's not responding!

You should use the host name there rather than the IP directly as you have in the earlier screenshot. That IP might change.

Correct those things on the client. Post a new screenshot of the client setup.
Re-test.

Steve

Gertjan

I created a VPN client with the opvn file.

The connection is there.
Right now it blocks on :

edit : @romantik70 : I completely deleted the config from my pfSense setup.
I advise to to remove the zip file you posted above - or at least 'destroy' the cert keys in it.

johnpoz

Also they are setting compression to no

comp-lzo no

Looks like you didn't even look in the file at all.. Just clicked some random shit and wondering why not working.

Gertjan

@johnpoz :

I should be ok :

The opvn file ( /var/etc/openvpn/clientx.conf ) constructed mentions :

johnpoz

Exactly... And upon looking closer at his first posts... Looks like he tried to set it up as server vs a client?

And he put the CA cert as a user cert, etc. etc..

I also deleted the attached zip, so nobody else can grab it..

Seems odd that that they would be running access server vs the community version... AS is for companies, its not all that cheap at 15$ per user per year to start with.. You would think they would just configure the community FREE version to maximize profit..

At 24 € a user - the cost of the license $15 USD per year... Thats not much per year per user at all.. At current exchange they make like 10 bucks a year per user.. That has to pay for infrastructure and bandwidth as well... Not a very good cost model ;)

romantik70

@stephenw10 did the cahnges you asked me to do but there is a host resolution issue so it' s bettere i pu the ip address instead of the hostname .

i have tried to change the hostname in the ip address and i leave unchanged the otrher and the logs turned back to be what they are before as you can see , in the next pictured i have taken after changing. I am starting to be pissed off of this fucking pfsense. .
I would like to make the last attempt after that i will think to abandone pfsense . My question is what do you use for your network , pfsense like me or onther solution.If you use pfsense would you please screeshot the setting you got on your pfsense so i do the same .

johnpoz

Ok I have your zip file - give me one sec...

Gertjan

@romantik70 said in CONNECTION WITH REMOTE SERVER NOT ESTABLISHED BECAUSE OF A SERVER VERIFICATION METHOD ERROR:

i will think to abandone pfsense

Setting up an OPENVPN client on some other firewall/router will give you the same issues .... because the items to set will be identical ....

This means your pfSense has a broken DNS setup ....it can't resolve domain names.

Check for yourself :

@romantik70 said in CONNECTION WITH REMOTE SERVER NOT ESTABLISHED BECAUSE OF A SERVER VERIFICATION METHOD ERROR:

My question is what do you use for your network , pfsense like me or onther solution.If you use pfsense would you please screeshot the setting you got on your pfsense so i do the same .

That could be hundreds of screens.
Far more easier would be : reset pfSense to default.
If needed, setup WAN.
Check that your are connected to the Inter etc.
DO NOT change anything else.

And just to motivate you : setting up a VPN client to use a VPN server (that doesn't detail close to nothing about how to do so in your case) is difficult to do for someone who as experience with the issue. With no experiences it's close to impossible.
Settings up a OpenVPN server (on pfSense) should be done first. Because you have a Phone with a Open VPN client app, so you can test things for yourself and see the logs on both sides (very important).
This learning process is not something optional. It's needed - burning the learning steps a guarantee final outcome : it won't be a "Pass".

Always go step by step.

@johnpoz said in CONNECTION WITH REMOTE SERVER NOT ESTABLISHED BECAUSE OF A SERVER VERIFICATION METHOD ERROR:

Ok I have your zip file - give me one sec...

Optimist ^^ Give him one hour or so.
(see my posts above ....)

johnpoz

Ok that guy is NOT answering on port 443...

Maybe he blocks me because from US and not France? But there is NO answer back to that that host IP on 443...

So no you would not be able to connect.... But you have to setup your client correctly...

Lets see the log from when you use that opvn file to connect from your client...

From that file

proto tcp
remote ovpn-20.shpv.fr
port 443

And there is ZERO reply back from that host on 443, no RST, no syn,ack - nothing... So no it would not be possible to connect a vpn..

Show us your clients log when you run it on say windows.

I imported that ovpn file into my vpn client on my windows machine - and NO answer.. Maybe he doesn't like US IP address?? Didn't mention that when you did that it worked - if so lets see the log of that connection.

Gertjan

@johnpoz : see my last image above.
I could connect ..... calling from France, true.

Btw : using
proto tcp
remote ovpn-20.shpv.fr
port 443

johnpoz

I don't see an answer back - and looks like you forgot to put in the tls key?

Let me see your sniff where you get a response - just import that ovpn into a client openvpn on a windows/linux box - so we can see the full log of client connecting..

edit... Now the client is connecting

Thu Dec 19 17:40:19 2019 Initialization Sequence Completed
Thu Dec 19 17:40:19 2019 Register_dns request sent to the service
Thu Dec 19 17:40:19 2019 MANAGEMENT: >STATE:1576798819,CONNECTED,SUCCESS,172.27.224.11,185.212.227.121,443,192.168.9.100,64601

Give me a sec to move it back into pfsense.

edit: Ok connected just fine using his ovpn file transposed to pfsense client.

edit2: settings

edit3: Ok created interface and setup outbound nat - and now routing traffic through it

edit4: Disconnect and back to my normal wan IP

Gertjan

Nice !
The only difference (your screen and mine) I can see : Auth digest algorithm : You set to SHA1, I had SHA256.

I'm pretty sure I saw a

auth SHA256

in his opvn file.

johnpoz

nope didn't see that... So it default to old default of sha1, not the best setting these days...

