[solved in 2.2.6] 2.2.5 problems with XMLRPC sync - the server 2 is not updated

fmroeira86

Thanks for the leg work there, yarick123. I still can't replicate that anywhere, but knowing the source of the issue will help greatly. Will be looking more into it soon.

Do you have a fresh install?

cmb

@fmroeira86:

Do you have a fresh install?

All the systems I had tested with thus far were upgraded. Just checked a clean install and no diff there, works.

fmroeira86

Strange.

Fact is some people is getting this problem. :'(

@cmb:

@fmroeira86:

Do you have a fresh install?

All the systems I had tested with thus far were upgraded. Just checked a clean install and no diff there, works.

mdima

Same here! Before 2.2.5-RELEASE I never had this issue.

Thanks,
Michele

cmb

@fmroeira86:

Fact is some people is getting this problem. :'(

I'm not denying it's a problem. Just it's far from universal, and I don't have any case where it's replicable. Could someone that's seeing this share their config backups with me? Can PM me here, or email to cmb at pfsense dot org as attachments or to arrange another means of transfer.

I opened a bug ticket.
https://redmine.pfsense.org/issues/5509

mdima

Thank you Chris,
I just sent you the config and the syslog of both boxes via email.

Thanks,
Michele

Pentangle

I have a pair of boxes where I can reproduce this if necessary.

LFCavalcanti

Hi!

I was testing 2.2.5 to deploy on networks that have HA setup, had the same problem.

The test was done in Virtual Box, states are synced without problem, but XMLRPC Sync doesn't work.

I've attached "configs.zip" containing the backup of both VMs I used in the HA setup, also a PDF(topology.zip) containing a diagram of the network topology. If you need something tested, please let me know.

configs.zip
topology.zip

FlexyZ

Hi

I also have a pair of 2.2.5-RELEASE (amd64) built on Wed Nov 04 15:49:37 CST 2015 FreeBSD 10.1-RELEASE-p24, and I also have the SYNC issue. If I change/add a few new rules, and save - sometimes some of them are synced.

Thanks
Felix

LFCavalcanti

Is there a Bug item for this on Redmine or Git?

I'm trying to learn my way around the files and procedures to work on the packages, but it's being a little hard to get clear info on how to commit changes, interact and communicate around there.

jc2it

@LFCavalcanti:

Is there a Bug item for this on Redmine or Git?

I'm trying to learn my way around the files and procedures to work on the packages, but it's being a little hard to get clear info on how to commit changes, interact and communicate around there.

This was referenced on the previous page.

https://redmine.pfsense.org/issues/5509

Yann Richard

Same problem here, under VMWare ESX

Digital

I may confirm that same problem exists on 2.2.5 i386. Also confirming that yarick123 workaround to downgrade lighttpd on CARP backup to the one taken from 2.2.4 solves problem immediately.

html

lighttpd 1.4.38 is out. They fixed a header parse bug which breaks 1.4.36 and 1.4.37.
http://redmine.lighttpd.net/issues/2670
Maybe this bug is the reason for the sync problem.

rbgarga

I suspect this issue can be related this lighttpd issue:

http://redmine.lighttpd.net/issues/2670

This issue is fixed on lighttpd 1.4.38, which is available on most recent 2.2.6/2.3 snapshots

yarick123

Thank you, Renato!

I have tested the behaviour on pfSense 2.2.5 with lighttpd 1.4.38 from today's pfSense-LiveCD-2.3-ALPHA-i386-latest.iso.gz (09-Dec-2015 02:57). The problem does not reappear!

I could not find any snapshot for pfSense 2.2.6 :-\

Regards
yarick123

rbgarga

@yarick123:

Thank you, Renato!

I have tested the behaviour on pfSense 2.2.5 with lighttpd 1.4.38 from today's pfSense-LiveCD-2.3-ALPHA-i386-latest.iso.gz (09-Dec-2015 02:57). The problem does not reappear!

I could not find any snapshot for pfSense 2.2.6 :-\

Regards
yarick123

Great! Thanks!

2.2.6 can be found at https://snapshots.pfsense.org/FreeBSD_releng/10.1/amd64/pfSense_RELENG_2_2/

doktornotor

BTW, @Renato: the i386 snapshot builder is stuck YET again.

rbgarga

@doktornotor:

BTW, @Renato: the i386 snapshot builder is stuck YET again.

Fixed, thanks!

Build script used on 2.3 doesn't have this kind of issue of getting stuck when one error happens, it tries again after some time.

yarick123

Renato Botelho,

BTW, @Renato: the i386 snapshot builder is stuck YET again.

I have i386 platform and indeed there are no today's snapshots in https://snapshots.pfsense.org/FreeBSD_releng/10.1/i386/pfSense_RELENG_2_2/livecd_installer/ .

The latest i386 snapshot is dated 19-Nov-2015 18:49.

Regards
yarick123