Thinking about using a firebox, some questions
-
It should handle 100/50 firewall and NAT no problems. I have to admit I've never actually done any throughput testing on an X-Core personally but I an see no reason why it wouldn't. You will, of course, be limited to 100Mbps as it only has 10/100 NICs.
So you will have 4 WANs?
It should be fine as long as you don't have trouble with the Realtek NICs. :-
Some users have no problems. Others have problems!Happy New Year!
Steve
-
It should handle 100/50 firewall and NAT no problems. I have to admit I've never actually done any throughput testing on an X-Core personally but I an see no reason why it wouldn't. You will, of course, be limited to 100Mbps as it only has 10/100 NICs.
So you will have 4 WANs?
It should be fine as long as you don't have trouble with the Realtek NICs. :-
Some users have no problems. Others have problems!Happy New Year!
Steve
Ok! yeah i need 4 WANs enable:d with loadbalancing, dont know if loadbalancing is very cpu demanding?
Or would it be a neather solution for me the build a pfsense box on a itx motherboard or maybe a thin client with pci-e slot?
The problem is that i dont think i have the physically room for a x550e/x750e series… -
Outbound load balancing is not very CPU intensive it should not cause a problem.
It depends on how cheaply you can get a Firebox. If it is very cheap then you should try it. Bare in mind however that if you have trouble with the Realtek NICs you may have to try something else.If you decide not to go that route I would use a small 8 port VLAN capable switch, a Netgear GS108T for example, and a low power miniITX board. That will allow you to have up to 7 separate interfaces at the switch. E.g. 4 WANs and 3 LANs. Your ISP will not see the VLANs so that is not an issue.
Steve
-
Outbound load balancing is not very CPU intensive it should not cause a problem.
It depends on how cheaply you can get a Firebox. If it is very cheap then you should try it. Bare in mind however that if you have trouble with the Realtek NICs you may have to try something else.If you decide not to go that route I would use a small 8 port VLAN capable switch, a Netgear GS108T for example, and a low power miniITX board. That will allow you to have up to 7 separate interfaces at the switch. E.g. 4 WANs and 3 LANs. Your ISP will not see the VLANs so that is not an issue.
Steve
True! was at first unsure how VLAN work but if I've got it right now, i can use one NIC to "simlulate" like there was 4 nics in the computer? giving me access to more networks?. So if i got a x550e and there wasn't enough ports then i could buy a vlan switch and put it infront of it? to get vlans working?
//BR
Patrik -
Yes you could do that. The number of interfaces you can have is limited only by the number of ports on the switch. However all the traffic has to travel along the 'trunk' connection back to the pfSense box so that can also be a limitation. Not a problem with gigabit NICs though.
Steve
-
Yes you could do that. The number of interfaces you can have is limited only by the number of ports on the switch.
Not even limited to that really, you can have multiple vlans per port so long as whatever else you're talking to can trunk as well :-)
-
Just bought 2x firebox x5500e peak for $200 think it was kinda resonable price?
-
Considering you could have paid $6674 for one that seems very reasonable! :D
I had few problems with the X5500e I have. The CPU is not recognised by the est(4) driver so powerd doesn't work. You may have to swap it out. The VPN card is not supported but whilst it was in the box it caused huge interrupt load. You should remove it.
Steve
-
Considering you could have paid $6674 for one that seems very reasonable! :D
I had few problems with the X5500e I have. The CPU is not recognised by the est(4) driver so powerd doesn't work. You may have to swap it out. The VPN card is not supported but whilst it was in the box it caused huge interrupt load. You should remove it.
Steve
Haha true :)
But just changing the cpu should make it work?
My biggest concern right now is that i may be to big for my "server closet" :) -
Considering you could have paid $6674 for one that seems very reasonable! :D
I had few problems with the X5500e I have. The CPU is not recognised by the est(4) driver so powerd doesn't work. You may have to swap it out. The VPN card is not supported but whilst it was in the box it caused huge interrupt load. You should remove it.
Steve
Ok! some questions steve, hope you have the time.
#In my opionion it should be better to use a compact flash 4gb instead of a 2,5" drive, since i'm guessing the HDD would be using more power?
#Do you think i should flash my bios? if you do, with what version?
#When installing to a CF card how to i reach the configuration of pfsense?//BR
Patrik -
It will work with the 2GHz cpu that is fitted as standard to the X-Peak-e.
However you won't be able to turn on powerd which means it will run hotter and you won't be able to slow the fans as much and hence it will be louder.
Replacement CPUs that will work (any Pentium-M with a 400MHz FSB) are very cheap.I am using a CF card, it's an easier option. The only reason to go for a hard disk is if you need a specific package that needs the storage space.
