Having issues with Acme and Cloudflare

[iPenguin]

I recently just switched my domain to be hosted by Cloudflare, previously google. I'm having issues getting a cert created for the domain and wildcard.

I have successfully setup DDNS with Cloudflare, if that matters at all.

Account Key is Production v2
I made sure to hit Create Key, then Register. Both returned with a green check.

Cert Options:
Private Key is set to 4096, but I have tried 2048 with no luck either.

For domain, I added the main domain and a second record for the wildcard *.domain.tld
Method is set to Cloudflare

I've tried with the Global API and my email only. I can see the TXT record be created, but get this weird icon with no error

I've tried with the API Token and Account ID added
Token is Zone:Zone:Read, Zone:DNS:Edit, Includes:Specific Zone:Mydomain (I have tried it with it set to all)
Same results here

I tried generating the cert without the wildcard, no luck either. I can see the TXT being created, but just get that icon