haproxy and wildcard lets encrypt only for internal servers

PiBa

@noplan
Can you elaborate on the bammmmm part? Is the browser actually receiving the LE cert? Does it indeed show as valid for the domain used? No proxy is taking the browser traffic that checks differently?

Or perhaps its the 'chain' thats missing.? Have you uploaded the intermediate certs into pfSense cert manager?

Can you check in /var/etc/haproxy/ that the expected cert contents is there, including intermediates.?

noplan

@PiBa
when i call the website the browser still shows the "old" self signed cert
---> no i guess the LE cert is not received by the browser
Q1 how can i check if browser will get LE cert ?

what i find in /var/etc/haproxy/
name.crt_lst
name.pem
server_clientcert_1234.pem
haproxy.cfg

i think something is missing

Have you uploaded the intermediate certs into pfSense cert manager
no
i thought its a wildcard no use for that

hmmm
checking again

noplan

@PiBa

do i have to copy these to somewhere else ?
maybe to /var/etc/haproxy/ ???

-----END CERTIFICATE-----
[Tue Apr 14 20:47:33 CEST 2020] Your cert is in /tmp/acme/certName.xyz//.certName.xyz/.certName.xyz.cer
[Tue Apr 14 20:47:33 CEST 2020] Your cert key is in /tmp/acme/certName.xyz//.certName.xyz/.certName.xyz.key
[Tue Apr 14 20:47:33 CEST 2020] The intermediate CA cert is in /tmp/acme/certName.xyz//.certName.xyz/ca.cer
[Tue Apr 14 20:47:33 CEST 2020] And the full chain certs is there: /tmp/acme/certName.xyz//.certName.xyz/fullchain.cer
[Tue Apr 14 20:47:33 CEST 2020] Run reload cmd: /tmp/acme/certName.xyz/reloadcmd.sh

IMPORT CERT certName.xyz, /tmp/acme/certName.xyz/.certName.xyz/.certName.xyz.key, /tmp/acme/certName.xyz/.certName.xyz/.certName.xyz.cer
update cert![Tue Apr 14 20:47:34 CEST 2020] Reload success

PiBa

@noplan
If you open the 'name.pem' file, does it contain 'BEGIN CERTIFICATE' twice?
If you look in the pfSense certificate manager, on the certificates tab, is the 'Issuer' column filled? If not try adding the intermediate cert from LE at the CAs tab, it should then automatically fill the Issuer on the certs tab as well when iirc..

That would only be separate 'parts' of the fullchain.cer ..

(afaik the LE cert that signs public certs itself is not trusted root.., seems not with my one anyhow.. but i set it up a few years ago.. maybe things changed..)

noplan

name.pem (goes like this)

-----BEGIN CERTIFICATE-----
-----END CERTIFICATE-----

-----BEGIN RSA PRIVATE KEY-----
-----END RSA PRIVATE KEY-----

-----BEGIN CERTIFICATE-----
-----END CERTIFICATE-----

certificate manager, on the certificates tab
yes filled with

PiBa

@noplan hmm.. seems it all sounds good..
sure the browser doesn't use a proxy.? or a local dns direct record?

noplan

firefox / not usin a proxy

pfsense is the DNS

hmm /me a little in the woods now :) *ffffff

PiBa

@noplan
Send you a PM/chat, perhaps i can take a look at your setup.?.

capone

So Happy I found this thread.

I am having the EXACT same issue.

@noplan my setup is identical to your OP. Did you ever find a solution to this??

@PiBa were you able to fix @noplan's setup?

capone

The only progress I was able to make with this is to remove the "Register DHCP static mappings in the DNS Resolver" .... save ... apply.

Close the browser, run ipconfig /flushdns, reopen the browser and it works.

As a consequence, I loose access to anything that I had as a static DHCP lease and didn't set an override for...but also if I want to ssh into one of the machines that I have an override for...I will get my PFsense box.

For more details, I posted my findings here: Override Hosts not working with DNS Resolver

If you leave the tick in, "Register DHCP static mappings in the DNS Resolver" ... then the resolver servers two IPs... the 1st is the actual IP of your server, the 2nd is the override.

Looks like the browser uses the 1st IP and goes directly to your machine, bypassing haproxy, and getting the self signed cert... NOT the wildcard cert from LE.

I don't know what the solution to this is... maybe someone with more experience can chime in?

noplan

@capone

yes i fixed it

plain and simple the only thing i had to change in

domain = your domain
IP = ip your HaProxy is runnin on in this case the LAN IP of the firewall

and it is workin

let me know if u succeeded
brNP

capone

@noplan Thanks for the reply.

Naw... I've tried that. It doesn't work for my setup. Pfsense returns two IPs for that hostname...but the 1st IP is the real server IP...the 2nd IP is the 'override' ... besides I can't ssh into the server if the override IP is the only one that resolves for that hostname...

Just starting to accept the fact that this solution won't work for my setup.