Captive Portal / MAC Passthrough

gliddie

Thank you,

I just wait ;-)

brianc69

Has this bug been fixed yet? I just updated to 2.4 last night and having this same issue.

gliddie

Sorry, I just saw your message.
I dont think it had been fixed. But I also did not see something like that in the list of issues.
For me it is still not working

brianc69

Same here totally dead and a BIG security issue/inconvenience for me.

gliddie

You think so? I am impressed how good it is all ready.
Besides Captive Portal it works well for me. And my son loves the fact Captive Portal is disabled on my Pfsense

microtronx

My kids are loving also 2.4 … no mac on captiveportal ;-)

Does someone knows when we can expect a working mac authentication?

brianc69

It doesn't appear to be on the bug list either. Hopefully this is fixed soon. Its a real nightmare!

brianc69

I was quite surprised to see a public release today with a bug this big still present. I'd be more ok with it if it were a package add on but a core feature with a major regression?

jimp

This is only a problem on 2.4, where captive portal is not yet fully implemented.

The release today was 2.3.4. Not 2.4. No such issue in 2.3.x.

brianc69

My bad I read it wrong. Looking at the bug list though I don't see were this issue is even listed.

jimp

It is all a part of the captive portal reimplementation, which is this ticket:
https://redmine.pfsense.org/issues/6606

brianc69

I notice this ticket has been idle for quite awhile. Is it being worked on? Will this be resolved before the official release? Is there a rough ETA on release or fix or is it still aways off?

jimp

Yes, it is being worked on. It will be fixed before release.

microtronx

So, captive-portal and freeradius with IETF format of mac-addresses authentication has worked since update from yesterday.
Yesterdays / Todays update has updated freeradius to a newer version now it does not work anymore. We had to disable captiveportal to get internet-connection!

Is this a known bug? Before we had version from 2. may and everything was ok.

brianc69

Any updates on this? Last July ticket set to high priority. Still broke.

https://redmine.pfsense.org/issues/6606