Squid/SquidGuard NONE/409 and DNS issue
-
@shawn8888 Now you can start trying to get wpad working, then squidguard.
-
@kom
I will give it a couple of days to see if most of the problems can be solved in explicit mode before testing wpad again.
Thanks! -
@shawn8888 WPAD solves the problem of having to manually configure proxy setting on every device so it's kind of important to get it working. You can also push a proxy via DHCP option 252. I would do both, and don't forget to add your block rule on LAN to prevent people from going around the proxy.
-
After a week testing, I can confirm that NONE/409 issue is gone with the explicit mode. It seems that the issue only happens with the transparent mode.
WPAD is still a hit and miss. I will test it more later. Right now I set all the devices need to go through squid manually.
-
@shawn8888 @shawn8888 You can always try the Wpad Unofficial package https://github.com/marcelloc/Unofficial-pfSense-packages/tree/master/pkg-wpad
-
-
@shawn8888 I don't see any error. Did you look for the menu?
-
@kom
The install command, the last one, finishes in less than a second
I cannot find wpad in "Installed Packages" or any change on the menu. -
@shawn8888 first follow this step https://github.com/marcelloc/Unofficial-pfSense-packages
You have to first enable Unofficial pfSense packages
-
I ran the command in ssh. No change. Then I reboot pfsense. still the same. I don't know what I did wrong.
fetch -q -o /usr/local/etc/pkg/repos/Unofficial.conf https://raw.githubusercontent.com/marcelloc/Unofficial-pfSense-packages/master/Unofficial_25.conf -
@shawn8888 https://forum.netgate.com/topic/116163/unofficial-wpad-package-for-pfsense-software?_=1620716861139
-
Well seems like I am not the only one in the neighborhood having the same issue, at least with dynamic websites, under a transparent proxy with MITM Splice All. In documentation they should mention the consequences of having this setup with dynamic https websites. The idea that pass is that it should work without any issue, if configured as mention, but its not true, at all.
-
curious as to if there was ever a fix or a solution to this. I do have a bunch of NON/409 errors for various websites with Transparent Proxy configured. The solution is either to turn off the proxy and lose reporting or enable true MITM mode but for certain vlans where I can install the certificate thereby losing the effectiveness of the reporting
-
@michmoor I end up with a non transparent proxy, using an auto config proxy deployed through pfsense DHCP option 252, and that auto proxy config hosted in one Microsoft IIS, with a bunch of my pfsense IP gateways where squid is placed/responding.
On MacOS's I had to enable auto config proxy. Since than I didnt had any more issues. Squid cannot handle HTTPS well under transparent proxys.
Thinking in using a transparent proxy on pfsense through squid still gives me nightmares when I think about it....
-
@shawn8888 have you tried to creat a NAT rule to force all users to use the firewall for DNS?
Like this ??
After it doesn't matter what the devices try to use the firewall choses the DNS just change it to what your DNS server is and forget about it.
-
@jonathanlee make a alias with DNS ports
-
@jonathanlee also set WPAD up on the firewall
-
maybe a bit late answer but i also find such problem. And little exploring gives me a good solution.
(We a talking about Transparent Proxy + Splice all SSL mode)
So, first of all, the reason of such problem is one different addresses returned by DNS server
So, first of all Proxy should use the same DNS server as clients, so best way to do it is to use our firewall as DNS server (DNS Resolver turned on), so by DHCP we are setting primary DNS address of our firewall, also will be good to redirect all DNS requests to firewall address and block DoH (here article about DNS redirection "Redirecting Client DNS Requests"
And after this step lot of people says that it does not help, but why? the answer is simple, DNS RoundRobin, we are getting random ip address fore some websites even if we are using cache you can simply check it, if nslookup (for example for google.com, or twitch.tv or some other site which is not working) gives every time different address you will get 409 error.
So how to fix this part? we need to go to DNS Resolver settings, open custom options and add rrest-roundrobin:no which disables randomization of DNS entries. (it should be disabled by default but on pfsense looks like it's enabled)
-
Thanks for the reply,
I just tested this and I got a error,
Just to confirm rrest-roundrobin:no inside of the custom area.
This is the error I got kicked back.
-
@proggggger Another fix to issues with devices that have no option to configure a proxy is to configure DHCP option 252
This hands the proxy out also when it hands out the dhcp ip addresses. Make sure you have the proxy set up on wpad for this to work.
Example:https://192.168.1.1:8080/wpad.dat
is handed out with the dhcp address again if your wpad is set up to also hand out the dns server this fixes a lot of issues.
