Motherboard ideas

fwuser07

Ok no problem. I will order the same board soon and when I've done some performance tests I'll post them.

dotdash

Here are the things you should know before getting the board:

Update the BIOS. Initial version has flakey fan sensor readings.
Board needs an EPS-12V PSU
Board does not have standard P4 heatsink mounts, you have to get a Pentium M heatsink.

fwuser07

Ok thanks for these hints.

tedced

I also need a system with a lot of Nics.
2 WAN, 1 LAN, 1 VOIPLan, 1 DMZ, 1 CARP, 1 WIFI,= 7 Nics

I am planning to use the Intel INTEL PRO/1000 PT PCI-E adapter as well as the INTEL PRO/1000MT PCI adapter.
I've considered the two Asus boards below, mostly because of the high number of PCI-E slots.
I only buy Asus boards…

Asus M2N-SLI Deluxe (AMD AM2) 4 pci-E and 3 pci + 2 onboard gbe
and the
Asus P5N-SLI (Intel LGA775) 5 pci-E and 2 pci + 1 onboard gbe

I bought the m2n but havn't been able to get the onboard nics to work yet.
I've posted that tread here: http://forum.pfsense.org/index.php/topic,4902.0.html

fwuser07

I can't help you with your nvidia nics but my impression is that you should use intel nics for a stable environment to have less trouble.

And in my opinion it would be better to work with vlans instead of using so many nics for your internal lans. To do so, your switches must also have vlan support, of cource.

dotdash

I have not heard good things about Nvidia chipset NICs and FreeBSD. Asus generally uses Broadcom on their server class motherboards, I think Broadcom NICs would be preferable to the Nvidia ones. I was considering an ASUS board myself, but couldn't find a small form factor board with Intel nics… Also, consider alternatives to using a PCI or PCIe slot for everything. For example, the Tyan board I was talking about earlier only has 1 PCI and 1 PCIe slot, but I could do everything you described using the 3 onboard NICs, an add-in PCI and PCIe nic, the onboard firewire for CARP, and a mini-pci wireless card. For WANs, you could use a cheap dual-port fxp card in one PCI slot, and for faster interfaces, a dual-port PCIe Intel card. So you might be able to do this without needing five PCIe slots.

fwuser07

@dotdash: I ordered all componentes except for the heatsink. Please tell me what heatsink you used in yout 1U case.

dotdash

It was a Dynatron I31 active cooler. They also have a passive heat sink I51 that fits.

tedced

… the onboard firewire for CARP...

can you use firewire for CARP?

sai

ethernet over firewire doesn't seem to work with pfSense. the fwe driver has been taken out of the kernel some months ago

dotdash

I got CARP running over firewire using fwip, not fwe (which seems to be non-standard).
I have some notes here:
http://forum.pfsense.org/index.php/topic,3604.0.html