Should I switch to 64-bit ?
-
Something is awry with your system then. I installed on very similar hardware a month or two back (I believe I shared my parts list when you were shopping), and I found that system to be nearly instantaneous with anything I tried to do with it.
I did see my routing throughput jump from 100-300 mbps to 950 mbps when the yandex drivers were introduced. I understand those have been pulled in later builds. Maybe the Intel em driver is giving you grief?
My home system runs on an Atom D510 and although the UI is a little slow compared to the i5, I have no complaints, and routing performance is enough for what I'm doing with it.
-
I should have asked you to describe the slowness you're seeing in more detail. Is it the UI? poor routing throughput? Something else? Have a look at this thread here to see if it might be something you're experiencing:
http://forum.pfsense.org/index.php/topic,34839.0.html
-
Are you on a 64-bit snapshot?
I just installed the i386 back and my network is flying again. Could it be something to do with i5 processor or RAM drivers? I want to get the most of the system with full 4GB RAM. I am thinking of upgrading the RAM to 6 or 8GB later down the line as more users start coming on to this network.
BTW what are the vandex drivers for?
-
Yandex is a company that made some modifications to Intel's em NIC driver. There were issues with the em driver in 1.2.3 and the Yandex drivers were used to help resolve these. There were more issues with the em driver in the 2.0 betas, so the Yandex drivers were pulled in, then pushed out again. On the Intel mini-ITX board I was using, the onboard Intel GBE had poor throughput on em, but did well when the switch was made to Yandex. I don't have that hardware any more, so I don't know if the old issues would have returned with the em driver or not.
-
I see.
I will reinstall 64-bit again tonight and wont add Squid, Snort and others for now and see how it performs.
-
Yandex is a company that made some modifications to Intel's em NIC driver. There were issues with the em driver in 1.2.3 and the Yandex drivers were used to help resolve these. There were more issues with the em driver in the 2.0 betas, so the Yandex drivers were pulled in, then pushed out again. On the Intel mini-ITX board I was using, the onboard Intel GBE had poor throughput on em, but did well when the switch was made to Yandex. I don't have that hardware any more, so I don't know if the old issues would have returned with the em driver or not.
I sure as heck hope not! I just got my 3 port Intel gigabit daughterboard today for my Jetway motherboard that is on its way and I'll cry if I paid $30 more for the Intel one that was supposed to be better with pfsense than the much cheaper Realtek one! lol
Bill -
I believe the switch away from yandex happened on or about March 16, so if you see issues with the latest snaps you might try rolling back to early March, but be sure to report any issues you have.
-
My both network cards are Realtek. I ordered a HP Broadcom Gigabit NIC but that wont negotiate to 1000Mbit. No matter what I tried it would connect only at 100Mbps with the Netgear switch. So I go another Realtek gigabit and it works just fine like the onboard one.
Shoud I switch to Intel? I haven't seen a huge performance issue yet (on i386 build) with the Realtek NIC.
-
I wouldn't go out and buy Intel hardware unless you can nail your issues to the realtek part. If you have a spare NIC of another make then go ahead and see if it resolves your problem.
-
I was all paranoid that I made a bad decision going with the Intel NIC's so had to do some testing. My test setup is a 3Ghz P4 w/ 1GB with one of yesterday's 2.0 embedded & 2 Intel nic's. 1 onboard Intel 100mbit for LAN & 1 PCI Intel 100mbit for WAN. Speedtest.net showed a burst up to 40+mbit down then held at 21.2mbit down rest of the test & 2.2mbit up (~0.1 CPU & ~2.0 interrupt) so looks like my 20/2 cable line was going full speed & then some with very little effort for the system which I figure means it could do tons more. At this point I'm thinking the Intel drivers are fine for my needs. :D
I'll have to search around to read up on the Intel stuff though still as I'm still curious & baffled because over & over I read "go Intel NIC's".
Cheers!
Bill