Multiple xboxes DayZ use to work but now it doesnt

[RadarG]

I have a weird pfsense,dayz,xbox problem. I have multiple xboxs in my home (4 in use) I have nat rules setup and rules to allow for our favorite xbox game Dayz. These rules allowed for us all to connect to the same Dayz server located at ip address 85.190.157.116 on port 11000. I bought a new xbox and swapped it out and now none of the rules are working (maybe the game company patched something on their end) but I have not confirmed this. I have the pcaps from both xboxes. It looks like the first xbox to connect can connect to the server just fine but when the second xbox tries to connect to the IP and port the dayz server doesnt respond back. I thought that the NAT rules and alternate ports on the xboxes prevented this Dayz is saying that the server is unreachable with an error code 0x00010001 this matches what I am seeing in the pcaps. I am using pfsense version 2.4.5p

[RadarG]

@radarg Observations:
UPNP rules are created when two of the xbox power up.
WAN udp any 57085 192.168.90.6 57085 Teredo 192.168.90.6:57085->57085 UDP
WAN udp any 55522 192.168.90.7 55522 Teredo 192.168.90.7:55522->55522 UDP

during the last packet capture. I noticed that the second xbox was trying to talk on the same random out bound port as the first xbox in this case port 23000

[RadarG]

@radarg My outbound port mappings are the following
Interface: WAN
Source: xboxgroup
Source port: *
Destination: *
Desination Port: *
Nat Address: WAN address
Nat port: *

[RadarG]

@radarg ok it looks like all the UPNP is working I see the rules pop up. Why would the second xbox try to talk to the same port at the first one? I thought that once the second xbox made contact with the server it would use a different port. Am I wrong?