Crash when enabling traffic shaper on more than 1 port

doktornotor

FreeBSD made a decision to not keep up with openbsd in regards to PF and ALTQ so they made the rod on their own back with that decision, the good news is that they have started to fix FreeBSD specific PF issues now and I would hope this includes ALTQ as well.

ALTQ has been gone from OpenBSD for years. http://undeadly.org/cgi?action=article&sid=20140419151959

xbipin

my crash log attached as follows, im also having same issue on client box when i enable shaping, sorry the log was too long to capture completely

crash.txt
crash2.txt

dotOne

A quick update from my side.
Both ALTQ and HFSC crash on 2.4.1 as well.
It doesn’t have to have any load. It crashes only seconds after reboot.

Will try to upload the crash info tonight.

chrcoluk

@doktornotor:

@chrcoluk:

FreeBSD made a decision to not keep up with openbsd in regards to PF and ALTQ so they made the rod on their own back with that decision, the good news is that they have started to fix FreeBSD specific PF issues now and I would hope this includes ALTQ as well.

ALTQ has been gone from OpenBSD for years. http://undeadly.org/cgi?action=article&sid=20140419151959

It is gone now yes, but before it was removed, it was updated and improved over what the version in FreeBSD is.

PiBa

Luiz fixed it.!. ;D

https://redmine.pfsense.org/issues/7879#note-3

At least after initial testing with and pushing some traffic through my queue's which seemed like a sure way to crash it before, i'm gone try and see how it holds up tomorrow :)

2.4.0-RC (amd64) 
built on Mon Sep 25 15:04:23 CDT 2017 
FreeBSD 11.0-RELEASE-p12

Perhaps some of you guy's here can also give it another testrun.? 8)

xbipin

i tried on 2 apu2 boxes and now works all good, can any1 point me to the actual commit that fixed this?

dotOne

It's running for a few hours now.
No crash since the reboot, so this looks promising.