Floating Rules Reordering On Their Own (Non-pfB autorules)
-
Hello there,
I'm trying to set up some Alias Native rules in my Floating Rules in pfSense. I do not use pfBlocker's auto rules at all, as I like to control the rules individually myself.
I seem to have run into an issue where my floating rules seemingly reorder themselves once a certain number is reached. See my screenshots below.
Before adding too many:
Note my limiter at the bottom, and the block/reject rules above.
After adding 13 or so, the rules reorder themselves and I cannot get them to maintain their order:
I can rearrange and save the rules but they do not maintain their order until after I delete a rule or two.
As I stated all of my IP rules are set to Alias Native in pfblocker so I shouldn't need to be concerned with the auto ordering here.
Is this a legitimate bug?
Just a note, I tried this on both 24.03 and 24.11 beta/RC. -
Does it persist after a reboot? Are there changes being made from different logins/tabs?
-
@marcosm
Yes, it does persist after a reboot. I double checked the config xml file and the rules get reordered there as well.I made sure to only have one tab open, and even cleared my cookies/cache and tried a different browser with the same outcome.
-
So to be clear you are also seeing that happen in 24.03?
And do you have MIM enabled in 24.11?
-
@stephenw10 Yes, that's correct. I upgraded to the beta initially to see if that would fix the issue, deleted my rules, and retired which led to the same result.
I do not use MIM, I currently only have a single instance running on bare metal locally.
-
deleted my rules
Which rules - the same rules, or all rules on all interfaces?
It shouldn't make a difference, but are there existing rules in
/cf/conf/config.xmlwhich use an interface that doesn't exist?Are you able to reproduce this starting from a fresh configuration? If so, would you provide exact steps?
