Configuring Transparent Mode

globalmcs

Hi,

I bridged OPT1 with the WAN interface without IP or gateway, created two test firewall rules to allow all TCP/UDP and ICMP traffic in the OPT1

I can ping the WAN IP but I can't ping the WAN gateway so I cant get out to the internet from the server in the OPT1.

Here is some more information about the IP configuration

WAN Interface IP configuration:
IP….........24.XXX.XXX.50/29
Gateway...24.XXX.XXX.49

LAN Interface IP configuration:
IP............192.168.1.1/24

OPT1 Interface IP Configuration
Brdige with WAN
IP............N/A
Gateway...N/A

The Server in OPT1 has the following IP configuration:
IP............24.XXX.XXX.51
IP............24.XXX.XXX.52
IP............24.XXX.XXX.53
IP............24.XXX.XXX.54
Subnet.....255.255.255.248
Gateway...24.XXX.XXX.49

Thank you in advance!

danswartz

well the subnet mask is wrong for the server. for a /29 it should be 255.255.255.248. also what are the rules you put on OPT1?

globalmcs

Sorry I fat-finger the subnet in the post -it is 255.255.255.248

The rules I created on the OPT1 are:

TCP/UDP Any Source, Any port, Any Destination, Any Port
ICMP Any Source, Any port, Any Destination, Any Port

danswartz

This makes no sense. The gateway is in the same subnet as the WAN IP, so if you can get to one, you should be able to get to the other. Are you sure the WAN gateway even responds to pings? And are you sure your server has a default gateway pointing to it?

globalmcs

Hi Dan, I sent you a private message.

danswartz

I'm not interested in what the LAN hosts can do - we already know they work. When you said the WAN gateway can be pinged, I assumed you meant from the server, but the server cannot ping the WAN gateway (but can ping the WAN IP, which is why I said it doesn't make sense.) And you haven't answered my question as to your server's config.

globalmcs

The default gateway of the server connected to the OPT1 interface is 24.XXX.XXX.49

danswartz

so to confirm: the server cannot ping outside hosts? the server cannot ping the gateway (which obviously doesn't require the gateway IP - LOL)? If you run a packet capture on the WAN interface, and try pinging the gateway IP, what (if anything) do you see? Also, I would remove the two rules and replace with a single rule that permits everything (unless you have some reason not to.)

globalmcs

Correct, the server cannot ping outside hosts.
I'll run the packet capture on the WAN and modify the rules later tonight and report back.

Thanks for your help so far

danswartz

but can it ping the WAN gateway IP? I am reading conflicting statements about this.

globalmcs

I can ping the WAN IP 24.XXX.XXX.50, but not the WAN Gateway IP 24.XXX.XXX.49 from the server in OPT1

I have a total of 5 IPs from the ISP, one for the WAN and four for the server in the OPT1

danswartz

if you login to the pfsense, can you ping the WAN gateway IP?

globalmcs

I haven't tried it, I'll do so tonight - I'm not there right now and dont have remote access yet.

globalmcs

I changed the OPT rule to one
Proto Source Port Destination Port Gateway Schedule
* * * * * *

I was able to ping the WAN Gateway from the pfSense console

Ping output:

PING 24.xxx.xxx.49 (24.xxx.xxx.49) from 24.xxx.xxx.50: 56 data bytes
64 bytes from 24.xxx.xxx.49: icmp_seq=0 ttl=64 time=1.537 ms
64 bytes from 24.xxx.xxx.49: icmp_seq=1 ttl=64 time=1.262 ms
64 bytes from 24.xxx.xxx.49: icmp_seq=2 ttl=64 time=2.456 ms

–- 24.xxx.xxx.49 ping statistics ---
3 packets transmitted, 3 packets received, 0.0% packet loss
round-trip min/avg/max/stddev = 1.262/1.752/2.456/0.511 ms

I ran the packet capture on the WAN interface and pinged 24.xxx.xxx.49 from the server in OPT1 and here is what I got

12 2.041353 00:50:56:94:1a:b4 Broadcast ARP Who has 24.XXX.XXX.49? Tell 24.XXX.XXX.51
13 2.782611 24.XXX.XXX.50 24.XXX.XXX.49 ICMP Echo (ping) request
14 2.783796 24.XXX.XXX.49 24.XXX.XXX.50 ICMP Echo (ping) reply
21 3.783133 24.XXX.XXX.50 24.XXX.XXX.49 ICMP Echo (ping) request
22 3.784322 24.XXX.XXX.49 24.XXX.XXX.50 ICMP Echo (ping) reply
23 4.784588 24.XXX.XXX.50 24.XXX.XXX.49 ICMP Echo (ping) request

So the server broadcast who has 24.XXX.XXX.49, the ping starts from the WAN IP and the Gateway replies back to the WAN IP instead of the Server IP

danswartz

Aha. It sounds like it is doing NAT for some reason. If you go to firewall => NAT => Outbound, what do you see?

globalmcs

The option "Automatic outbound NAT rule generation (IPsec passthrough)" is selected.

danswartz

aha, click to AON (manual) and delete the rule that then appears.

globalmcs

I did it and lost internet connectivity from the LAN and the OTP1 still the same.
I selected the "Automatic outbound NAT rule generation (IPsec passthrough)" back.

danswartz

sorry, my bad. re-enable manual AON and tell me what rule you see.

globalmcs

Its ok, I appreciate you trying to help me.
Here is the only rule when manual AON is Enabled

Interface Source Source Port Destination Destination Port NAT Address NAT Port Static Port Description
WAN 192.168.1.1/24 * * * * * NO Auto created rule for LAN