CoDel rewriting ICMP/UDP traceroute traffic
-
This post is deleted! -
@coldfire7 Only thing to do is to make a rule having ICMP traffic avoid fq-codel. It's not a new issue and has been discussed more times than i can count in the mile long fq-codel thread.
But if you made the rule according to the guide you linked to, then create a new floating rule above it and set the following:
Action : pass
Quick : checked
Interface : WAN
Direction : Out
Protocol : ICMP
Gateway : WAN Gateway -
Will it be fixed in future releases? I used CoDel/FQ_CODEL with OpenWRT never faced this issue before.
-
Problem doesn't exist if you make floating rule on your LAN/VLAN in. I wrote more here. It won't work for traffic originating from pfsense router, but it shouldn't be a problem. You have to make sure that floating rule is properly set so your local LAN traffic is not limited.
-
@coldfire7 The one who implemented fq-codel into FreeBSD also chimed in on various subjects in the fq-codel thread and should be aware of it. But since it is very low priority and that rule basically fixes it i highly doubt it. I am sure most are more interested in getting fq-cake implemented.
-
@bobbenheim Cake implementation would be nice!
