Forwarding ports?

killmasta93

bump

johnpoz

And why don't you just put in the IP of nighthawk? Why do you have an alias in use? Do you have an IP in the alias or name that is not resolving?

What is the IP?

Have you looked and followed https://doc.pfsense.org/index.php/Port_Forward_Troubleshooting

killmasta93

Hi,
Thanks for the reply. I tried without alias the IP was 192.168.1.151 with port 8080 didnt work. Funny thing that all ports listed worked fine but when i tick other and put another port like 85 did not work. I will roll back to 2.1.5 to see if it works tonight and I will keep you posted if anything. I also tried the wiki but I know i can forward those ports because i have another router(ddwrt) connected to my modem (bridge) and I can forward any port on ddwrt with no problem. Also side note I have two different external IP. I have no idea why.

Thank you again

johnpoz

Your other IP is 192.168.3.1, do you have more than 1 lan segment?

And have you gone through the doc I linked too - this is no brainer stuff to troubleshoot. Did you sniff on your wan and the traffic is there, did you sniff on your lan and is the traffic sent?

Are you trying to forward to the lan IP of your dd-wrt router? And its also doing nat? Draw out your network.

cmb

@killmasta93:

I will roll back to 2.1.5 to see if it works tonight and I will keep you posted if anything.

Don't bother, that won't change anything. There's definitely nothing wrong with port forwards in any version.

Go through the troubleshooting steps listed in the port forward troubleshooting document johnpoz linked. Try to connect from outside, go to Diag>States and filter on :8080. See it there? If not, packet capture on WAN filtering on port 8080. If so, what does the state look like?

killmasta93

So here my setup the 192.168.1.1 is completely separate and has no contact with pfSense. Later tonight i will send the information

Thank you

Drawing1.png_thumb

killmasta93

hi so heres the screen shot of the ports
Im just curious why it does not work for 8080 when i can forward on pfSense port 80 and 443 with no problem

Thank you

Capture.PNG_thumb

Capture2.PNG_thumb

johnpoz

So what does a sniff show on the lan of pfsense - does it show it sending the traffic? Does dd-wrt answer? Looks like not answering to me.

killmasta93

o snap i think your right..i just tried port 22 i unchecked pfSense ssh to test the port then I tick ssh then open the port it worked. Hmm…howcome ddwrt not answering? well..worst case just create a vpn and connect to ddwrt

THANKS :)

cmb

The connections are in time wait, which means they were successful at the TCP level bidirectionally, so your port forwards are fine. I presume that's the web interface of the DDWRT, what did you see in a browser trying to browse to :8080 on your IP from outside?

killmasta93

i think i need to play with some iptables in ddwrt to make it listen on that port because WAN is disabled on ddwrt

killmasta93

o snap…port 80 is also ddwrt internally and 8080 wont work because its for the WAN and its disabled.

My 2 options are:

Change port 80 on pfSense which I really dont want to
or
find a way to change port 80 on ddwrt
OR
is it possible two devices running on the same port (80) be able to port forward (maybe crazy idea) :P

Thanks

doktornotor

There's really nothing preventing you from forwarding 8080 -> 80 or whatever. As a generic note, you'd better get HTTPS working everywhere. Sorry but sending firewall/router credentials in plaintext over internet is a very bad practice.

johnpoz

Why anyone would allow public access to their admin gui of anything is beyond me.. If you want to admin dd-wrt while your remote then vpn into pfsense and do it that way. Then you don't have to forward anything either ;) This is way MORE secure..

killmasta93

Thanks johnpoz and doktornotor your completely right. Its better though VPN i guess i got used to ddwrt for a while didn't want to let it go. :P Just trying to adapt more to pfSense now :)

Thank you again