DLNA + BRIDGE + IGMP PROXY
-
It is performance mostly. Dedicated chips in even the cheapest switches are always going to be faster than software, at least in latency terms. Also it's cost. In most situations it costs far more to add NICs to get more ports than it does to connect a switch. Of course in a box like the XTM5 you already have 7 NICs so you may as well use all of them as I outlined above. :)
Steve
-
As mentioned performance is prob always going to be better with an actual switch.. As "test" or lab ports with bridge sure ok.. I personally would use those ports when/if you want to add more segments to your network.
Or even in a lagg sort of setup for bandwidth or failover, etc.
https://doc.pfsense.org/index.php/LAGG_InterfacesLeveraging interfaces on the device your running pfsense on for "switch" ports by bridging them into a network segment would rarely be best use of the interface. If as mentioned you need to filter between two physical sections of your network segment then ok bridge interfaces would allow you to do that, etc.
-
UPDATE:
Changed my configuration accordingly to your suggestions.
WAN: public IP from cable modem
WLAN: 192.168.1.1 DHCP enabled
LAN: 192.168.2.1 DHCP enabled
Everything is working as expected, but the transfer speed between WLAN and LAN is very slow, 1mbyte/sec roughly
No traffic shaping or QoS enabled of course…..any idea? :-\ -
Your wireless sucks? Would be my first guess ;) hehehe
How are you testing? Last test I got 271Mbps over a wireless AC connection without even trying to tweak anything.. And my pfsense is virtual on old N40L hardware, etc. Plug something in with a wire on pfsense wlan segment what are your speeds then?
What is your wireless AP, clients? Are you G, N, AC? How are you doing the test showing 1MBps?
Did you completely remove all the bridging stuff.. Maybe you got multicast you don't want flooding your wlan causing issues?
-
Your wireless sucks? Would be my first guess ;) hehehe
How are you testing? Last test I got 271Mbps over a wireless AC connection without even trying to tweak anything.. And my pfsense is virtual on old N40L hardware, etc. Plug something in with a wire on pfsense wlan segment what are your speeds then?
What is your wireless AP, clients? Are you G, N, AC? How are you doing the test showing 1MBps?
Did you completely remove all the bridging stuff.. Maybe you got multicast you don't want flooding your wlan causing issues?
I'd agree with you about the wireless that sucks :-) But this is not the case, with my previous configuration, all ports bridged, my speed was around 50mbytes/sec.
the AP configuration didn't change. -
50MBytes ps over wireless? So 400Mbps roughly – yeah I find that a little hard to believe ;)
-
Yup, need to clarify bits or bytes.
Such a dramatic reduction look for a duplex mismatch. Are you using the fxp interface? I've seen some odd behaviour on that NIC.Steve
-
The AP has 4 gigabit ports, so it's acting as a switch if I connect to it over cable I can easily achieve 50mbytes/sec as transfer speed. Wirelessly 12mbytes/sec
WLAN –> EM1
LAN --> EM2The numbers above are coming from my previous setup, where all the ports were bridged, only 1 subnet and 1 dhcp server.
-
So how were your NICs/subnets/cables arranged when you saw only 1MB/s?
Steve
-
wired I see 900Mbps.. Yeah 50MBps over a wired gig connection would be common place..
If your AP has switch ports, its most likely a wireless router that your just using as AP would be my guess.
How are you wired currently would help us point to your problem - I would agree 1MB or 1Mb over a wire something is major wrong.. duplex mismatch would be my first bet too.
-
Ok, I've made some more test!
I've enabled the HW offload and I've attached a laptop directly to the WLAN interface. Transfer rate between WLAN and LAN 80mbytes/sec (yes megabytes)
Re-connected the AP to WLAN, configured my laptop in wireless N 5ghz 450mbps rock solid at 2 mt from the AP. Transfer from WLAN to LAN 1 mbytes/sec
Speedtest on internet, wo WLAN to WAN 93mbps/secSo looks like the problem is the wireless…but how is possible I'm getting better speed over wireless on internet then on internal lan?
-
Ok, I've found the problem! For some reason my killer wireless card had the bandwidth control enabled….it's a "feature" from Atheros.
Many thanks for your help and sorry to wasted your time :-/
-
Never would have thought of that. Thanks for reporting back.
Steve
