NUT suddenly stops working every app. 6 minutes

j.koopmann

@Gertjan I agree. I suppose you disconnected and then reconnected?

When I restart via pfsense and then kill the driver and manually restart it with -DDD upsmon either does not notice the problem or recovers automatically. Which is why I am puzzled that exactly this did not happen. And yes I suspect an error in upsmon. But I am not experienced enough to dig into the source code.

Gertjan

@j-koopmann said in NUT suddenly stops working every app. 6 minutes:

then kill the driver

That can/will not happen in reality ?! right ?

It probably happens when processes get restarted because there was an Interface event somewhere.
For me, that's against my "church rules". It says : as the admin, do everything, and more, so that interfaces always say up. No exceptions allowed.
And I'm not allowed to believe.
I have to fact check myself being my own big-brother - click and see for yourself.
That's why I use an UPS btw ^^

edit : the stats have a granularity (?) of '300 seconds'. That elmans that smaller outages are possible a can go unnoticed in stats.
But I'm a "good admin", I rarely look at the dashboard page. I look at the logs, as that is place where the real fun is being showed.

j.koopmann

@Gertjan said in NUT suddenly stops working every app. 6 minutes:

That can/will not happen in reality ?! right ?

I hope not. Only reason for me doing it currently is to have more debug output and see if the underlying problem is in the USB communication between the driver and the UPS (which was speculated but I believe not to be the case so far) or somewhere else.

I just wanted to second your conclusion (at least I believe). If the USB connection goes away and comes back upsmon regularly is fine. Even if I kill the driver and get it back online, upsmon is fine. Not so this morning however.

Gertjan

@j-koopmann

Normally, I don't checkup with my 4100 all the time : as long as PC applications that need a connection, work fine, I can work (which doesnt' include pfSense baby sitting).

I do have this on :

= WinNut 2.0 client on my desktop.

And it does happen that is shows this :

so I know I have to go to pfSense and start UPS again as it failed 'for some reason'.
Now I'm thinking about it, this happens more often then the wished for 'never' ^^

j.koopmann

@Gertjan Welcome to my world. I have this on my unraid server and get the occasional "UPS is not responding" which led me to start this thread in the first place... :-)

Gertjan

@j-koopmann

Up until now I always thought it was me, the UPS series of processes get restarted, and because it's more then one thing (process) that gets restarted I didn't give it a lot of thought. Happely enough my power utility company is pretty stable (France here).
That said, I might also be me who causes it, as I'm messing around a lot with my pfSense box. And it do make failures ... (more and more btw).
Just yesterday, was doing 'something' and I lost all IPv4 traffic on all interfaces. IPv6 was ok. A nice test to see what works, and what doesn't. Google, Netflix, Most Microsoft sites : ok. Other sites like expedia and other hotel related productivity sites didn't show up anymore. DNS was doing great, and it showed me that everything goes overv IPv6 by default, as IPv4 has become the 'fall back' network.
I quickly discovered that my phone busing the carrier 5G was ok (same operator), so it was 'me'.
Normally, I would say : great, a self inflicted problem, let's debug that, but as my connection is also the connection of the company, things went out of control rapidly. Clients got to the desk to say that my (free) wifi sucks ... so I fired back that I was working on the quality / price of the wifi and the ones who followed math beyond 11 years would know instantly that I'm telling them to f up. something that is, I know, not a very mature neither professional thing to do.
Anyway : I used Plan Z : I rebooted from as safe ZFS partition, and I was back up in no time, but this took away an occasion to find out what happened (where I fcked up).

j.koopmann

@Gertjan I know what you mean. And same here. :-)

In this case however it is just a great annoyance. I could restart nut every x hours to be on the safe side. And it's a first world problem as the UPS itself still works even if nut is not there and my PV battery at least in the summer should be ok for many minutes to hours as a backup as well.

but.... A service that should be there stably and is not is an annoyance. :-) And I would love to understand the underlying problem. The more I debug this the less it looks like "a usb cable problem" which was the first (understandable) suspicion.

dennypage

@j-koopmann said in NUT suddenly stops working every app. 6 minutes:

Started happening again (not that frequently but still...)

Today I noticed it stopped around 6:30.

upsmon 89561 - - Poll UPS [Keller] failed - Protocol error

The usbhid-ups was still running. I killed it and restarted it with -DDD. As always it comes up flawlessly and communicates with the UPS. BUT upsmon continues to show Protocol errors. That is new (to me). Once usbhid-ups is back again (started with -a Keller of course) usbmon should be able to reestablish connection to it. In this case it failes!

After restarting usbmon and usbhid-ups things come back. Why is usbmon showing a protocol error when usbhid-ups clearly is running and showing no errors and has a clearly established communication with the UPS?

This is not related to usbhid-ups. The protocol error in question is between upsmon and upsd. usbhid-ups does not communicate directly with upsmon.

If you see this again, run upsc, which also talks directly with upsd, and confirm that you can see values for the UPS.

In general, this is indicative of a bug in NUT itself. What version of pfSense and NUT are you running? Do you see any other log entries for upsd or upsmon in the system log?

j.koopmann

@dennypage said in NUT suddenly stops working every app. 6 minutes:

This is not related to usbhid-ups. The protocol error in question is between upsmon and upsd. usbhid-ups does not communicate directly with upsmon.

