CARP limiters and Traffic Shaping



  • Greetings to all.
    I don't know if this is known but here is what happens:

    1. Master pfsense: Create a simple limiter 10 Mbit
    2. Backup pfsense: Limiter 10 Mbit is also created
    3. Master pfsense: Create a simple limiter 20 Mbit
    4. Backup pfsense: Limiter 20 Mbit is also created
    5. Master pfsense: Delete the 10 Mbit limiter
    6. Backup pfsense: Limiter 10 Mbit is also deleted
    7. Master pfsense: Delete the 20 Mbit limiter
    8. Backup pfsense: Limiter 20 Mbit is NOT deleted and remains there active
    9. Master pfsense: Create a simple limiter 30 Mbit
    10. Backup pfsense: Limiter 20 Mbit is now deleted and 30 Mbit is created

    Seems if you delete the last entry on the list it is not pushed correctly.

    Same thing happens if you create a wizard. If you delete the shaper it's not synced to the Backup Pfsense.

    Any thoughts?


  • Rebel Alliance Developer Netgate

    I was able to reproduce both of those bugs. We've hit similar things in the past.

    I created new issues for them:
    Limiters: https://redmine.pfsense.org/issues/9468
    ALTQ Shaper: https://redmine.pfsense.org/issues/9469


Log in to reply