Random Disconnect Issues
-
Well i'm not sure what it could be. I don't have anything like traffic shaping, or load balancing or anything enabled.. All internal traffic is routed through the wan3 (opt2) interface. It's the basic pfsense setup besides the two additional wan connections… Is it a problem to have multiple wan connections coming from the same default gateway?
-
Oh, re2 and re3 are probably both WAN interfaces of yours aren't they? That changes things, and makes me lean towards hardware issues again.
-
Yes, exactly. To be more descriptive:
xl0 - WAN
re0 - LAN
re1 - Internal Wireless
re2 - WAN2
re3 - WAN3
-
A bit of an update.
I'm kinda of leaning away from it being a modem issue.. Last night i plugged my laptop directly into the modem using the usb connection, and it did not disconnect at all, while at the same time leaving my desktop connected normally to pfsense, and the connection dropped about 12 times..
-
Doesn't mean there isn't an issue with the Ethernet on your modem that isn't an issue with USB.
Are all your WAN interfaces going to the same DSL modem? Does this affect traffic regardless of which WAN it is directed to?
-
Good point..
The disconnections happened regardless of which wan interface i routed traffic through.. I'll leave this alone until the new modem comes in.. thanks again
-
So they are all 3 going to the same DSL modem? Couldn't you just one use WAN if you only have one ISP? I'm curious if the problem would go away without a multi-WAN setup.
-
well the multiwan setup is so that i can host a couple websites, and keep them all on the default port 80, instead of having to do something messy like www.secondwebsite.com:90, etc., That was my main reason for moving from an ipcop environment to pfsense. Right now, since everyone is gone, i plugged my desktop directly into the modem via a cat53 cable, so this will tell me if it's a modem issue or not.
-
Are your wan ip's dynamic? most multi ip setup from one provide there would be only one physical line to pfsense with multi ip's that one can assign with virtual ip in pfsense.
The reason i said you should ping from pfsense was to check the line out but still keep every thing connected.
-
Ok,
After all last night, and early into today, i have not had one single disconnect issue when plugging directly into the modem, using both the usb port, and the ethernet port, so the modem appears to be functioning correctly.
As for your question Perry, yes, the wan ip's are dynamic. I have been unable to get logged into the gui while the connection dropped to see if pfsense can still ping out, but i will keep trying that.
-
Upgrade to a recent testing snapshot: http://snapshots.pfsense.com/FreeBSD6/RELENG_1_2/updates/
-
Alright i just upgraded to the lastest snapshot. Will keep you all updated.
Thanks again for all the great support. None of you all have to do this, so thanks again.
-
Ok,
I just upgraded to the most recent testing snapshot available, and still getting the same thing as before. Did i miss a step in configuring pfsense for a multiwan setup? I figured i could just add the two additional wan interfaces, and then route the traffic how i want using firewall rules.
-
Thought i would give an update, hopefully someone has a few more ideas for me to try. I took out the two nics that i was using for my multiple wans, and installed pfsense again using one interface for the lan, one for the wan, and one for my wireless network. After 2 days of this, i haven't had one disconnection issue. So the problem only occurs when running multiple wans.
-
I've changed my setup at home so i got 2 dynamic ip's from the same modem going to the pfsense box. Atm i do get a lot of those arp messages but no disconnect so fare. From what i can find on the web it shouldn't be a problem.
To get rid of the messages look here http://freebsdhowtos.com/102.html
Replace your wan nic's ( intel is best ).That is what i would do at this point.
-
Yah, i don't mind the messages haha. One thing i did realize was the two wan nic's i was using were both realtek gigabit nic's. So i'll throw in a couple 100Mb intel cards see if that fixes the issue.
-
Well after i swapped out all of my wan nic's with 10/100 Mb intel nics, i still experienced the same issue..
The problem is definitely somewhere within my pfsense box.When i plug into the unmanaged switch in front of the pfsense box, i am able to lease public ip addresses from isp without a problem, and experience 0 disconnect issues.
When i run pfsense with a single wan interface, still behind the unmanaged switch, i all experience 0 disconnect issues.
As soon as i put two additional wan interfaces in, i start experiencing d/c issues. One thing im not sure if i mentioned or not was that i had to set both my lan and wireless interface to send all traffic through my opt3 (WAN3) interface, since the default routing would float between the 3 different wan interfaces, although i doubt that will help you out any…
I dunno, im out of ideas... Anymore ideas?
Also, might i mention, i tried installed the most recent snapshot released yesterday (june 4th).
-
Still no disconnect here. http://www.mail-archive.com/support@pfsense.com/msg09832.html uses the same modem as i.
If you have a spare router you could add it in front of pfsense
+–---router1---- wan2
|
modem-----switch---+---------------- wan
|
+-----router2---- wan3Else i only see a move to static ip's
-
May i ask how your setup is for your multi-wan setup? Does your modem have multiple ethernet ports or do you have a router or switch in front of pfsense?
-
Got a hub in front
+–-wan
|
modem ---- hub---+---wan2