Ftp passiv mode problem with FW Rules
-
yep - seeing this on Apr 5 20:35:18 build with pasv to external 3rd party ftp servers
seperately
active does not work for me either - not sure if its because of double nat [ lan->pfsnse->adsl_router(s) ] or just allowing huge fw inbound ports on wan[ from 8.1 updater run on 8.0 box - still says 8.0 ??? is this right ??? ]
-
I've been running an old alpha for at least 6 months. When was the last build that worked for you guys?
I wonder if this change is implicit:
http://redmine.pfsense.org/repositories/revision/3/53e2d23469c707bf7d66ad680a0b1c422f2e6548
-
I think you probably meant complicit, not implicit :)
-
Perhaps but in either case downgrading to 2.0-BETA1-20100331-1228 looks to have resolved this issue for me.
Does anyone care to file a bug report?
-
There is something broken in the FTP proxy since changes last week. Ermal is on vacation this week, he'll fix when he's back next week.
-
On snap 20100409-1808 whenever I try to start an FTP transaction I get a panic. For the record, it may be a conflict with OpenVPN since I'm shunting all data down an OPVN tunnel rather than the WAN…
-
Try newer snaps
-
Seems to be working again on "2.0-BETA1 built on Tue Apr 13 19:26:36 EDT 2010" snapshot, tested both active and passive mode. I didn't test with restrictive outbound rules on LAN.
Thanks Ermal :)
-
Hi guys, I have always problems with the passive, can I ask for some HowTo to pf2.0 or advice set it properly
EDITED
OK it's working without any rules in FW … SNAP from 13th
-
I still have a problem on "2.0-BETA1 built on Wed Apr 14 19:40:01 EDT 2010". Whenever an FTP transaction starts, it's OpenVPN that crashes.
This pf is setup to route through one of 7 OVPN instances…
-
can you please do a 'bt' at that prompt.
Please send me your pf.conf ruleset(mask any addresses that you need to). -
if i understand correctly, passive ftp should now work out of the box.
In my case, it doesn't.
I tried downgrading to 04/13 snap but same thing. Active ftp works, but passive doesn't.Any hints/ideas to what i might be setting wrong?
-
passive ftp works on my alix running 1st may nanobsd snaps
-
Snap from May 1 works.
Thank god! (On my network i'm heavily dependent on ftp)Thanks for the info xbipin