Watchguard Firebox M400/M500

stephenw10

It might have bad RAM. That's not the standard CPU, is it the factory RAM?

Can we see a screenshot of the actual error you see?

Can you boot and run a Nano image as a test?:
https://nyifiles.pfsense.org/mirror/downloads/pfSense-CE-2.3.5-RELEASE-2g-amd64-nanobsd.img.gz

Steve

Testing

Ram during start of opnsense and pfsense: both show 8120mb present and usable.
Ram is factory standard, box wasn't opened until I replaced CPU. Box worked fine with factory OS.
After replacing the CPU(for AES-NI support), box still worked fine with factory OS.

Now I tried to install pfsense and because of error, also opnsense. Both halt at exactly the same command.

I have removed Dimm0, box gives error during installation.
I have removed Dimm1, box gives error during installation.

Tried the Nano image: box works fine.

Saw on internet that opnsense and pfsense updated to freebsd 11.1 and that gives errors.

Maybe I will try installation of older pfsense/opnsense? Or maybe more ideas? I will post picture of error tomorrow.

stephenw10

You're booting the installer on a CF card and installing to hard drive? Is the drive standard in the m500 or something you added?

Personally I installed to a CF card in another box and then moved it across into the m400 I have. Never had any issues.

You might try a 2.4.4 snapshot. If it's a known FreeBSD bug it might have been fixed in 11.2:
https://www.pfsense.org/snapshots/

Steve

Testing

Drive is not standard in m500, m500 is the same as m400 only with 8gb ecc memory instead of 4gb. I added a 120gb ssd, works fine in notebook. Also it receives some files, but not all(stops at the error).

Thanks for your suggestion! Will try that tomorrow.

Testing

Tried version 2.4.x(newest)=>error
Tried version 2.3.x(newest)=>error

Error message is different on opnsense vs pfsense.
Pfsense: CAM status: Uncorrecatable parity/CRC error
It keeps retrying a couple of times and then gives up.

Which sata port did you use?

stephenw10

You tried a 2.4.4 snapshot rather than 2.4.3?

I'm not using SATA currently, I just installed to CF and booted that.

That error looks like a bad disk though or bad disk controller or maybe some incompatibility between them.

The original OS is on CF so I assume you have not booted anything from that drive?

Steve

Testing

I tried 2.3.5, 2.4.3 and 2.4.4
Al give the same error.
Looks like it doesn't want to start anything on Sata(used port 2 and 4).

CPU tested in notebook, works fine
SSD tested in notebook, works fine
PFsense on CF(4gb), all works fine

The problem is installing to the ssd. The installer does recognize the ssd(sata3, correct speed, correct size, etc.), but gives error or when it looks like it installed everything(manually set MBR and don't use GPT/UEFI). After it looks like it completed installation without error, it won't boot from sata. So I think it didn't write anything to it.

The original OS is on a 4gb CF and I also have my own 4gb CF(don't want to destroy the data on the original). My own 4GB CF is tested, works fine.

PFsense runs fine on the CF, but I would like to install it on the ssd(faster, bigger, more functions, etc).

IJay-XTM5, how did you install it?

I think I am going to order IDC12 to VGA cable or make one myself and see if I can get into bios. Maybe there is an faulty setting there(legacy mode perhaps?). Or can I access bios over com-port?

stephenw10

The BIOS is password protected and I have not managed to remove it. Console redirect is not enabled by default either. But even after enabling it or hooking up VGA you can't enter setup.

What size SSD is it? Something unusual? Can you try a different drive?

You can full install to CF, which is what I did. Just be sure to remove the SWAP slice at install time and then move /var and /tmp to RAM drives after booting.

Can you install to the SSD in the laptop and then move it back?

