Nat reflection

[ugur]

nat reflection not working on
1.2.3-RC2
built on Wed Jul 22 03:48:08 EDT 2009
FreeBSD 7.2-RELEASE-p2 i386

(disable nat reflection unchecked)

ps. like this config 1.2.2 and 1.2 running.

[GruensFroeschli]

Setup? Background? How did you test? Any changes in the config? Messages in the systemlog?

[ugur]

yes. exactly.

lan: 192.168.1.1
wan: 88.x.x.2
vip: 88.x.x.3/24 88.x.x.4/24 (…)
dmz: 10.6.1.1
web: 10.6.1.3 gw 10.6.1.1

nat outbound:
192.168.1.4/32 -> 88.x.x.4
10.6.1.3/32 -> 88.x.x.3

pfwd: wan/tcp/80 10.6.1.3/88.x.x.3

lan: all port open
dmz: all port open
wan: all to 10.6.1.3 port 80 open

nat refl.: unchecked

and
i use pf 1.5+ years
and
this config running 1.2 and 1.2.2 (no nat reflection problem)

[tracer]

We're seeing a similar thing, it either doesn't work, or ports are mixed up.
Meaning we're doing Port forwards with aliases, where more than one port is redirected.
Is this legal ?

thanks in advance