FreeRadius won't start (differs from MaxC post)

jeroen234

yes your pfsense install is to old
first uninstall the freeraduis package
then download from this link the pfsense full update
http://pfsense.com/~sullrich/1.0.1-SNAPSHOT-12-23-2006/

when it is on youre pc got to the webgui of pfsense
and upload that file on the firmware page
when the upgrade of pfsense is done you can install the freeradius package

Justinw

Thanks for the quick reply, I wasn't sure if a newer snapshot would help or not, I'll give it a run and let you know.

Justinw

I updated to the latest snapshot 12-23 (after uninstalling the package) fired it up, reinstalled freeradius, and the same error persists. Any additional ideas?

Justinw

I noticed that the package version in the gui is 1.1.2 but the version the package manager gets according to pkg_info is freeradius 1.1.3_1, I'm not sure if these are meant to match, but I looked on another older machine I have and it said freeradius was 1.0.4. I noticed that current port was posted 10/29/2006 on freebsd ports. Any chance that this is the problem and does anyone know how to fix it?

jeroen234

i have 1.1.2 in the gui and when installed its 1.1.3_1
so the 1.1.2 in the gui is a leftover from before the last update off the package

i will put rlm_exec.a on a webserver that i own
i have had this error 1 time but it was fixed by uninstalling the package and go to the last snapshot and then reboot and then install the package
don't now if i rebooted again afther that
but then it worked

jeroen234

if i have made the port forward on pfsense correct then you can access my webserver and download the file from it
http://wlelystad.homeip.net/pfsense/freeradius/

Justinw

hmm, looks like its still not forwarding right just yet, thanks for your effort to help me out though.

jeroen234

oeps the nated ip mist a 1 so pfsense was sending traffic to a ghost pc
thanks for reporting

Justinw

I got the file and set the permissions and replaced the old one, they differed by 600 bytes or so. I still get the same error as before, and I started my install fresh, then updated to 12-23, then installed the package, still had the error, tried to replace the file with the one provided above, still has an error. If anyone else can confirm similiar problems, that would be great. Any other suggestions would also be appreciated.

jeroen234

i see there a more files of rlm_exec
i have :

ls -l rlm_exec*

lrwxr-xr-x 1 root wheel 11 Nov 25 22:26 rlm_exec-1.1.3.la -> rlm_exec.la
-rwxr-xr-x 1 root wheel 8676 Nov 25 22:26 rlm_exec-1.1.3.so
-rw-r–r-- 1 root wheel 4326 Nov 25 22:26 rlm_exec.a
-rwxr-xr-x 1 root wheel 880 Nov 25 22:26 rlm_exec.la
lrwxr-xr-x 1 root wheel 17 Nov 25 22:26 rlm_exec.so -> rlm_exec-1.1.3.so

Justinw

Here is what I see:

lrwxr-xr-x 1 root wheel 11 Dec 3 18:45 rlm_exec-1.1.3.la -> rlm_exec.la
-rwxr-xr-x 1 root wheel 8676 Dec 3 18:40 rlm_exec-1.1.3.so
-rwxrwxrwx 1 root wheel 4326 Dec 28 22:32 rlm_exec.a
-rw-r–r-- 1 root wheel 4914 Dec 3 18:45 rlm_exec.aold
-rwxr-xr-x 1 root wheel 816 Dec 3 18:45 rlm_exec.la
lrwxr-xr-x 1 root wheel 17 Dec 3 18:40 rlm_exec.so -> rlm_exec-1.1.3.so

I did a chmod 777 on it just to see if it had anything to do with permissions, and .aold is the previous rlm_exec.a other than rlm_exec.la it looks like all of them are the same size

jeroen234

can you test if u copy this file to /usr/local/etc/raddb/radiusd.conf
http://wlelystad.homeip.net/pfsense/freeradius/radiusd.conf
edit this line to youre ip
bind_address = 212.187.92.144

if it then works for you ?

if that works then download
freeradius.inc
freeradius.xml
from my website to /usr/local/pkg/freeradius.inc
freeradius.xml

Justinw

As a matter of fact it does seem to get a clean startup, I don't see the service start in status > services, but when I try and start it again it says its running and the error is gone. I made some changes in the gui and when the new conf file was created the same error came back, I wonder if there is a problem with how it is being written on the fly. I'll look into it more, thanks again for your help.

jeroen234

if you make a chanche in the gui then it writes the error back
the 2 gui files on my website have the error removed and don't write it to disk
also it add's some extra's

jahonix

On a vanilla system updated to 2006-12-23 I installed the freeradius package but the service won't start.
Deinstalled from webGUI and trying to manually add:

pkg_add -r freeradius

gives this error:

warning: package 'freeradius-1.1.3_1' requires 'gdbm-1.8.3_3', but 'gdbm-1.8.3_2' is installed

It won't start also but might be a hint…
Just deinstalled the package as I don't need it on this box.

jahonix

jeroen234

the pfsense freeradius package is talered to pfsense the one from freebsd needs more libs then pfsense has
in the pfsense freeradius gui there is a small gui error
if you replace freeradius.xml and freeradius.inc on location /usr/local/pkg
with the same files from http://wlelystad.homeip.net/pfsense/freeradius/

and then go to freeradius settings on the gui and save then the correct freeradius config is made and freeradius will start

jahonix

yep, just got it working this way.
Thanks alot - especially for the extended options accessible via webGUI!

Now I can lockout the kids at night when they are supposed to sleep (if it works, haven't tested it yet but I am confident…)

jahonix

jeroen234

for that option you need to config the captive portal with these options:
Hard timeout leave blank
send RADIUS accounting packets
Reauthenticate connected users every minute
Accounting updates interim update

then pfsense will check every min if the user is still alowed

Justinw

Well the updates look great, apparently I am still doing something wrong though here is the break down again:

With your updates I am now getting this error :

radiusd.conf[246] Failed to link to module 'rlm_expr': /usr/local/lib/rlm_expr.a: invalid file format

When I use an invalid bind address it does say this:

There appears to be another RADIUS server running on the authentication port 1812

Without jeroen234 upates I got the error on line 226 as previously posted…

It sounds like I may just still have a few bad lib files that aren't being built correclty, even with a fresh radius install, I'm not sure exactly why that is, but I would greatly appreciate if you could post the other lib files on your site for radius as well and I can see what I can do from there. Thanks again for all your help.

jeroen234

i think that you better can try a complete fresh install of pfsense
http://pfsense.com/~sullrich/1.0.1-SNAPSHOT-12-23-2006/pfSense.iso.gz
i can post the 50 or so freeradius files
but if youre hd is not good then that makes no sense
and my libs are the same as that you installed with the pfsense freeradius package