Atheros WLAN card without ath0: device timeout or fix it for me- 25$
-
I tried 3 different atheros cards (9280, 9287, 9281), all 3 end up with "ath0: device timeout" in infrastructure (client) mode after some time.
Your task:
Recommend me a an atheros based mini pcie card (full or half height), that does not have this problem, supports at least g mode (54 mbit/s), wpa2 and has 2 antenna connectors. The card has to be available in stock in a german onlineshop with a good reputation for max. 50 EUR.I will test the card one week for stability in general using infrastructure (client) mode (it does not help me if the card then has another problem), if all works fine, I will pay 25$ to you.
Alternative:
Provide me a solution for one of my existing cards (9280, 9287, 9281 based). Solution should survive pfsense upgrades etc. Explain me your solution on a high level, then we will see if it would be OK for me and then we can think about implementing your proposed solution. -
Instead put your bounty towards a cheap router that is flashable to your choice of WRT-based distribution (but not DD).
Consider money spent on cards as a learning experience, they can still work as client cards in laptops :)Put it on one of your LAN subnets or ideally give it its own interface. (wifi security track record is terrible, even current "safe" WPA2/AES is brute forcible without a longer password, gpus are monsters these days)
Yes its another device to manage, but you will get much better end results, at the very least least N support if not more.
-
Yeah, I already have a WLAN router, but I am lacking some space in general or lets say it doesn't look very nice to have dozens of devices ;-) BTW why no DD-WRT?
As there has to be some working card, I am still looking for a solution ;-) -
Yeah, I already have a WLAN router, but I am lacking some space in general or lets say it doesn't look very nice to have dozens of devices ;-) BTW why no DD-WRT?
As there has to be some working card, I am still looking for a solution ;-)Not going to start a ddwrt flame on pfsense forum, going to leave it at wouldn't touch it with a ten foot pole. Still better than a lot of the absolutely broken consumer firmware I suppose.
There is no confirmed working pci express card in 2.0.3 or 2.1. (for most atheros chipsets, I probably own a card with it)
Your solution is basically to wait for the next major release and /crossfingers. -
Sorry I am confused, you dismissed the possibility of using a separate wireless router but you want to get infrastructure client mode working, what are you trying to achieve? Using the wireless card in your pfSense to become a wireless access point? Or for your pfSense to become a wireless client connected wirelessly to another wireless access point?
Either way I use mine in HOST AP mode so my pfSense acts as the wireless AP that client devices connect to. I was under the impression "Infrastructure Client" mode is for making your pfSense a wireless client, which connects to another device acting as a wireless access point.
I am 90% certain the one I am using myself is this one http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/ASUS-B53F-C1B-wireless-module-new-genuine-/130598853538 - but I use mine in HOSTAP mode ("Access Point" now in the interface), not client.
I pulled it out of my Asus B53F notebook. Also I can't say with absolute certainty but I think before that (again, in HOSTAP) I was using the one I pulled from an old Apple Mac Mini, although there is no promise they only ever shipped with one version of card the model I had can be googled as "macmini2,1"
If this is helps you achieve your goal please donate the bounty to the pfSense community, not me personally.
-
I hereby close this bounty, I gave up and ended up using a wlan router at each pfsense box.
@jonesr:
I need both, infratructure and access point. access point seems to work quite well though. infrastructure however is a total pity ): -
@jonesr:
I need both, infratructure and access point.No wonder I was confused then. Sorry I couldn't be of help in that case.
-
well, you tried it and I appreciate this :-)