Traffic shaping without the wizard?
-
Actually trafficshaping is quite hard to setup and to understand. This even becomes harder when making multi-interface-shapings. Atm we only support what the wizard creates and shaping between 2 interfaces. There are some limitations in the gui when creating custom rules (like you can't attach a queue to another queue that is attached to the parent queue) though in general setting a multi interface scenario up might be possible if done correctly. You really have to play around with it. I suggest starting with a wizard created ruleset and modifying this first. Then try to add more queues and rules but be prepared to get rule-errors if you set it up incorrectly.
-
Actually trafficshaping is quite hard to setup and to understand.
So I've noticed ;-)
Given that this sounds a bit "unofficial" I'll have a play on the production firewall's twin and report back.
Cheers,
Steff
-
Hi
I have a similiar situation as "Steff". Currently i'm using m0n0wall with 3 interfaces and the pptp Server. On WAN interface i do shape traffic, but the config is pretty simple, as i have just a few protocols which i actually configure specially, the rest is per host. On the Wireless Interface i only distinguish between pptp and the rest.
Now i'm considering to get a second WAN connection as failover because my primary one isn't very reliable. But m0n0wall doesn't support multiple WAN connections. This brings me to pfsense. But if i can't achieve my traffic shaper scenario, pfsense is no option for me.
Is it not possible to deactivate the wizard?
(I know it has to be possible, but why don't you tell people how? You don't need to provide support for "self-made" configurations)Greetings
TealC -
altq trafficshaping is not that easy like dummynet. If you make a single mistake it won't load at all. Actually you can make custom rules but you need to run the wizard once to setup some basics. After that if you visit the trafficshaper you will have rules and queues. You can modify them, add or delete them but now you are on unsupported territory. You'll see what I mean once you try to create your custom ruleset. Good luck.
-
Hi
I have a similiar situation as "Steff". Currently i'm using m0n0wall with 3 interfaces and the pptp Server. On WAN interface i do shape traffic, but the config is pretty simple, as i have just a few protocols which i actually configure specially, the rest is per host. On the Wireless Interface i only distinguish between pptp and the rest.
Now i'm considering to get a second WAN connection as failover because my primary one isn't very reliable. But m0n0wall doesn't support multiple WAN connections. This brings me to pfsense. But if i can't achieve my traffic shaper scenario, pfsense is no option for me.
Is it not possible to deactivate the wizard?
(I know it has to be possible, but why don't you tell people how? You don't need to provide support for "self-made" configurations)Greetings
TealCMult-wan traffic shaping is possible although unsupported, being done right now with two 5 meg dsl's
-
Mult-wan traffic shaping is possible although unsupported, we are doing it right now with two 5 meg dsl's
As Borat would say, NNICE!
Do you mind sharing this config? You can export it under Diagnostics -> Backup
Select the traffic shaping option and only download that portion of the configuration.
Then simply search and replace any external IP addresses that you may have and change descriptions if they are sensitive ;)
-
Justinw. I would really like see who you did this. I tried a lot of combination but have failed to get it working. Pleas !!
-
Sorry, finals week, I'll post the conf when I have a chance to get ahold of it…
-
Well I'm out…bad news is that traffic shaper is running but the traffic isn't being classified as correctly but its not crashing. I'm going to keep working with it and I will post when I get it. Don't I feel like a jerk...
-
do not crosspost that is not helping !!