Agreed.

If you see this again, run upsc, which also talks directly with upsd, and confirm that you can see values for the UPS.

Good hint. Thanks. Will do!

In general, this is indicative of a bug in NUT itself. What version of pfSense and NUT are you running? Do you see any other log entries for upsd or upsmon in the system log?

Again: Agreed and my thesis from the start. :-)

24.11-RELEASE
nut package 2.8.2_4

dennypage

@j-koopmann said in NUT suddenly stops working every app. 6 minutes:

Again: Agreed and my thesis from the start. :-)

24.11-RELEASE
nut package 2.8.2_4

I see that this information was discussed above. I've been traveling the past three plus weeks, so it's been hard to keep track of things. Sorry.

dennypage

@j-koopmann Checking on the prior issue for a moment... Were you able to implement a quirk? Are you still having issues with usbhid-ups?

j.koopmann

@dennypage I honestly never had a problem with usbhid-ups (so I believe). Whenever I start it it immediately recognizes my UPS. It is currently running as user nut and I never installed a quirk.

upsmon 75628 - - Signal 15: exiting
upsd 24479 - - Signal 15: exiting

But these are due to interface WAN IP changes that restart all services.

At one point other the other I get

psmon 89561 - - UPS [Keller]: connect failed: Connection failure: Connection refused

(even though usbhid-ups seems to be running) and
then

<27>1 2025-06-26T08:48:50.206377+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - UPS [Keller]: connect failed: Connection failure: Connection refused
<27>1 2025-06-26T08:48:55.275466+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - Set password on [Keller] failed - got [PASSWORD 66da6bc012db26058161]
<27>1 2025-06-26T08:49:00.279702+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - Poll UPS [Keller] failed - Protocol error
<27>1 2025-06-26T08:49:05.280772+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - Poll UPS [Keller] failed - Protocol error
<27>1 2025-06-26T08:49:10.285154+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - Poll UPS [Keller] failed - Protocol error
<27>1 2025-06-26T08:49:15.287439+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - Poll UPS [Keller] failed - Protocol error
<27>1 2025-06-26T08:49:20.292291+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - Poll UPS [Keller] failed - Protocol error
<27>1 2025-06-26T08:49:25.301818+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - Poll UPS [Keller] failed - Protocol error
<27>1 2025-06-26T08:49:30.303758+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - Poll UPS [Keller] failed - Protocol error
<27>1 2025-06-26T08:49:35.304766+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - Poll UPS [Keller] failed - Protocol error
<27>1 2025-06-26T08:49:40.308262+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - Poll UPS [Keller] failed - Protocol error
<27>1 2025-06-26T08:49:45.323762+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - Poll UPS [Keller] failed - Protocol error
<27>1 2025-06-26T08:49:50.325535+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - Poll UPS [Keller] failed - Protocol error
<27>1 2025-06-26T08:49:55.330127+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - Poll UPS [Keller] failed - Protocol error
<27>1 2025-06-26T08:50:00.337898+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - Poll UPS [Keller] failed - Protocol error
<27>1 2025-06-26T08:50:05.343880+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - Poll UPS [Keller] failed - Protocol error
<27>1 2025-06-26T08:50:10.367770+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - Poll UPS [Keller] failed - Protocol error
<27>1 2025-06-26T08:50:15.370222+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - Poll UPS [Keller] failed - Protocol error
<27>1 2025-06-26T08:50:20.473811+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - Poll UPS [Keller] failed - Protocol error
<27>1 2025-06-26T08:50:25.475779+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - Poll UPS [Keller] failed - Protocol error
<29>1 2025-06-26T08:50:25.475839+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - UPS Keller is unavailable
<27>1 2025-06-26T08:50:30.480347+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - Poll UPS [Keller] failed - Protocol error

dennypage

@j-koopmann said in NUT suddenly stops working every app. 6 minutes:

<27>1 2025-06-26T08:48:50.206377+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - UPS [Keller]: connect failed: Connection failure: Connection refused
<27>1 2025-06-26T08:48:55.275466+02:00 pfSenseHills.koopmann.local upsmon 89561 - - Set password on [Keller] failed - got [PASSWORD 66da6bc012db26058161]

Okay, that is entertaining to say the least. Does "66da6bc012db26058161" happen to be the locally generated password for local-monitor?

The next time the protocol error happens, would you please report the start time of the upsd and upsmon processes, plus the mod time and contents of these two files:

/usr/local/etc/nut/upsd.users 
/usr/local/etc/nut/upsmon.conf

After capturing that information, run

/usr/local/sbin/upsd -c reload

and see if the protocol error stops.

If it doesn't, then run

/usr/local/sbin/upsmon -c reload

and see if that stops it.

Thanks.

j.koopmann

@dennypage said in NUT suddenly stops working every app. 6 minutes:

Okay, that is entertaining to say the least. Does "66da6bc012db26058161" happen to be the locally generated password for local-monitor?

I have not the slightest idea! Never seen this before!!!!

Rest: Will be delighted to do so! Thanks for the instructions.