HFSC not assigning bandwidth properly

[pirron]

My HFSC is not assingning bandwidth properly. I will show my set up in screen shots.

The point is that even tho I have only 1% of bandwidth from qLANRoot assigned to p2p traffic (which goes to a proper queue btw) - no real time traffic given and total bandwidth limited to 95% - and 60% assigned to a qOthersH which is http (including youtube ofcourse) when the p2p start onsuming it's 95% allowance once the http traffic becomes active it does not take more than 300-500 Kbps (youtube). However when p2p is not active onca I start launching video from youtube the traffic graph for qOthersH jumps to 4Mbps inicially and slowly drops to 1Mbps and a bit lower further on.

Here are some screens from my configuration:


[pirron]

Two more screens:

I was thinking maybe the order of the queues from top to the bottom has an effect on how they are calculated?
Would it be a good idea to move queues with the highest priority to the top of the table?

[Alan87i]

I have played with adding additional penalty queues with the p2p queue in place . All my penalty queues are before the p2p queue . The rules are set up this way as well.
As far as I can tell the rules page is the place to set the order . After I ran the wizard all the p2p rules were at the bottom of the list with catch all rule at the end. Seems to work fine on this end.

[pirron]

Well I'm quite fresh after the wizard and in the Rules tab all qOthersH are higher then the qp2pDown or qp2pUp so I guess we have different results with similar setup  :-[