But clearly as you can see works just fine with pfsense - just have to take the settings correctly from the ovpn file and put them in the gui... What would be really slick as shit is if there was an importer ;) Someone should really code that ;) I don't have any use for it - but could save many users headaches to be sure..

Maybe you caught this

## -----BEGIN RSA SIGNATURE-----
## DIGEST:sha256

But that is not part of the config.

edit: I think they must of been having issues before, since it wasn't connecting before at all..

edit2: I would prob make sure not to pull routes and just policy route - was in a hurry so didn't pay much mind.. Its all disabled currently but will leave it ready to go until OP says he has it working ;)

romantik70

@johnpoz i didnt forget to put tls key as you can see by screenshot . tried to make all the changes you tell me to do , but anfortunately there is no changes. i have noted and i dony know why oy happens that when i put the entire host ovpn-20.shpv.fr it always answer me that it is not able to resolve the host , error that i dont get when i put the ip address . it 's an hard hard issue to solve ....i can say yoy that the first time a collugue if mine....just an america man from texas Mattew ( i worked in the nato base here in naples , where i knew him . i am a solder from the italian army ....he made me discover pfsense cause i didnt know it at all ) the vpn worked .After one year they made some setting changes and after that changes the vpns finished working ,When i asked support for it they only could answer that dey didnt support pfsense.I say business is business , do you care i take the subscription help me solve this fucking issue , but french are french no way of changhing their mind.An other clue that their mind are insane is that they give an internationak service and they have web pages written only in french language , strange guys , strange guys they are. I want to tell you a funny story on french guys when last stayed to Kobul for duty wit the NATO .I went twice in Kobul first time with germans , second with french , would you aspect that germans are more confortable and funny then french , i wouldnt.When you stay in the base , at night we arrange parties , there sheltered places in the base , where we make parties , we drink , what to do , when you go outside in patrol you are fortunate if you get back.They even invited a ferman rock band to celebrate di OKTOBER FEST , what a day man i got drunk as a monkey , we say here in italy.When , came french everything changed .The suddnly , built a little Effel Tower before the bar where all soldiers went to relax. The even made stupid private partie , no private parties with germans , you could access to whatever fuckuing party they did. A collegue of mine , an american wanted to access a party they was helding , and the french guy said him : it's a french private party , you are american you cannot get in. The american answered : you should appriciate my presense in the party man, because it is thanks to me that you speak french , you would have spoken germans . hahhahahahah that's true no graditude.

johnpoz

Lets see your full page... of settings of your client, like I posted.

seems like you put a colon in your hostname:443 vs just the hostname??

from a client or pfsense resolve just the name?

$ dig ovpn-20.shpv.fr

; <<>> DiG 9.14.7 <<>> ovpn-20.shpv.fr
;; global options: +cmd
;; Got answer:
;; ->>HEADER<<- opcode: QUERY, status: NOERROR, id: 16646
;; flags: qr rd ra; QUERY: 1, ANSWER: 1, AUTHORITY: 0, ADDITIONAL: 1

;; OPT PSEUDOSECTION:
; EDNS: version: 0, flags:; udp: 4096
;; QUESTION SECTION:
;ovpn-20.shpv.fr.               IN      A

;; ANSWER SECTION:
ovpn-20.shpv.fr.        4734    IN      A       185.212.227.121

;; Query time: 2 msec
;; SERVER: 192.168.3.10#53(192.168.3.10)
;; WHEN: Thu Dec 19 21:31:17 Central Standard Time 2019
;; MSG SIZE  rcvd: 60

I see from your settings you have auth and encryption... I doubt they are allowing for that, you notice I am just using auth..

Why are you putting in something for username and password? You do not need that!!!

romantik70

i Did settings changes you hinted me but nothing changes i appriciate your efforts of helping me but i am strongly thinking about to use something different than pfsense for building ny network , i will try to set on a linux VM openvpn and try to do some portforwarding with linux to redirect my ip public address tcp's port to my inner VMs. The first time i used vpn by shpv.fr provider it worked but all setting were made by an american collegue of mine here in the NATO base in Naples ( i am a soldier by the army) , but the dude , fortunately for him , less for fortunetky for me , got back to states , i think now he is in duty to Hawaii ilands m blessed him . Thank you far all man.

johnpoz

Dude this took really all of 30 seconds to setup... As you see I connected and routed traffic just fine through your connection. But if your not going to post screen shot of what you actually setup.. There is no way I can point out to you what your missing/doing wrong.

As to base in Naples ;) I visited Naples during Med Cruise back in Navy days .. 87 I think it was ;) Might of been Summer of 86? when we did med, then 88 we were in Gulf.. escorting tankers.. Many Many years ago ;)

What I recall from Naples was drinking really cheap big bomber bottles of Heineken ;)

edit: You Italian.. Oh man some of the greatest guys we ran into was in Haifa, Israel during that Med Cruise - there was an Italian ship docked next to us.. And we would go drinking with them - there was 1 of our guys that spoke some Italian and one of their guys spoke some english.. They gave us tour of their ship, we gave tours of ours... You guys could drink beer on your ship - bastards ;) US ships are dry!!

We were there for a couple of weeks - best time of the whole cruise was party with the Italians!

johnpoz

I just checked out in the garage, we had just recently cleaned out the attic and found my box of stuff from navy.. I had hat from one of the Italian guys (ship name and number on it - we exchanged hats)... But must of put that box out in the shed - was going to post a picture of it.. I believe it was an Frigate, I was on CG-27.. Guided Missile Cruiser..