Unexplained NAT failure.
-
If you remove squid, do you get a working firewall?
-
If you remove squid, do you get a working firewall?
Nearly. I talked someone through a factory reset. Now LAN clients can see everything but the servers on the OPT1 bridge.
Everyone else - the Internet on the WAN interface - can see those servers. I think I know what the problem is - it's with the KVM configuration for the servers. pfSense is passing the packets.
I'm struggling to install the OpenVPN export tool because apparently the pfSense box has no Internet connectivity even though I'm connected to it via SSH and HTTP and it can resolve hostnames. But there's an error message when I navigate to the list of packages to install.
-
I have managed to access the box running KVM and the Ovirt management tool. Hooray for port forwarding! Unfortunately rebooting that machine hasn't made a difference.
At the moment, the situation is this:
- LAN can see the Internet. This is a good thing.
- WAN can see the Internet. Very good!
- Internet can see OPT1. Great success.
- LAN cannot see servers on OPT1. Very bad.
Basically, from my hotel in Bangkok I can ping/access servers on OPT1 but I cannot do so from the pfSense box itself, nor from the LAN.
This is driving me nuts. I really don't want to spend 14 hours getting home to perform a 4 hour fix (building a new box with new hardware) and then head back here… another 14 hours... ugh.
Any suggestions?
-
Are they on different physical interfaces??
-
Yes, they are. WAN is re0, LAN is em0, and OPT1 (connected to the virtualised servers) is on em1.
-
do you have rules for em0 -> em1 ?
-
I have the default LAN to anywhere rule enabled and I have a rule on OPT1 allowing all traffic - OPT1 is essentially unfiltered at the moment.
-
I would check the routes. Then I would check NAT rules (outbound as well). Are there any other rules besides your allow all in opt1 and LAN firewall rules?
Have you done a tcpdump at the pfsense machine first on LAN, then on opt1 to see if the traffic is making it through the firewall correctly? -
Well, it looks as though the problem has resolved itself.
And by that I mean that the guy who unplugged a cable from a switch and then replaced it to a different port finally told me that he had done so. Unsurprisingly, when that was fixed, the problem "magically" disappeared.
Thanks for the help, guys :)
-
Ah … the user tried to hide his mistake ... happens all the time. Glad you have the issue resolved ... and don't have to make crazy flight plans for a 1 minute fix.