Access point recommendations?

johnpoz

@NogBadTheBad wouldn't call it a curve ball - the 22 or the 25 would be what I would look at.. Seems a bit more price than the unifi or omada.. But its not crazy different..

keyser

@johnpoz But the Instant on is sooo much more simple and elegant in management for home users than the Unify AP’s.

DominikHoffmann

I do like the Ubiquiti equipment very much and have installed for a few clients. I myself have access points from EnGenius. Their support recently improved, which makes them a viable option. I have four of them in my home.

Head on over to GrabCAD, if you are interested in a copy of an STL of the bracket I designed that can mount the EnGenius AP to a 2-gang electrical box.

tgl

@DominikHoffmann
Another UniFi user here. I have 3 U6-Enterprise APs, which are a tad pricier than other U6 models but have 6E support, and I've been pretty pleased with them for the 6 months or so I've had them.

I would not recommend trying the U7 yet --- price is sky-high and they seem to still be getting the bugs out.

johnpoz

@tgl I read something that they get pretty freaking hot as well, especially when updating or something... I don't pay a lot of attention to those since I don't have one and not in the market even.. But I do recall seeing some issues people are having with them.

And they make noise? That was the U7s doing that right?

tgl

@johnpoz
Ubiquiti definitely design their equipment to run hotter than most other manufacturers do. I've not heard that they have reliability problems, so maybe they know what they're doing. But I'd recommend making sure there's good airflow around any of their gear. My U6s get uncomfortably warm to the touch (maybe about 130F?) on the rear mounting plate, but they seem happy anyway.

The U7's have a fan, not sure about its noise level offhand. Mine don't, and I've not heard that any other Ubiquiti APs do. There are noisy fans in many of their switches and routers, too.

johnpoz

@tgl here you go on the unifi forums post about the noise of the fan in the U7

https://www.reddit.com/r/Ubiquiti/comments/1bfe7n9/u7pro_very_loud/

I have 3 unifi myself, but not any of the newer ones - they don't make a sound.. They haven't caught the house on fire yet ;) but not sure how warm they get they are in the ceiling (where APs belong) hehehe

If I was actually in the market to change mine out, I would prob pick up a few different ones and check them out - the EAP660 HD, the omada line seems like a great price for its feature set.. Does it perform up to its specs, not sure - but be worth checking out, if I was in the market.. Or if one mine died.. UAP-AC-Pro, lite and LR.

netboy

@johnpoz I have 2 APs TP-Link EAP615-Wall and have been using it for 3 years now without no issues. However, it does not have USB

JonathanLee

@netboy can you disable the tp-link cloud constant connections? I had to send my tplink back because it wouldn’t stop connecting to something I never approved

netboy

@JonathanLee It is connected ONLY to my router using a wired connection. It does not connect directly to the cloud AFIK

JonathanLee

@netboy mine TP link was to something dev cloud or something who knows I sent it back to get a new one. Something was mixed up

netboy

@JonathanLee I checked yes you can disable the cloud access

JonathanLee

@netboy mine did not have those options, if it did I would have kept it, mine was stuck on all the time. You could see it in logs but couldn’t turn it off. Drove me tinfoil hat crazy, it was filling my logs up

netboy

@JonathanLee This has been rock solid!!!
4 Gigabit Ethernet Ports: 1× Uplink 802.3 af/at PoE powered port, 3× Downlink ports, with one access port supporting PoE pass-through to provide power for a wired device, making deployment effortless and flexible

The price is right too around $90

JonathanLee

@netboy I got a new one coming, ultimately want to install OpenWRT on it as I can get more experience with programming

Dobby_

@JonathanLee said in Access point recommendations?:

want to install OpenWRT

You are on the way to search for this device I am thinking.
Banana PI BPI-R4

Debian
Ubuntu
OpenWRT
(WiFi6 and/or WiFi7) should be running there if the boards will be more
available in the public. Because this boards are brand "new".

The second one is more for data holding, let us call it. But you were
also looking for a small NAS as I am right here. Please have a look.
FriendlyElec CM3588
You can install much more systems and they have all preconfigured
images for any kind of install media (SD card, eMMC and M.2 SSD)
Images for CM3588

Android
Android TV
Debian
Ubuntu
OpenMediaVault
FriendlyWRT 21.x and 23.x (OpenWRT variant matching this board)

Perhaps it is something for you?

JonathanLee

@Dobby_ YES!!!

Dobby_

@JonathanLee

First test of my TurrisOmnia with TurrisOS (based on OpenWRT)
I got mine used for around 200 €, I added a WiFi and modem card.
SFP Glasfasermodem and two SFP to eth modules are on its way.

coxhaus

@JonathanLee
I am a Cisco fan boy. I use all Cisco small business networking equipment as you get firmware support for the life of the product. I use a Cisco layer 3 switch and Cisco APs.

I like the Cisco 150ax 2x2 WiFi 6 APs. They are cheap and they come in 5 packs. I think around $102 each at least the last time I bought one. They are so cheap you can add one to every important room so you have high speed WiFi. I use 3 and may add a 4th.

My old Cisco WAP581 APs were 4x4 and covered better but cost more. You can add more Cisco 150ax APs for less money and have better coverage.

PS
The Cisco 150ax APs download code from the cloud so it takes a few minutes if they go offline. It is not a problem for me as I have an APC battery smart backup. My Cisco APs never go offline if there is a power outage. I have 5 hours of backup.

coxhaus

@johnpoz
I had a Cisco AP run hot and it turned out it was the cable I bought off Amazon. I bought a different cable local and it did not run as hot. How I knew is my other Cisco AP was not running hot. I assume the CAT cable really did not meet spec. I don't buy CAT cables off Amazon any more.

I had run out of CAT6 cables and I needed a 50 footer. I bought it from Amazon