default route no longer working

SpaceBass

Hey folks - I've been working on a project and the result is that I've learned a lot...and also seem to have broken something.

original goals

create a SSL OpenVPN connection for an 'on demand' iOS profile
2.A. get a client OpenVPN to TorGuard working to route some traffic out through VPN
2.B. route traffic from those on-demand clients out through TorGuard and deny them access to any internal network

So here's what I did

got the on-demand server and client working, connects fine
learned a lot about aliases and rules and got it working to allow outbound to WAN but block to all internal network (with a few pin holes)
finally got TorGuard working... something I've been tinkering with for months.
turned on hybrid NAT

here's what happened
Now, traffic cannot route out of my LAN, other internal networks, or 'more trusted' OpenVPN connections without me specifying a gateway in the advanced settings in firewall rules. The default option doesn't work.

The result is that, for instance, my trusted Road Warrior OpenVPN request a gateway to route traffic out. But when I set that gateway, I cannot reach my LAN.

My question is...
My perception is that adding the three (really the first) TorGuard VPN client broke something in my routes. I tried deleting them all and re-creating the clients and the interfaces in case something was just twisted in the config. No dice.

Is correct to assume that I should be able to use the default rout settings in most rules and the system will route things appropriately over the selected default (wan) route...then only where I explicitly want to route over TorGuard I can set those settings in a specific rule.

Here's my gateways:

alt text

here's my outbound NAT
alt text

here are my LAN rules
alt text

and my OpenVPN rules (for trusted VPNs)
alt text

SpaceBass

FWIW I have “don’t pull routes” set for the TorGard OVPN client connections

Derelict

If you are not pulling routes then you have to policy route to the VPNs. I don't see anything there that does that.