You need to access the bios because a bug in the bios code stops the box booting from anything larger than 256MB. To work around it you need to set the IDE channel to manual and CHS and then set the heads to 2.
You can do this either by getting a PCI-E graphics card and some sort of adapter to make it fit the slot and making up a keyboard connector to go on the header. Alternatively you an flash the bios with the modified version that enables serial port access to the bios. Probably easier! ;)
All the boxes I've seen or spoken to others about had the same buggy bios labeled either 2005/12/21 or X017. If you had anything different it would be great.The NanoBSD install to a CF card uses the serial port for it's console so you need a null modem cable and a computer with a serial port. You'll need this for the initial install and setup but after that it's all web based.
Steve
-
It will work with the 2GHz cpu that is fitted as standard to the X-Peak-e.
However you won't be able to turn on powerd which means it will run hotter and you won't be able to slow the fans as much and hence it will be louder.
Replacement CPUs that will work (any Pentium-M with a 400MHz FSB) are very cheap.I am using a CF card, it's an easier option. The only reason to go for a hard disk is if you need a specific package that needs the storage space.
You need to access the bios because a bug in the bios code stops the box booting from anything larger than 256MB. To work around it you need to set the IDE channel to manual and CHS and then set the heads to 2.
You can do this either by getting a PCI-E graphics card and some sort of adapter to make it fit the slot and making up a keyboard connector to go on the header. Alternatively you an flash the bios with the modified version that enables serial port access to the bios. Probably easier! ;)
All the boxes I've seen or spoken to others about had the same buggy bios labeled either 2005/12/21 or X017. If you had anything different it would be great.The NanoBSD install to a CF card uses the serial port for it's console so you need a null modem cable and a computer with a serial port. You'll need this for the initial install and setup but after that it's all web based.
Steve
Ok thank you! so if i find a cf with 256mb of space then i could use that without making changes to the bios? (with the nano bsd?)
I guess the best solution is to flash the bios then :) but where do i find it? and to access the bios i do with the nullmodem cable right? is this still buggy? or will it be pretty easy to change the settings?Btw is it possible to use a serial to usb adaptor?
//BR
Patrik -
The minimum CF card size is 512MB for the NanoBSD images so you need to access the bios.
Instructions for doing that are here.Yes you can use a USB serial adapter. Make you know it is working before you start or it's easy to get confused. Connect up your serial cable/usb adapter/terminal program and boot the Watchguard OS. You should see the boot up at 115200 8N1.
Steve
-
The minimum CF card size is 512MB for the NanoBSD images so you need to access the bios.
Instructions for doing that are here.Yes you can use a USB serial adapter. Make you know it is working before you start or it's easy to get confused. Connect up your serial cable/usb adapter/terminal program and boot the Watchguard OS. You should see the boot up at 115200 8N1.
Steve
Ok cool!
So the things i need before starting is:#Firebox (doh!)
#Nullmodem cable
#cf card with 16mb+ (maximum 256mb)
#cf card for the OS (4gb) -
Yes.
You can use the CF card that comes in it if you don't want the Watchguard OS (or back it up first).
There is almost no point in using a 4GB over a 2GB card and there is absolutely no point in using a super fast card. pfSense won't use UDMA and it only reduces boot time slightly anyway.Steve
-
I just received a message from the post office that finally they have arrived.
Just came up with a question.
Do i need to flash the bios or just enable these things? (for larger cf cards).If i understand everything right i need a nullmodem cable to access the bios? and a cf card 512mb+ to use with pfsense.
Do i need anything else?
//BR
Patrik -
Recently some other users have had great trouble getting a 512MB card to boot. It seems that at least some 512MB cards will not boot with the bios set either at 'auto' or heads=2 so to be safe get a card at least 1GB. I have personally used 2GB and 4GB cards with no problems.
Steve
-
Recently some other users have had great trouble getting a 512MB card to boot. It seems that at least some 512MB cards will not boot with the bios set either at 'auto' or heads=2 so to be safe get a card at least 1GB. I have personally used 2GB and 4GB cards with no problems.
Steve
Ok! then i'll buy a 1-2gb card.
But i dont need to flash the bios or? Can you tell me the steps in short… :)
//BR
Patrik -
Yes you will need to flash the bios.
To do that you need the serial cable (and usb adapter if you need it) and a very small CF card. You can use the card from the box if you don't want to keep it.
Instructions to do it are here.Steve
-
Haven't picked it up from the post office yet, but i found a Intel T5500 SL9U4 (Core2duo 1,66ghz 667bus) do you think it will work in the firebox?
//BR
Patrik