IP based Routing & VPN Multi-gateway Setup

joelones

I'm routing all traffic for an internal IP through a VPN gateway, however, I also have a service on that IP that's getting a 403 forbidden when hitting a specific URL/IP on the internet. Is there an easy way to selectively route traffic through another gateway for that one destination IP ? I already have one working rule on the LAN interface to route all traffic through the VPN gateway, when adding a second rule just above that one, for the source internal IP, destination host and gateway (all flags set, sloppy state), the wget (command which I use to test) times out instead of giving me 403?

I see the TCP:S being passed through the firewall, never do I see the SYNACK.

I tried https://doc.pfsense.org/index.php/Asymmetric_Routing_and_Firewall_Rules as well, did not help.

- Firewall Aliases
   - IP > Add - 
      Properties
               Name = 
               Description = 
               Type = Host(s)

      Host(s)
               IP or FQDN = (Domain IP Address)
               Description= 

- Firewall Rules 
   - Lan > Add 
            (Leave everything else as normal except Destination)
            Destination = 
                                 (Single host or Aliases)  /  (Aliases name)

          - Advanced Options 

             - Gateway  ( Chose WAN interface)

Thoughts?