Debug.pfftpproxy=1 to enable LAN to WAN FTP
-
On another note, I still managed to get kernel panic with FTP traffic with
2.1-RC0 (i386) built on Thu Jul 11 23:06:42 EDT 2013 FreeBSD 8.3-RELEASE-p8The more patches here go in, the more broken the thing is, and I have yet to see anyone reporting any improvement to the issues they were supposed to be fixed. Please, revert the stuff altogether.
-
Same issue here on same build.
On another note, I still managed to get kernel panic with FTP traffic with
2.1-RC0 (i386) built on Thu Jul 11 23:06:42 EDT 2013 FreeBSD 8.3-RELEASE-p8The more patches here go in, the more broken the thing is, and I have yet to see anyone reporting any improvement to the issues they were supposed to be fixed. Please, revert the stuff altogether.
-
Same issue here on same build.
The patches thankfully got reverted.. Try later with today's snapshots, the panics should be all gone.
-
Just updated to the lastest snapshot. Passive FTP is still hanging frequently. It would be really nice if the patches from about 2 month ago could be reverted, too. After those FTP started to behave odd, it was working perfectly fine before.
-
Same problem here with a simple setup and the snapshot from July 17, the browser ftp test to dd-wrt fails. While pfSense 2.0.3 works.
Hopefully these ftp helper changes get reverted to what worked in 2.0.3I do not have multi WAN so I am not affected by the problems that the old code had, hopefully for those who do there exists a good workaround.
Maybe a new ftp helper could be tested and developed on a different version then pfSense stable and release candidate as it seems to be quite complicated as the 2.1.0 release candidates have a broken ftp helper for over 2 months.
-
Devs, could someone make a testing "out-of-band" 2.1 snapshots with the recent (2+ months) FTP "fixes" removed? I suspect those really don't improve much, but rather keep breaking things for more people. This way, those lots of people who posted on this thread could test those and report if they get actual improvement, or whether there are some regressions from reverting the patches, or whether it changes nothing for them.
On a positive note, after several days of downloading and uploading via FTP, the panics seem to be gone for good. Pheeeeew.
-
Many thanks to Jimp for finally removing the rest of the problematic patches! FTP is finally working again :)
-
Many thanks to Jimp for finally removing the rest of the problematic patches! FTP is finally working again :)
Awesome! Do you know which snapshot this takes/took effect in? I'd like to test it out. Thanks!
-
Awesome! Do you know which snapshot this takes/took effect in? I'd like to test it out. Thanks!
Certainly there with 2.1-RC1 (i386) built on Thu Aug 1 19:03:48 EDT 2013 and anything newer.
-
This is the last revert:
https://github.com/pfsense/pfsense-tools/commit/3e9741ca7738bee066bfac95d5efba343ddf4c48
So it's already in the latest snapshots, I just upgraded und tested. -
Awesome! Do you know which snapshot this takes/took effect in? I'd like to test it out. Thanks!
Certainly there with 2.1-RC1 (i386) built on Thu Aug 1 19:03:48 EDT 2013 and anything newer.
I just upgraded to 2.1-RC1 (amd64) built on Thu Aug 1 19:39:40 EDT 2013, everything looks good now :)
-
Thanx, I can confirm FTP works again with the default value!
-
Is this an issue for WAN > LAN > FTP ? I did some editing on my rules table and now I cannot get it to work.. I even reverted back to my original settings.
I posted a comment in url below hoping for a reply but I also found this which caught my attention…
http://forum.pfsense.org/index.php/topic,58678.msg315592/topicseen.html#msg315592
thanks!
-
Is this an issue for WAN > LAN > FTP ? I did some editing on my rules table and now I cannot get it to work.. I even reverted back to my original settings.
This thread is NOT for debugging your firewall/server misconfiguration problem, please do not cross-port here.
Back to the topic: no problems after 2 days of testing.