Bug in Broadcom bnxt driver in combination with VLANs

[stephenw10]

Since it looks like that's in VLAN filtering in the driver you could try disabling VLAN hardware off loading on the NIC.

[tmoehle]

@stephenw10
Thank you for that suggestion. The idea was promising, but unfortunately not successful. I tried:

ifconfig bnxt0 -vlanhwtag -vlanhwfilter -vlanhwtso
ifconfig bnxt1 -vlanhwtag -vlanhwfilter -vlanhwtso

But the errors remain :(

[slu]

I'm also interested in a workaround, we plan to use the Broadcom BCM57416 with VLANs.

[stephenw10]

Mmm, worth trying but I did expect to see that on the FreeBSD bug report.

In he short term going back to 2.6 may be the only option.

[Delegator5042]

@stephenw10
Can you point me where to look if I want to try and recompile this for myself?
I'm a beginner but I would like to try to get my NIC to work with more than 1 VLAN

[stephenw10]

As far as I can see there is no validated patch for this yet: https://bugs.freebsd.org/bugzilla/show_bug.cgi?id=269133#c31

[Delegator5042]

@stephenw10
A bummer, but can't be helped! I'll have to find other uses for the NIC in the meantime.
Thanks for the quick response!

[Delegator5042]

@tmoehle Did going back to 2.6 make the VLANs functional?
I tried it for a bit and didn't get anywhere (didn't get the re-allocate error but the interface didn't forward any traffic)
Going back to 2.6 permanently also seems cumbersome since I could not install packages from the package manager until I update to 2.7 again.

[stephenw10]

You can install packages, just set the repo branch to 2.6 (deprecated).

[tmoehle]

@Delegator5042
I did a clean install for pfsense 2.6 and restored the old configuration backup. That went perfectly smooth. After that, as @stephenw10 already suggested, I went to System > Update and changed the desired branch to 2.6, so I could download packages again.

[Delegator5042]

@tmoehle
Encouraging to hear! I will give it a(nother) proper go then.
Silly me just read an old forum posts about the packages requiring an update, which I somehow can't find anymore so I probably didn't read something correct when I was looking for a place to download 2.6

[Delegator5042]

@tmoehle Sorry for prying a lot, but do the VLANs on your NIC really work?
I installed 2.6 and the NIC works without VLANs.
When I create a VLAN and assign it to an interface, No traffic gets through (oddly enough the DHCP does work)
When I set a different network port (non bnxt) with the same VLAN to the same configured interface, it all works (albeit I have to reload firewall rules first).

I am hoping that I am doing something wrong, since DHCP somehow still works on the VLAN with bnxt, but I don't see any issues with the gateway and the firewall rule permits the traffic.

[tmoehle]

@Delegator5042 My VLANs are working perfectly fine, yes. If your DHCP is working within those VLANs and pfsense is your only DHCP server, then chances are you overlook something.

[stephenw10]

This should now be fixed in the next 23.09 snapshots if anyone can test that.

Steve

[tmoehle]

@stephenw10 Will it only go into 23.09 or will there also be an update for CE?

[stephenw10]

It's fixed upstream in FreeBSD so it will be pulled into new CE builds.

[chinraam]

@stephenw10 Hi. With pfsense version 2.7.0 im still facing this issue.

Will it get resolved in 2.7.2 or should i downgrade?

[chinraam]

@stephenw10

[stephenw10]

Yes that patch is in 2.7.2: https://github.com/pfsense/FreeBSD-src/commit/21d49ce6efe3883beef6d5456a3bda4194028b01

[chinraam]

@stephenw10 Thank You. Let me try the same.