Firewall blocking too much?

Tomasu

the only strange thing in your setup is the 192.168.1.1 as dns in general settings. even that should not let in the icmp…

this is really weird.

you said that there were some NAT rule. can we see those?

I added 192.168.1.1 as an extra DNS server, since I want to use the repeater even on the firewall.

Nat Port Forward Rules:

The 1:1 and Outbound rules are empty (Automatic outbound nat is enabled)

EDIT:

Heres an interesting bit of log info:
And clicking on the green arrow at the left shows no rule triggered it. The text after the "The rule that triggered this action is:" is missing. Theres several logs like that. The wan rule for that ip forward is not set to log, and there is no lan rule corresponding for anything resembling that packet.