Steve

iJay-XTM5

My M400 install was rather uneventful. I had a working SSD installation in an XTM525, which I tried transplanting into the M400 but wouldn't boot. Upon Steve's suggestion, I booted from a CF card in the M400 and installed to the 120 GB SSD. Next I removed the SSD and the box booted up just fine off the SSD.
I hooked up the VGA port to diagnose the original issue of not being able to boot off the SSD, no matter which port I used. BTW, the box only has SATA 2,3 and 4 connectors. SATA 1 connector is not populated atleast in my box. The VGA output is very useful in tinkering with the box.
I downloaded a copy of the user manual for Lanner's FW-7585 as the M400 appears to be a derivative with some items missing; connection to the VGA port is relatively straightforward once you have the manual, I ended up using jumper cables I had lying around.
I'm no expert but it looks like you may have a SATA controller issue if none of your SATA ports is able to boot. I would suggest verifying the SSD (looks like you already did), booting the box via CF - I used pfSense-CE-memstick-serial-2.4.3-RELEASE-amd64, and installing to the SSD. I had the SSD connected to SATA 4 for the install as it was the nearest port to the SSD but I did check and the box boots fine with the other ports as well.
If you're still not able to complete the install successfully, I would suggest booting with an image of freeDOS and running hardware tests to ensure your SATA controller is working.
I'm afraid I don't know of any but perhaps Steve might be able to point you in the right direction.
I hope to install an i3 at some point in my box as well for AES-NI so it's good to know a 4370T works.
Hope this helps

Testing

SSD is OCZ arc100-120gb and pfsense installs fine and works fine if I use my notebook.
When moving back to Firebox, doesn't boot.

So it seems I can't boot from sata at all, even with CF removed.

I ordered an old vga card, the older low profile ones have the same pinout for the vga connector as this board. So I ordered it for the cable with vga port, was cheaper than ordering jumpercables and vga port seperately ;).

Freedos needs vga port if I am correct, so I can do that next week. Vga card arrives saturday or monday.

Maybe the m500 has more restrictions in bios? How can I dump the bios to a rom and open it?
Or maybe the bios is set to legacy mode for sata instead of the other one(can't come up with the name now)?

ADDED: Did you try to reset CMOS? Does that remove password?

ADDED2: I noticed someone here had the same problem: https://forum.pfsense.org/index.php?topic=61799.0. He got it installed by disabling some features for the cpu. As you guys have the original CPU and I have got 2cores/4threads(and a bunch of extra features), maybe it's because the cpu has too many features. Still doesn't explain why a working installation won't boot… I will try to access bios when I have got the vga cable ;)

stephenw10

@Testing:

ADDED: Did you try to reset CMOS? Does that remove password?

Yes. No.

It's custom coded into the BIOS code somewhere which makes it difficult to impossible to remove.

The CPU option theory is interesting though I think most of that is disabled in the BIOS default settings anyway, speedstep, hyperthreading etc. Also it still boots the Nano image.

When you installed to the SSD in the laptop I assume you used the VGA installer? Did you enable the serial port? Did you complete the install using the laptop NIC as an interface? If it wasn't an igb NIC the SSD might be booting fine but stopping at the interfaces assign screen due to the mismatch and you dont see it because it's on the VGA console.

Steve

Testing

I installed with vga, and also it uses the laptop NIC. So you are right it isn't the igb0/igb1 I use on firebox for wan/lan.

Where can I enable serial port after vga-installation? And how can I configure it so it uses the igb0 and igb1 for wan/lan?

ADDED: found the serial setting. fresh install on the ssd, works fine in notebook. Put it in the firebox, no output on serial port. So looks like it just won't boot sata. I think when I have the vga port I can use windows live cd, create bios rom and try to tinker with that. Or maybe the vga output shows a message which describes how to fix it ;)

ADDED2: Is it possible to install an ami bios from ami itself? So without passwords and such? Or maybea bios from the FW-7585 mainboard?

ADDED3: Got it to boot. Sata2: nothing. Sata4: error with privileges or something. Sata3: boots. Strange, any explanations?

iJay-XTM5

Good deal, looks like you're finally on your way!

If you need to access the VGA, all you need are some $3 arduino jumper cables from ebay. Here's what my crappy setup looks like - not very elegant, but works! I was able to boot freedos and tinker a bit….

IMG_3290.JPG_thumb

IMG_3282.JPG_thumb

Testing

Yeah, I think my bios is setup for different devices on the sata ports. In the manual I saw that you need to select which kind of device is connected to which sata port. So it seems Sata4 is for HDD in a Firebox m500.

