Dell Wyse 5070
-
@sledge said in Dell Wyse 5070:
Is the QAT and AES-GCM-128 really making up that much of the difference?
It absolutely could be. What VPN settings are you using?
-
@sledge said in Dell Wyse 5070:
What I don't understand is why the 6100 can report 552 Mbps VPN throughput on IMIX traffic and it has a lower passmark score, yet the Wyse with a higher score is only getting about half that value.
I'm guessing that the other user was talking about speeds in OpenVPN tunnel or he has an Intel Celeron version maybe.
Mine has Intel Pentium Silver J5005, I'm paying for 600 Mbps down / 120 up. With WireGuard tunnel to Mullvad VPN I can easily achieve over 500 Mbps down and over 100 Mbps up (and that's with CoDel limiters for bufferbloat enabled) -
@stephenw10 said in Dell Wyse 5070:
@sledge said in Dell Wyse 5070:
Is the QAT and AES-GCM-128 really making up that much of the difference?
It absolutely could be. What VPN settings are you using?
The Wyse is @USofA1984's machine, not mine, so I will defer to him on VPN settings.
I was just making the observation as I am trying to decide on what device I want to use for my firewall/router and the Wyse was an interesting option to me.
Out of curiosity is QAT something built into select processors, or can it be added with a PCI card? If built-in, how do I go about finding which processors have it? And if a card, are certain ones supported by pfSense? Lastly, I am not yet aware all the differences between pfSense and pfSense+ but could see these being a + feature. Is that true?
-
Ah, yes they're connected to PIA so almost certainly OpenVPN. Much slower than IPSec with QAT acceleration.
QAT is on-die in some CPUs like the Atom C3000 but can also be a separate device on a card. There are several QAT devices with varying capabilities.
Steve
-
@emikaadeo said in Dell Wyse 5070:
I'm guessing that the other user was talking about speeds in OpenVPN tunnel or he has an Intel Celeron version maybe.
Mine has Intel Pentium Silver J5005, I'm paying for 600 Mbps down / 120 up. With WireGuard tunnel to Mullvad VPN I can easily achieve over 500 Mbps down and over 100 Mbps up (and that's with CoDel limiters for bufferbloat enabled)Sorry for the delay, to answer the question, yes, I'm using OpenVPN for my VPN tunnel, and the Dell Wyse 5070 does have the Intel Pentium Silver J5005, with a single 4GB DDR4 Stick of Ram and using the onboard 16GB eMMC drive.
SJ
-
@emikaadeo said in Dell Wyse 5070:
I'm paying for 600 Mbps down / 120 up. With WireGuard tunnel to Mullvad VPN I can easily achieve over 500 Mbps down and over 100 Mbps up (and that's with CoDel limiters for bufferbloat enabled)
Upon searching for how to go about setting up Wireguard via PIA on my Dell Wyse 5070 running PFSense to see if I could obtain better throughput, I found this thread, which leads me to believe that I won't be doing so anytime soon?:
https://forum.netgate.com/topic/162198/wireguard-removed-from-pfsense-ce-and-pfsense-plus-software/28
SJ
-
It available again as a package so you can use it with any provider that has Wireguard.
Steve
-
@usofa1984
Why not? There's a pfSense WireGuard package.
How-To for remote VPN providers: https://docs.netgate.com/pfsense/en/latest/recipes/wireguard-client.html -
As @stephenw10 and @emikaadeo pointed out, it's back in 2.06 CE / 22.01 Plus. I'm new to this platform but my rough mile high overview was it was rushed, pulled and then re-released once it was fixed. I noticed the post you linked was from 2021 and think you caught old news.
-
@stephenw10 said in Dell Wyse 5070:
It available again as a package so you can use it with any provider that has Wireguard.
Guess I need to pay better attention to the dates of post.
Thank you to all of you who pointed this out to me.
I guess I know what my project is this weekend.
Hopefully I can get this to work with PIA and see faster throughput
thanks again,
SJ -
@stephenw10 said in Dell Wyse 5070:
It available again as a package so you can use it with any provider that has Wireguard.
Just installed the package, and see this.... I see it's 'experimental' at this time. I'll give it a go, and see what I can break :)
-
@usofa1984 I have another thread and someone had made a comment about Wireguard and not trusting it yet. I asked for a deeper explanation but got no response. I am thinking this may be why.
I’m new and still learning but to my inexperience this screams use in a test environment or for non-sensitive transmissions. Of course if they weren’t sensitive then you probably wouldn’t be using VPN.
Hoping others will chime in.
-
I am using Lenovo M900
I have an M91P Desktop standing by but I assume the power consumption is lower for the Tiny :) -
@charlesdevis My Dell Wyse 5070 consumes 8W per the TP-Link HS-300 power strip that it’s plugged into:
(screen shot is from my Sense device that reads power stats from the powerstrip)
While my Asus RT-AC86U consumes 9W of power
