WAN DHCP - N/A IP

stephenw10

Does the WAN appear to be down when dhclient initially runs then?

I recall seeing this before where you can hit a timing issue if the WAN comes UP between the dhclient initially failing but before boot has finished.

If you replug the WAN cable after this has happened does that then trigger the dhclient to start again and works correctly?

Steve

zander99

@stephenw10 Replug of the cable helps.
It seems WAN interface somehow appears to be up during the boot (even though switch is not yet initialized), if I understand this log lines correctly.

Nov  8 12:17:30 pfSense check_reload_status[408]: Linkup starting igc0
Nov  8 12:17:30 pfSense kernel:
Nov  8 12:17:30 pfSense kernel: igc0: link state changed to UP

And after that there is and error:

pfSense php[430]: rc.bootup: The command '/sbin/dhclient -c /var/etc/dhclient_wan.conf igc0 > /tmp/igc0_output 2> /tmp/igc0_error_output' returned exit code '1', the output was ''

stephenw10

If the link is actually down the dhclient will fail because it cannot run. If the interface is up dhclient can run even if it can't pull a lease and should just continue to try until it gets a lease.
The fact it;s failing implies igc was down at that point but the logs showing it come up are before that at boot?

zander99

system-boot.log.zip @stephenw10 Yes, looks like it. Attaching a more complete log.

stephenw10

Yes, that looks familiar. So igc1 and the VLANs on it are connected to the same switch?

zander99

@stephenw10 Yes, everything is on one switch.
igc0 - WAN interface (connected to 16 RJ-45 port, that is on one VLAN with 18 SFP port).
igc1 - LAN trunk port connected to port #15 of the switch.

stephenw10

Hmm, what you're describing is exactly this: https://redmine.pfsense.org/issues/9484

That is reported as solved some time ago though. What advanced settings in the dhcp client config did you test?

Steve

zander99

@stephenw10 initially tried with default options. Then tried with increased timeout (set to 120), also tried to set reboot=60.
If there are any suggestions for dhclient - I can try and play with them.

stephenw10

Ah, yes I knew this was familiar. Setting a boot delay will probably fix this, see:
https://forum.netgate.com/post/1038593

This probably needs a bug opening/re-opening though, let me see....

zander99

@stephenw10 Yes, boot delay solves an issue. I’ve tested today, thanks for help @biggsy

If there are any additional info that I can provide in order to isolate/understand the exact cause of the issue I would be happy to help.

stephenw10

It would be interesting to try a much longer timeout in the dhcp settings instead, The suggested 900s for example. However I don't expect that to work since the timing difference in the logs is only ~15s. A setting of 120s would have worked if it could.

Steve