The complete videocard with the right vga port+cable was 8dollars including shipping. I will send a picture when I have it up and running ;)

iJay-XTM5

Hopefully the BIOS is setup to switch automatically to an external VGA when one is detected. The problem with the locked BIOS is you can't change any setting.
I was naive and actually called WatchGuard support expecting to get an unlocked version of the BIOS or the password to unlock it! :)

stephenw10

I'd be surprised if it cannot boot a legacy install though it might be locked out of doing so in the BIOS. You'd have to inspect the BIOS image to know for sure.

What options did you chose in the install process?

My own VGA hookup was even more basic. I connected only the green signal line and used some random header cables from an old PC. ;)

Steve

N1ck

Well, it seems only uefi will boot, nothing else.

And for my vga cable, forgot a few holidays here, so that will arrive tuesday. I am not using the vga card, only the vga cable that comes with it. It's a low profile card and those had the blue vga port above the rest(full profile), but in low profile you needed an extra steel plate next to the card and there you would mount the blue vga port. That's why on those cards the vga port is connected via a ribbon with 12pin(1NC) connector. Ordering header/arduino cables was an option, but it was cheaper to buy an entire graphics card which has the correct vga port with ribbon ;)

stephenw10

That's interesting. Yet legacy images boot fine from CF?

I don't see anything in the default BIOS settings that I can see in the image that might do that. However some stuff is not visible there.

Can we see a comparative output from the console command 'geom part list'?

For example from a Minnowboard Turbot which only boots UEFI:

[2.4.4-DEVELOPMENT][admin@4220.stevew.lan]/root: geom part list
Geom name: ada0
modified: false
state: OK
fwheads: 16
fwsectors: 63
last: 62533255
first: 40
entries: 152
scheme: GPT
Providers:
1\. Name: ada0p1
   Mediasize: 209715200 (200M)
   Sectorsize: 512
   Stripesize: 0
   Stripeoffset: 20480
   Mode: r0w0e0
   efimedia: HD(1,GPT,3da27220-1e32-11e8-8da9-0008a20bc486,0x28,0x64000)
   rawuuid: 3da27220-1e32-11e8-8da9-0008a20bc486
   rawtype: c12a7328-f81f-11d2-ba4b-00a0c93ec93b
   label: (null)
   length: 209715200
   offset: 20480
   type: efi
   index: 1
   end: 409639
   start: 40
2\. Name: ada0p2
   Mediasize: 29855055872 (28G)
   Sectorsize: 512
   Stripesize: 0
   Stripeoffset: 209735680
   Mode: r1w1e2
   efimedia: HD(2,GPT,3da318d6-1e32-11e8-8da9-0008a20bc486,0x64028,0x379c000)
   rawuuid: 3da318d6-1e32-11e8-8da9-0008a20bc486
   rawtype: 516e7cb6-6ecf-11d6-8ff8-00022d09712b
   label: (null)
   length: 29855055872
   offset: 209735680
   type: freebsd-ufs
   index: 2
   end: 58720295
   start: 409640
3\. Name: ada0p3
   Mediasize: 1601175552 (1.5G)
   Sectorsize: 512
   Stripesize: 0
   Stripeoffset: 20480
   Mode: r1w1e1
   efimedia: HD(3,GPT,3da43efe-1e32-11e8-8da9-0008a20bc486,0x3800028,0x2fb800)
   rawuuid: 3da43efe-1e32-11e8-8da9-0008a20bc486
   rawtype: 516e7cb5-6ecf-11d6-8ff8-00022d09712b
   label: (null)
   length: 1601175552
   offset: 30064791552
   type: freebsd-swap
   index: 3
   end: 61847591
   start: 58720296
Consumers:
1\. Name: ada0
   Mediasize: 32017047552 (30G)
   Sectorsize: 512
   Mode: r2w2e5

Any 2.4.X should be able to create that. You do have to choose efi rather than freebsd-boot though.

Steve

N1ck

I will install a CF image(nanobsd) and will try the command. Or is there a faster way to use the command? Now I have install image on my CF and unfortunately only have 1 CF.
I don't think the images are legacy images, my image has got an efi-partition and is a GPT not MDR.

stephenw10

The installer image has both efi and freebsd-boot partitions so it should boot either.

In the MBT which only boots efi the installer only adds en efi image. I'm pretty sure I didn't do anything special there. I suspect it adds the partion type depending on how the installer booted. Trying to confirm that.

So if you installed to a HD in an efi laptop it will probably work.

Steve