Bogon Alias address created for pppoe WAN

dandare100

@Bob-Dig Done and it matches the public ip in pfsense, thanks

dandare100

@Gertjan Thank you for the explanation, makes sense.

It just seems weird that the ISP is assigning the "100.64.0.225" as the gateway for a pppoe interface with a public ip address.

I understand that I am not a network fundi :-) and that this setup may be completely normal, I am just trying to understand the setup because it was not previously like that.

Bob.Dig

@dandare100 It is just efficient. Your ISP is saving on public-IPv4-space.

My WAN looks like this.

IPv4 Address
    46.*.*.* 
Subnet mask IPv4
    255.255.255.255 
Gateway IPv4
    94.*.*.*

You can see, there is no relationship between the IP-address on my WAN and its gateway.

dandare100

@Bob-Dig Ok cool. Thank you. I understand now and will let it go.

Thanks for the patience guys

johnpoz

@Bob-Dig said in Bogon Alias address created for pppoe WAN:

You can see, there is no relationship between the IP-address on my WAN and its gateway.

I wouldn't say that - that is not how a typical network is setup.. Normally the gateway off a network, needs to be on the network your trying to get off of, how else would you get there. But yes you can go against normal practice. Multiple layer3 on the same layer 2.. Where the IP is different layer 3 but your on the same layer 2 network so the client can get the mac of its gateway.

PPPoe is a tunnel so its a bit different. But normally the gateway would and should be on the same network space.. If its not you normally have to let the client know this.

If you go into routing and, and look at your dhcp gateway - if that IP is outside your network you get - you would normally have to set this.

https://docs.netgate.com/pfsense/en/latest/routing/gateway-configure.html#advanced-gateway-settings

The Use non-local gateway through interface specific route option allows a non-standard configuration where a gateway IP address exists outside of an interface subnet. Some providers attempting to scrape the bottom of the IPv4 barrel have resorted to this in order to not put a gateway into each customer subnet. Do not activate this option unless required to do so by the upstream provider.

Normally if you manually set that - the OS should scream at you.

So while it "can" be done - it is not your typical setup..

When a client decides that hey this IP is not on my network, I need to send it to my gateway - it would arp for the mac address of the gateway (that is on its network) and send the traffic there.. In a typical setup if the gateway is not on the same network, how would the client get the mac to actually send the traffic to.. So there are some caveats to be sure if doing such a setup.. So please don't get the idea that you can make your network 192.168.1.0/24 and just set a gateway as 192.168.2.1 and it will work.

Bob.Dig

@johnpoz said in Bogon Alias address created for pppoe WAN:

When a client decides that hey this IP is not on my network, I need to send it to my gateway - it would arp for the mac address of the gateway (that is on its network) and send the traffic there.. In a typical setup if the gateway is not on the same network, how would the client get the mac to actually send the traffic to..

@johnpoz I am curious. Normally it would arp for the MAC of the gateway. Now when this is not on its network, it would still arp for the MAC of the gateway? So it is basically the same? What are the caveats of this approach.

johnpoz

@Bob-Dig clients don't normally arp for an IP that is not on their own network. This is why you need to tell the device - hey that is your gateway you can talk to it on the same L2 network, so you can get the mac if you arp.

Bob.Dig

@johnpoz So it is basically the same.
I am asking because I have a VPS and proxmox on it. The VPS-Provider gave the following, single IP-configuration: IP 5.5.5.5/24, Gateway 5.5.5.1

In Proxmox, the local subnet has more rights, for instance, it doesn't get blocked if it uses the wrong credentials too many times.
That is why I changed the network config on that VPS to be: IP 5.5.5.5/32, Gateway 5.5.5.1

No questions asked, it just works (Debian).

Bob.Dig

@johnpoz said in DNS Rebind attack conditions doesn't make sense:

if pfsense has no portward to itself then it must think that IP is his.

Really, his?

johnpoz

@Bob-Dig You can set the gateway to any IP you want, but its not a normal, typical setup - and like the warning I showed you - the OS thinks you must of made a typo ;) It might still arp for it since its gateway IP and has to be reachable on the same L2

But you can not be sure device or OS will do that. Nor can you be sure what your arping for will answer if the IP is not on the gateways network IP range.