Openvpn issue - site 2 site

maverick_slo

Please confirm my problems if you dont Im probably crazy :)
Ah at least friday is here :)

maverick_slo

About topology…
Mentioned it here: https://forum.pfsense.org/index.php?topic=105341.msg587367#msg587367 but nobody bite it :)

Steve_B

Fix was just pushed.

Please gitsync and let me know if it helped

maverick_slo

No dice:

SERVER:

Jan 21 18:20:14 	openvpn 	64463 	clientIP:38832 SIGUSR1[soft,tls-error] received, client-instance restarting
Jan 21 18:20:14 	openvpn 	64463 	clientIP:38832 TLS Error: TLS handshake failed
Jan 21 18:20:14 	openvpn 	64463 	clientIP:38832 TLS Error: TLS object -> incoming plaintext read error
Jan 21 18:20:14 	openvpn 	64463 	clientIP:38832 TLS_ERROR: BIO read tls_read_plaintext error: error:140890B2:SSL routines:SSL3_GET_CLIENT_CERTIFICATE:no certificate returned
Jan 21 18:20:14 	openvpn 	64463 	clientIP:38832 VERIFY SCRIPT ERROR: depth=1, C=SI, ST=VL, L=VL, O=IT, emailAddress=grega@domain.eu, CN=Internal CA
Jan 21 18:20:14 	openvpn 	64463 	clientIP:38832 WARNING: Failed running command (--tls-verify script): external program exited with error status: 1

I did not change anything, I just re-saved config on 2.3 server after gitsync.

Steve_B

Does the openvpn config file still have "topology subnet" at the end?

maverick_slo

Yes.

Steve_B

Then I suspect that either the gitsync was too early, or you need to reboot.

It is no longer in my config file. I created a new server and tested with that.

maverick_slo

one sec, trying again

maverick_slo

gitsynced,rebooted and topology subnet still there.
I deleted server and added new one, still there?

Steve_B

OK. First let's make sure you really did get the updated file.

please use Diagnostics->Edit file and open the file /etc/inc/openvpn.inc Then using the new GoTo control, go to line 1066.

You should see:

// If the server is not a TLS server or it has a tunnel network CIDR less than a /30, skip this.

If not, that file is not up to date.

(Your CIDR is 30, so it should skip adding the topology line

maverick_slo

I changed cidr to /24 does that change things?

Steve_B

Yes it does. Change it back to 30 and the topology subnet should go away.

maverick_slo

Ok but shouldnt it also work with 24?
2.2.6 to 2.2.6 did just fine?

Steve_B

I don't know, but to get to the bottom of your issue, lets just change one thing at a time, or it gets too complicated.

Lets make sure that the openvpn config file in /var/etc is absolutely identical 2.2.6 vs 2.3

Once we get there, we know the GUI and the OpenVPN subsystem are good. About all that is left is firewall rules and route.

maverick_slo

Steve, with /30 tunnell now works :)
Ssl tls.
Still no joy with /24
But we made progress :)

Steve_B

Cool

maverick_slo

So what's next? :)

Steve_B

Now need to see all the settings from both sides when set to /24. SSL/TLS with a /24 requires a lot more setup. (Client-specific overrides with remote nets/iroutes, client can't have a tunnel network or remote networks set, server needs local network set to push routes, plus remote set for client LAN…etc)

We tightened up a lot of that stuff in 2.3 and you may be running afoul of that. To some extent, things that shouldn't work now don't, whereas in prior versions they might :)

maverick_slo

Well that explains it :)

maverick_slo

Probably this explains it why shared key worked:

IPv4 Tunnel Network : The suggested default in the GUI of 10.0.8.0/24 is sufficient, but any random unused network inside of the RFC1918 space is recommended. For site-to-site shared key, only a /30 is used, not a /24, even if /24 is specified.

Taken from: https://doc.pfsense.org/index.php/OpenVPN_Site_To_Site