PfSense not showing up in tracert for Dual WAN + CARP

[jasonlitka]

I'm having an issue where my new pfSense boxes are not showing up in tracerts.  A tracert shows that the data goes straight from my machine to my first WAN hop.  I am able to ping the LAN CARP interface just fine.

My config has two boxes with Dual WAN and a Sync interface for CARP.  Thoughts?

[jasonlitka]

More info:  The change that is doing it is when I switch the default LAN -> Any firewall rule from the default gateway to the "WAN1 -> WAN2 Failover".