Playing with fq_codel in 2.4

[thiasaef]

@mind12 it definitely works if I add the -I flag to the traceroute command, but the 1st floating rule (policy routing traceroute workaround) seems to have nothing to do with it.

I logged the outgoing traceroute traffic both with and without the -I flag using Wireshark, but I could not find any packets of the ICMP subtype: Traceroute.

I would be glad if someone with more expertise than us would chime in on this.

[mind12]

@thiasaef I replied to this I'm sorry, not the traceroute part

"PS: Could someone explain me why fq_codel still works in both directions when I disable the 3rd floating rule (WAN-In FQ-CoDel queue)."

[thiasaef]

@mind12 if I disable the 3rd floating rule, reset the firewall state table and then run the waveform bufferbloat test, I get the following result: https://www.waveform.com/tools/bufferbloat?test-id=9cced6ab-e6a9-48b9-a7a5-c562dc7df528, my limiter is set to (96, 36).

[tomashk]

@thiasaef

I believe you need third rule (WAN in) only if somebody initialize connection from "internet" and connects to your WAN (so you also need some other rule to allow connection from "internet" to your WAN)

Your WAN out rule makes almost all work because it is working with traffic from your LAN going to internet and all responses (matching response is like the same traffic as your WAN out).

Because of that for fq_codel I have only one rule (but I also use different approach - when you have rule on "LAN in" there is no problem with ping and traceroute)

I hope it makes sense and I'm not wrong :)

[thiasaef]

Flent is amazing - simple yet incredibly powerful! The result after optimizing my VVDSL line:

Before:


https://www.waveform.com/tools/bufferbloat?test-id=9bee8331-5e7f-4503-a74d-d146ab511ab9

rrul-2021-05-07T200244.228034.vvdsl_native.flent.gz

After:


https://www.waveform.com/tools/bufferbloat?test-id=1ccd779a-c3f3-4b0f-be46-22638b446d96

rrul-2021-05-07T200823.580873.vvdsl_fq_codel.flent.gz

[sikita]

Hi, what about "hn ALTQ support" setting? Is it recommended enabled or disabled in 2.5.1?

[thiasaef]

Is there a recommended strategy for when the WAN speed fluctuates significantly, such as with a cellular connection (e.g., LTE)?

[robnitro]

@thiasaef
Not that I know of. If you can change the settings via a script, perhaps you can run a loop that runs a ping and when its high, drops the speed and checks again

Gargoyle router which is a version of openwrt does it well though, auto speed adjust.

[user7364]

Hi guys,

just want to ask how to add a 1mbit guarantee to a voice vlan on the limiter? I am a bit scared that voip does not work if someone in the network max out upload/download ... i already use QoS as best i can, but i think reserved bandwith for the vlan is maybe safer?

[Zeny001]

@robnitro That sounds really good.