Why two binat lines for npt?
hcoin last edited by
In experimenting with Npt, PFsense generates two binat rules.
binat on <wan interface="">from <local v6="" prefix="">to any -> <global v6="" prefix="">Which, as far as I can tell from the docs, means "set up a 1-1 mapping so outbound from private source gets the public prefix as source, and inbound from public with public prefix as dest gets the private prefix as dest before filtering and routing." This is (I think) a stateless procedure.
But then pf creates another rule:
binat on <wan interface="">from any to <global prefix="">-> <private prefix="">Which I think means 'anything outbound with source in the global prefix gets source mapped to the private prefix (where exactly nobody can do anything with it..), and anything inbound with dest using the private prefix gets forwarded to dest mapped to the global prefix'. But as doing that makes little sense to me… I must have some category error in understanding these things.
What is the second binat rule meant to accomplish? Could someone take me through:
a: Kernel app generates a packet with <private prefix="">outbound on npt interface, what does downstream router see as the prefix? How do the two rules apply?
b: A packet comes in on <lan>with <private prefix="">policy routed to be outbound on npt interface, what down downstream router see as the prefix? Which rules do that?
c: What is the second rule supposed to enable?</private></lan></private></private></global></wan></global></local></wan>