2.2.3 Inquest
-
I have a 4G install (2.2.2 to 2.2.3) and it's got that 2 minute locking up while I change ANYTHING. That's not cool. But I just reverted back to 2.2.2 on the other slice.
-
I had to revert back as well could not get outside the lan after the upgrade. Not sure if it's related to packages not updated to match the upgrade to 2.2.3?
-
I have a 4G install (2.2.2 to 2.2.3) and it's got that 2 minute locking up while I change ANYTHING. That's not cool. But I just reverted back to 2.2.2 on the other slice.
If you're running pfSense on 4G CF or SD card this applies to you:
"The forcesync patch for #2401 was considered harmful to the filesystem and removed. As such, there may be some noticeable slowness with NanoBSD on certain slower disks, especially CF cards and to a lesser extent, SD cards. If this is a problem, the filesystem may be kept read-write on a permanent basis using the option on Diagnostics > NanoBSD."
From here https://doc.pfsense.org/index.php/2.2.3_New_Features_and_Changes
-
The release notes I see call it low risk if your on 2.2, if your has been up for 300 there is no way you were on the 2.2 line
For those already running any 2.2 version, this is a low risk upgrade. For those on 2.1.x or earlier versions, there are a number of significant changes which may impact you.Good catch! ;)
Or 75 days on 4 different boxes.
-
From this huge volume of provided info I have come to the conclusion that its caused by unfortunate planetary and lunar alignment.
I thought it was solar flares!
http://pages.cs.wisc.edu/~ballard/bofh/bofhserver.pl -
As likely a cause as any (given the details) :P
-
hummm.
Let's be counter-productive (to this thread).
Mine works.UP since week 26, when I installed 2.2.3
(edit: I didn't try to reboot it yet - I'm done with the rest, all ok)
-
Hello. I don't mean this to be a hit and run, I am simply too busy to check in as often as I'd like.
Let me reset the message. If you scan down the subjects of the Installation and Upgrades area of the forum and look at how many are 'broke or degraded since 2.2.3', it's more than 1 or two. In fact at the time of writing, I think I can see possibly 6 (not including this) on the first page alone.
What I'm suggesting is that it may be a good idea to consider what can be done to reduce this in the future. More testing? More testers? Different test scripts or test harness?
This was intended to help build up pfSense
andyPS, For the record its the squid package that's causing me problems, but this isn't the forum.
-
I can see possibly 5 (not including this) on the first page alone.
If the sample size is small then 5 glitches would be terrible. But there are literally hundreds and thousands of installs out there. I know of people who are managing more than 100+ instances by themselves.
If you're having trouble with squid, head on over to the Cache/Proxy forum.
-
Hello. I don't mean this to be a hit and run, I am simply too busy to check in as often as I'd like.
Let me reset the message. If you scan down the subjects of the Installation and Upgrades area of the forum and look at how many are 'broke or degraded since 2.2.3', it's more than 1 or two. In fact at the time of writing, I think I can see possibly 6 (not including this) on the first page alone.
What I'm suggesting is that it may be a good idea to consider what can be done to reduce this in the future. More testing? More testers? Different test scripts or test harness?
This was intended to help build up pfSense
andyPS, For the record its the squid package that's causing me problems, but this isn't the forum.
You are aware that pfSense is being ran in productions worldwide? So we're talking hundreds of thousands installs? Not to mention thousands of installs of pfSense / Netgate hardware as well?
-
At every upgrade and new release there are always many many "The update broke my pfsense" threads.
Some are actual pfsense issues
Some are hardware issues
Lots are issues with the guy at the keyboard.
No such thing as a release that goes perfect.
Even if the code were 100% perfect, just when you assume its idiot proof a better idiot would come along.
Just saying. There are always problems.
-
And the funny part is that such problems (and even worse) usually occur in similar situation at most commercial products too.
-
One thing I've learned with pfsense, linux, windows, whatever…
Don't install any feature unless you NEED it.
The cleaner and simpler you keep an install the less problems you will have.
Thats universally true.
