IPv6 with two or more LAN-side interfaces

Bob.Dig

@jimp Ok, tried them now, not working.

JKnott

@Bob-Dig said in IPv6 with two or more LAN-side interfaces:

So is there any option left with that ISP-IPv6 or no?

You could try mentioning what ISP that is. There might be someone here who has experience with them.

Bob.Dig

@JKnott Na, as I was mentioning they are doing 1:1 CG-NAT (IPv4) nobody could believe that here.
I am pretty sure they only do /64, so what are my options?

JKnott

@Bob-Dig

Well, it's hard to know what to believe, when you won't mention who the ISP is. If all you get is a single /64, then you can't do much, as both SLAAC and DHCPv6 require a full /64 to work properly. One option would be to use he.net for a 6in4 tunnel.
They provide a /48.

Bob.Dig

Interesting, never thought something like that with all the IPv6-addresses we got, little that I know.
The ISP is
https://www.pyur.com/

Thanks @ all

Bob.Dig

@JKnott said in IPv6 with two or more LAN-side interfaces:

Or, if you're handy with Packet Capture and Wireshark, you can see what is provided. The prefix size and address are provided in both the Advertise XID and Reply XID lines.

Could you help me with that? I have downloaded Wireshark and also captured something and then loaded it in Wireshark.

But what should I capture in the first place and how to look for it in Wireshark would be much appreciated.

JKnott

@Bob-Dig

To capture with Wireshark, you need some way to insert a computer running it between the modem and the pfSense computer. This is can be done with a managed switch, configured for port mirroring. Failing that, you can use the Packet Capture that's built in to pfSense. You can then capture the packets when you disconnect/reconnect the WAN port. You can then download the capture to view in Wireshark. If you use a managed switch, you can capture everything from power up, instead of just disconnecting the WAN port. You want to filter on DHCPv6, which is port 546 or 547. You can use either. That should leave you with the XID packets, which you can then open and find the info.

Bob.Dig

@JKnott So is that it? Or is it not?

Bob.Dig

@JKnott Just to be sure, this is what my ISP is giving out or what I asked for? I want to be absolute sure about this once and for all.

JKnott

@Bob-Dig

I see your prefix length is 64, which means you get a single /64. My length is 56, which leaves room for 256 /64s.

Can your ISP provide a better prefix? As I mentoned, I have a /56, but other ISPs provide a /60 for 16 /64s or a /48, for 65536.

Bob.Dig

@JKnott Thank you.
No, as far I can tell, my ISP is not changing that. Could you call comcast and ask for a larger prefix? Sure you could, but it would took ages to get someone on the phone who is even capable of understanding it. I am almost not.

Thanks again and I replaced the picture.

JKnott

@Bob-Dig said in IPv6 with two or more LAN-side interfaces:

No, as far I can tell, my ISP is not changing that.

Have you even tried? Handing out a single /64 has to be the ultimate in stingy. There are enough /48s to give well over 4000 of them to every single person on earth and that's with only 1/8 the IPv6 address space allocated to Global Unique Addresses.

BTW, he.net will give, for free, a /48. Prior to my ISP (Rogers) offering IPv6, I used a tunnel broker who gave me a /56 for free.

Bob.Dig

@JKnott Most home users will not notice it anyway. I can live with it but I wanted to know it for sure.

JKnott

@Bob-Dig

Still, it wouldn't hurt to ask.

Bob.Dig

@JKnott It would hurt me. Had enough problems with my isp in the last years and know some thing or two how they operate.

JKnott

@Bob-Dig

Maybe you should get a different ISP then.

johnpoz

You understand it would take you all of a couple of minutes to get everything you want to do up and running with a FREE /48 from HE.. You can do your statics on and not have to worry about any changes in the prefix... You can even take the same /48 with you if you change ISPs

You also can set PTRs on this /48 space if you have any need for that, etc.

There really is little reason to have to "deal" with lack luster and shitty isps when it comes to doing ipv6.. Giving out 1 /64 is just plain stupid.. But when the vast majority of their users are using their device, and only have 1 flat network behind - why not just do it that way, etc..

So find an isp that does what you want, or just run a tunnel.. It really is a couple of minutes to setup.

Bob.Dig

@johnpoz Is there a noob friendly tutorial for HE around here?
For my noob-E-Mail-Server it would be nice to have PTR.
Can I have two ore more IPs with each there own PTR for one machine/host? So that every Service got its own IP/PTR, even when it is on the same machine as another Service?

johnpoz

You can setup PTRs for any of your IPv6 addresses.. I have a few setup

here is the pfsense docs
https://docs.netgate.com/pfsense/en/latest/interfaces/using-ipv6-with-a-tunnel-broker.html

Haven't run through it years... But I would assume its current and ready to go from a quick look over it looks fine..

I don't run smtp on it, I know a few years back they had some issues with abuse of users sending spam, etc. etc. And you had to enable it if you were sage, and now that is even gone - and you might have to contact them to enable 25.. Guess I could do a simple test to see if 25 is open in and out over the IPv6, etc.. But just be aware that might be something you will have to contact them about.

edit: did a simple test of outbound and that is open

telnet -6 2607:f8b0:4001:c03::1a 25
Trying 2607:f8b0:4001:c03::1a...
Connected to 2607:f8b0:4001:c03::1a.
Escape character is '^]'.
220 mx.google.com ESMTP e24si5820214ioh.159 - gsmtp

So I don't see why outbound would be open without inbound.. I haven't kept up with all the stuff on their forums and such for years and years since its just rock solid and no need.. Only time I was on there frequentlly was years ago like early 2011 or something when got sage via their free certification test.. You can get a FREE tshirt ;) I still sport mine now and then..

Bob.Dig

@johnpoz said in IPv6 with two or more LAN-side interfaces:

You can setup PTRs for any of your IPv6 addresses.. I have a few setup

Where can I do that? I got a he tunnel just now but can't find that option.